The Yankees don’t have the luxury of pretending the Ryan McMahon thing is working. After a season and a half in pinstripes, the bat has sunk to a level that no amount of steady defense can really cover anymore. His .208/.274/.344 line over 119 games this season tells the story, and it’s a rough one: he’s struggled against righties, he’s been even less effective against lefties, and the glove no longer carries enough weight to make up the difference.
That’s why the conversation has already shifted past this season and into the winter ahead. If the Yankees are serious about moving on, the real fun starts when you look out toward 2027 and start imagining who could fill the hole. The list isn’t overflowing with easy answers, but there are a few names worth dreaming on.
Rafael Devers is the loudest swing of the bunch. He’s been floated as a trade target for New York since before the deadline, and the fit would be a major philosophical shift.
The defense concerns that helped sour things between Devers and the Red Sox are still part of the package, and since landing in San Francisco, he’s mostly been used at first base and designated hitter. Still, there’s an argument that George Lombard Jr.’s athleticism and defensive upside could soften that problem.
The bat is the real draw. Devers hit 38 homers this year, and even his slow first half would have been a massive upgrade over anything McMahon has given the Yankees.
There are complications, though. He’s coming off core muscle surgery, so his Opening Day status is in question, and New York would likely have to absorb most of the nearly $200 million left on his deal.
Even so, the offensive payoff would be obvious, and the bonus of turning him loose on Boston would be hard to ignore.
Isaac Paredes is another trade name that fits the Yankees’ search. The 27-year-old has been on their radar for a while, and this winter could be the moment when things finally line up. The Astros don’t make life easy for New York, but Houston’s situation could force their hand.
They stumbled out of the gate, are locked in a battle with the Texas Rangers for the AL West, and the loser of that race could wind up missing the postseason entirely for a second straight year. On top of that, they fired general manager Dana Brown this summer, so change is already in motion.
Paredes has been in trade speculation before because Houston’s infield was crowded, and even though Carlos Correa’s injury cleared some space in 2026, he’ll be back next year and is under contract through at least 2028, with a chance to extend that even further through vesting options. Christian Walker is still there for another season, Jose Altuve isn’t moving, and Houston needs pitching more than another bat.
An Elmer Rodriguez-led package might be enough to get their attention.
Bo Bichette is the kind of option that could sneak up on people. His overall numbers have taken a hit because of that miserable start in Queens, but since June 1 he’s hit .291/.335/.440. There’s also a case to be made that a fresh start away from the Mets’ mess could help him even more.
He’d give the Yankees something they could use: a contact-oriented bat and a right-handed presence in the lineup. For a while, it looked like he was headed toward opting into his contract, but now it sounds more like a 50-50 call on whether he tests free agency again this winter. If he gets there, New York should absolutely be in the mix.
The wildest swing is Zach Neto, but it’s not as far-fetched as it sounds. Neto came up in trade rumors at the deadline, and Angels insider Jeff Fletcher of the OC Register reported that Los Angeles is expected to shop him again this offseason. The Red Sox and Rays were both said to be interested, which tells you the market will be active if he becomes available.
Neto is a shortstop, but his range at the position is considered a weak spot. What he does bring is a big arm, with his throwing power grading in the 85th percentile per Baseball Savant, and that could make a move to third base a real possibility. He also just launched his 25th home run over the Green Monster, another reminder of the kind of impact he can make.
The obstacle is the price. Neto is the rare player who can be viewed as a perennial 30-30 type and still not hit free agency until 2030, so he won’t come cheap.
For New York, the deal would only make sense if Lombard Jr. stays put; otherwise, it’s just swapping one shortstop for another. That may be easier said than done, especially with Los Angeles having already added top prospect Arjun Nimmala from the Blue Jays for Jose Soriano, and the soon-to-be 21-year-old is tearing up Double-A.
Of the four, Neto is the longest shot. But if the Yankees want a way to stretch their competitive window deep into Aaron Judge’s decline, he’s the kind of player who makes that conversation worth having. A future built around Neto, Lombard Jr., Spencer Jones, Ben Rice, and Cam Schlittler would give them a path forward without tearing everything down first.
In Other News...
Yankees Playoff Rotation Rumor Suddenly Feels A Lot More Real
With the AL Wild Card Series approaching, the Yankees are still sorting out how they want to open the round, and a new injury development on the other side has only added to the intrigue. Willson Contreras is reportedly doubtful because of a hand injury that has left him with significant inflammation, and while there is no fracture, his availability remains in question as the series nears.
Max Fried has surfaced as a possible Game 1 choice for New York, a move that would give the Yankees a left-handed look if Contreras is unavailable. It is still only a rumor at this point, not an official decision, but it has made the rotation chatter feel much more real with the postseason about to begin. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Doubleheader Moves Just Raised A Bigger Playoff Question
Brendan Becks latest turn in the Yankees rotation picture did not go as planned, and the club moved quickly after his start in Game 1 of the doubleheader. The rookie was charged with seven runs over five innings in a loss, then was optioned back to the minors with an 0-2 record and a 9.95 ERA in four games, a reminder of how thin the margin can be when a team is trying to patch together innings this late in the season.
In his place, the Yankees promoted Alexander Cornielle, a Triple-A arm who has not yet appeared in the majors, while Fernando Cruz was transferred to the 60-day injured list. It leaves New York juggling both the present and the near future, and it also raises a larger question about how much depth is really left to lean on if the rotation keeps getting tested. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Could Give Carlos Rodon A Surprising Postseason Role
The Yankees are already weighing a few October wrinkles, and Carlos Rodn might be one of the biggest. With the wild-card series limited to a three-starter format, Aaron Boone acknowledged that one of his best starters could be pushed into a bullpen role to help maximize his impact in a short series, a move that would be more about fit than routine.
Rodn has been paid to start, and the Yankees still view him that way, but the postseason often rewrites the usual script. Using him in relief would keep his arm in play for the wild-card round while also preserving the option of sending him back to the mound if the Yankees advance to a division series matchup with the Rays, a balancing act that could shape how Boone lines up the staff. [Read more 🡒]