Ryan McMahon spent months giving Yankees fans exactly the kind of fuel they hate to argue about: a big-name trade deadline pickup who wasn’t doing enough at the plate. Now, though, the picture looks a lot different. The bat has come around, the defense is still there, and suddenly the deal is looking less like a mistake and more like a useful piece of business.
That wasn’t how it felt for much of McMahon’s first stretch in New York. He arrived at last year’s deadline and did little with the bat, even if he was steady enough in October.
In 54 games, he hit .208 with a .641 OPS and a 79 OPS+, but his glove kept him afloat. He still finished with 1.1 WAR thanks to his work at third base, though the strikeout rate - over 30% - gave critics plenty to lean on.
Then 2026 got off to a rough start. McMahon was in the middle of changing his batting stance, and the early results were ugly.
His defense slipped some too. He committed four errors in his first 32 games and didn’t get his average above .200 until the first week of May.
That was around the time Amed Rosario started seeing time at third base, and that experiment went badly enough that the pressure to platoon McMahon only intensified.
Lately, though, McMahon has started looking like the player the Yankees thought they were getting. Over his last two weeks, he’s hitting .290 with an .830 OPS, with two doubles, one home run and five RBI. More than just empty production, it’s been the kind that keeps New York hanging around.
Ryan McMahon now has 5 go-ahead RBI in the 7th inning or later this season, the most on the Yankees.
The only player in MLB that entered Tuesday's games with more was Brice Turang (6).
- Katie Sharp (@SharpStats17) August 12, 2026
Since Aug. 2, the Yankees are 6-1 when McMahon scores a run or notches an RBI. And in “late and close” spots, his numbers have been especially strong all year. That’s the kind of thing that can change the tone around a player in a hurry, even if the overall line still leaves room for complaint.
Ryan McMahon won’t impress you with his offensive stats, but he will impress you with his stats when the game is “late and close” (7th inning or later, either leading by 1 run, tie game, or can tie game)
His stats in that situation this year:
.350 BA
.413 OBP
.550 SLG
.963 OPS
- Jon from Maspeth (@JonFromMaspeth) August 12, 2026
The ugly part of the profile is still there. The RISP numbers need work if this is going to fully hold together. But after the way things looked earlier this season, the Yankees will take functional offense and strong defense at third base without much hesitation.
And that’s really the heart of the trade debate. New York took on more than $36 million of McMahon’s remaining contract, and there’s plenty of room to question whether the money and the prospect cost were ideal.
Griffin Herring and Josh Grosz were part of the conversation, and you can make the case that the Yankees might have used those arms differently. But the present-day reality matters too.
Herring has an 8.87 ERA and 2.10 WHIP in 12 games at Double-A, with 23 earned runs allowed in 23 1/3 innings. Grosz was later traded to the Diamondbacks for outfielder Jake McCarthy in January, and he’s posted a 4.46 ERA and 1.32 WHIP in 42 1/3 innings. His 65 strikeouts stand out, but the control has been shaky.
So for now, the Yankees are left with the simplest possible version of the McMahon story: keep being useful, keep playing the position well, and maybe deliver one of those postseason moments that changes how everyone remembers the deal. If that happens, the rest of the noise will fade fast.
In Other News...
Yankees Suddenly Have A Chance To Upgrade Behind Austin Wells
The catching market shifted quickly when Boston activated Adley Rutschman from the injured list and moved on from Jake Rogers, a veteran backstop who has been in the mix with multiple clubs this summer. For a Yankees team that has Austin Wells entrenched as the starter and Ali Snchez as the right-handed reserve, that kind of roster churn can matter, especially when a familiar name suddenly becomes available.
Rogers is the sort of catcher clubs value for reasons that do not always show up in the box score. He has a reputation for handling pitchers well and bringing defensive stability, while his bat has not been the draw. For the Yankees, the question is whether that profile is enough to make him a better fit than what they already have behind Wells, and whether they see enough upside to jump in before another team does. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees May Have Won The Catcher Gamble Without Making The Splash
The Yankees chose the quieter route behind the plate, signing Mitch Garver to shore up a catcher spot that needed attention without chasing the biggest name on the market. It was the kind of move that drew less noise than a blockbuster pursuit, but it also reflected a front office willing to trust fit and value over headlines, especially with other catching options moving around the league.
Adley Rutschmans path to Boston only adds to the conversation, because the former top prospect has not been the same offensive force he once was and his recent seasons have been shaped by injuries. For the Yankees, the larger takeaway is less about who they passed on and more about whether a modest gamble can pay off in a division where the Red Sox have altered their roster and the Orioles are forced to reconsider theirs. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Frustration With Trent Grisham Just Spilled Into Plain View
Trent Grishams first year back in pinstripes has not unfolded the way the Yankees hoped after he accepted a $22 million qualifying offer following a strong previous season. His offense has backed up a bit, and the bigger concern has been the work in center field, where his defense has graded below average and started to draw sharper attention as the season has worn on.
That unease spilled into the open during a recent game, when a defensive misplay set off visible frustration from a Yankees pitcher on the mound. It was the kind of moment that tends to linger beyond one inning, because for a team with postseason expectations, shaky communication and uneven play in center can quickly become more than just a passing annoyance. [Read more 🡒]