Sonny Gray Just Set A Pitching Market Yankees Fans Should Watch

In a surprising move that has reshaped the pitching market, Sonny Gray has left the Red Sox for the Twins in a significant and unexpected deal.

Sonny Gray’s move to Minnesota has turned into one of the louder reminders that the market is already behaving like the future matters.

Gray, the former Yankee who spent last winter leaning hard into Boston and then just as quickly left it behind, signed a two-year, $55 million deal with the Twins that includes an opt out after Year 1. That’s a hefty commitment for a pitcher who could be back on the market after one season - and even more striking in a baseball world where people are already pricing in uncertainty around 2027.

The timing only adds to the weirdness. Gray’s exit from Boston felt inevitable after he was pulled early for Erik Miller in Game 2 of the Wild Card Series. He tried to soften the landing with some lukewarm praise for the Red Sox on the way out, but the simplest read was the right one: he was gone fast.

And he was gone fast in a way that changes the conversation around other pitchers, too.

Dustin May’s contract already looked like a strange benchmark after he made more than $50 million across three seasons in Chicago despite uneven production that left him largely minimized during the Brewers’ World Series run. Gray’s deal pushes the market into even stranger territory. He just posted an 18-5 record with a 2.72 ERA in Boston, finished fifth in the Cy Young race, and now may make about $28 million for one year before deciding again whether he wants to keep going.

That kind of number matters when clubs start trying to pin down what arms are worth. Will Warren sits somewhere between those two examples, and the question is how teams value him now. At this point, the argument is that he should be treated like an $18-20M AAV pitcher.

The longer this drags out, the more valuable the chip becomes.

For the Yankees, the update is simple enough: Gray is on the other side again.

In Other News...

Yankees Third Base Search Just Took A Surprising Turn

The Yankees have spent the offseason looking for ways to upgrade both the infield and the bullpen, and the latest twist in that search has them tied to a player who would have seemed untouchable not long ago. Gunnar Henderson, once viewed as one of the brightest young pieces in Baltimore, has seen his offense slip over the past two seasons, enough for the Orioles to at least weigh whether a trade makes sense.

For New York, the appeal is obvious: Henderson could deepen the lineup and give the club another impact bat, while also creating a possible solution at third base. The fit would allow the Yankees to keep George Lombard Jr. at shortstop, but the bigger question is whether a division rival would actually be willing to move a player with Hendersons pedigree, and what it would take to pry him loose. [Read more 🡒]

Yankees Bullpen Rebuild Just Put One Intriguing Target In Play

The Yankees are still sorting through the bullpen after a season that exposed how much work the relief corps needs, and one name now in the mix is Adrin Morejon. The Padres left-hander declined San Diegos one-year qualifying offer, a clear sign he is aiming for a multi-year deal on the open market, and New York has already shown interest as it looks to rebuild that part of the roster.

Morejon fits the kind of arm the Yankees have been trying to line up: a reliever with upside who could help stabilize the middle innings if the market breaks right. The club also took a smaller but important step by re-signing Devin Bednar to a one-year deal, keeping a key bullpen piece in place for 2027 while the front office continues to chase bigger answers. [Read more 🡒]

Yankees Reunion With Jonathan Loaisiga Just Hit A Serious Snag

Jonathan Loaisigas return to the Yankees has moved from a familiar reunion idea to a real negotiation, and the gap is already clear. The right-hander, who pitched for the Arizona Diamondbacks in 2026, has a formal one-year offer from New York on the table, giving the club a straightforward path to bring back a pitcher it knows well.

Loaisiga, though, is looking much further down the road, seeking a three-year deal in the $18 million to $20 million range. Interest has surfaced from the Dodgers, Mets and Phillies, but none of those clubs has stepped in with an offer yet, leaving the Yankees to decide whether to stretch their comfort zone or risk watching the talks drift into a longer standoff. [Read more 🡒]