The Yankees’ search for catching help has already taken them to Colorado, and Hunter Goodman is at least on the radar.
Jorge Castillo of ESPN reported that the Yankees have called the Rockies about Goodman, though not recently. The timing of that check-in isn’t clear, but it confirms the two clubs have discussed the catcher at some point as New York looks for answers behind the plate.
That need is obvious. Brian Cashman said last week the catching group had become a concerning part of the roster, and the production backs that up.
Austin Wells is in the middle of a rough year at .155/.247/.258, while Ali Sánchez and J.C. Escarra have also struggled.
Ryan Jeffers of the Twins has been the more frequent name tied to the Yankees, and for good reason. He’s a productive hitter and an impending free agent, though Minnesota’s place in the playoff race makes his availability uncertain.
The Twins also have Victor Caratini, so a move would be possible even if they stay mostly in buyer mode, but they could just as easily keep Jeffers for the stretch run and sort out the future later with a qualifying offer. If that pursuit stalls, Colorado could be back in the conversation.
Goodman would cost more. Jeffers is making $6.7MM and is headed toward free agency, while Goodman has not yet qualified for arbitration and remains under club control for three more seasons after this one. That extra control makes him a much bigger asset, especially because the bat has real punch.
He struck out a lot, but the power has been loud. Goodman hit 31 home runs last season and already has 27 this year.
His strikeout rate has climbed from 26.3% to 32.2%, but he has also improved his walk rate from 5.7% to 8.5%. The overall offensive value has held steady too, with a 118 wRC+ last year and the same mark this season.
And this isn’t just a Coors Field mirage. Goodman has actually been better on the road than at home since the start of last season.
At home, he has 22 homers, a .276/.335/.497 line and a 101 wRC+. Away from elevation, he has 36 homers, a .262/.312/.557 line and a 134 wRC+.
Defensively, he’s viewed as about league average.
That combination - power, patience, and years of control - gives Colorado plenty of leverage if it decides to listen. It also makes the Rockies’ decision harder, because Goodman is one of the more appealing pieces on a roster that has spent years near the bottom of the standings.
Historically, Colorado has been reluctant to move players when their value is highest. The club has extended trade candidates before, including Daniel Bard and C.J.
Cron, while Trevor Story and Jon Gray were simply kept and allowed to reach free agency. Story brought back a draft pick after turning down a qualifying offer, but Gray did not even receive one.
The front office is different now. Bill Schmidt and the Rockies parted ways after last season, and Paul DePodesta was hired as president of baseball operations. This will be his first deadline in charge.
“There would be certain guys that would be really, really hard for us to move. I think that’s probably true of any team,” DePodesta said in June, when asked if anyone on the roster was untouchable.
“There are guys that we feel are hopefully foundational players for us going forward. At the same time, we need to be opportunistic.
We are not where we want to be. So, if there are opportunities for us to get better, certainly both in the short-term and the long-term, I think we need to look at that.
I think it’s our responsibility to do that. But there are a lot of guys that we’re not actively shopping.”
That leaves Goodman in a tricky spot. He matters to Colorado, but the Rockies also aren’t close to contention, and Baseball America recently ranked their farm system 28th in the majors. There isn’t an obvious wave of impact talent ready to change the picture anytime soon.
Colorado could keep Goodman through 2029, but there’s no guarantee the club will be competitive for much of that stretch. A trade would be one of the clearest ways to add to a thin farm and bring in new talent.
For the Yankees, the fit is imperfect but understandable. Catchers don’t just arrive and plug in smoothly midseason; they have to learn a new pitching staff fast.
Even so, New York appears willing to make that leap because Wells has been so ineffective. The Yankees may also have some flexibility with the designated hitter spot while Giancarlo Stanton is injured and without a clear timeline.
That could make Goodman easier to integrate. His bat is strong enough to play at DH while he gets acclimated to the staff.
Right now, Ben Rice and Paul Goldschmidt are splitting first base and DH duties, and Goldschmidt’s hot start has cooled sharply in July. That could open the door for him to shift from an everyday role into more of a short-side platoon spot.
Once Goodman is comfortable with the pitching staff, he could gradually take on more work behind the plate.
In Other News...
Aaron Judge Just Sparked A Strange Yankees Captain Controversy
Aaron Judges rehab from injury has kept him off the field for the time being, but he still managed to become part of a very odd Yankees conversation this week. The noise started when Gary Sheffield Jr. publicly pointed out a social media block and then wondered aloud what might have led to it, turning a routine online move into a topic that immediately caught the attention of Yankees fans.
The bigger intrigue is less about the block itself than about what it says, or might say, about Judges public image and how his account is handled. Neither Judge nor the Yankees has addressed it, which has left plenty of room for speculation about who is actually managing the account and why this particular interaction drew such a reaction. [Read more 🡒]
Aaron Boone Just Made A Telling Yankees Move Before Nightcap
The Yankees are treating the second game of their day-night set with the Dodgers like a fresh chess match, and Aaron Boones lineup and pitching plan show it. Ryan Yarbrough will open on the mound for New York, with the Dodgers countering with right-handed reliever Will Klein, while Trent Grisham is in center field and Ben Rice is handling designated hitter duties as the Yankees try to reset after the first game.
Boone also has a few late-inning options sitting in reserve after the afternoon game, including Brent Headrick, Fernando Cruz, David Bednar and Paul Blackburn, giving him more room to manage the nightcap aggressively. The roster shuffle around the pitching staff adds another layer to the move, and the real question now is how long the Yankees want to stay with the opener approach before turning the game over to the rest of the bullpen. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Finally Made A Jake Bird Move Fans Were Begging For
The Yankees finally made the bullpen move many fans had been waiting for, sending right-hander Jake Bird to Triple-A Scranton/Wilkes-Barre and bringing up Kervin Castro in his place. Birds rough stretch has been hard to ignore since he arrived last summer, and the latest decision came with the club trying to steady things before a doubleheader against the Dodgers.
New York also added Elmer Rodriguez as the 27th man for the twin bill, a practical roster move that lets the Yankees cover the extra game without burning an option. For now, Bird is out of the major league mix and the bullpen gets a fresh arm, but the larger question is whether this is just a reset or the start of a much longer wait before he gets another shot. [Read more 🡒]