The Red Sox keep finding new ways to turn a bad injury update into a worse one.
Curtis Mead’s broken wrist is just the latest example. The newly acquired infielder was hit by a pitch in his Boston debut on Monday, stayed in the game at first, then came out an inning later. Afterward, Mead and interim manager Chad Tracy both took the optimistic route, saying X-rays were negative.
By the next day, Mead was on the injured list with a broken wrist.
That kind of whiplash has become a theme around this team. The explanation for Mead’s initial clean bill of health could be anything from the conditions in West Sacramento to swelling in the wrist to the need for an MRI to catch a small bone fracture. But the bigger issue is what happened after the first diagnosis: the Red Sox repeated that relief publicly, only for the reality to change almost immediately.
And this isn’t an isolated case.
Boston has spent most of the season without Roman Anthony and Garrett Crochet, its two best players, and neither one was expected to be out very long when the injuries first surfaced. Crochet last pitched on April 25 with shoulder fatigue, and at the time he didn’t think the IL would be necessary.
A source told MassLive on April 30 that the move was only precautionary, with the "shoulder discomfort ... trending better on a daily basis." Crochet also said "it just makes more sense to get ahead of it now so I’m not playing catch-up the rest of the season."
That stay wound up lasting longer than anyone wanted. Even in mid-May, Crochet was still talking like a quick return was right around the corner, and he said he wouldn’t need a rehab assignment before coming back.
"I'd rather not waste innings on a rehab assignment when I feel like I can contribute," he said on May 13.
Then came last week, when Crochet could no longer say whether he’d be able to pitch at all in the 2026 season.
Anthony’s situation has been just as messy. The Red Sox have treated him like the centerpiece of their future, so when he left a game in Detroit on May 4 after a check swing, the concern was immediate.
Boston said afterward that X-rays on his wrist were negative, though he was headed back to Boston to see a hand specialist. Tracy said the club hoped the injury wouldn’t require an IL stint and even suggested Anthony might rejoin the team on the road in that Detroit series.
That was May 4. Anthony still hasn’t returned, and he’s not close. The team sent him to Florida to keep rehabbing, with no imminent comeback in sight.
Over the last three months, the gap between the Red Sox’s initial messaging and the eventual reality has been hard to miss. There has also been a clear disagreement at times between the team and the player, enough for president and CEO Sam Kennedy to publicly apologize to Anthony for mischaracterizing how serious the injury was.
Maybe Kennedy really does lean into the " toxic positivity" label that has followed him. Maybe the organization is simply struggling to properly identify and communicate injuries when they happen. Either way, the pattern is obvious now: when a Red Sox player gets hurt, the safest public statement may be no statement at all.
Because saying it’s minor and insisting it won’t be a problem has only made the public trust the team’s injury reporting a lot less.
In Other News...
Yankees May Have Finally Zeroed In On A Catcher Upgrade
The Yankees have been canvassing the catching market with a clear eye on upgrades, and the list of names they have checked in on says plenty about how serious they are. Tyler Stephenson of the Reds, Adley Rutschman of the Orioles and Hunter Goodman of the Rockies have all come up in recent inquiries as New York looks to stabilize a position that has been under the microscope.
Stephenson stands out as the most realistic target of the group because his improved play this season lines up with Cincinnatis rebuild, which could make him available. Rutschman and Goodman would be far tougher to pry loose, given their team control and the situations their clubs are in, so the Yankees may be narrowing toward the kind of move that is difficult but not impossible if they want a real answer behind the plate. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees May Have Just Found A Real Deadline Answer Behind The Plate
As the Yankees continue sorting through their trade-deadline options, catcher Carson Kelly has emerged as a name worth watching. New York is reportedly interested in the Cubs backstop as it looks for help behind the plate, and the timing is notable with Chicago opening against the Yankees and Kelly not expected to be in that lineup.
The Cubs, though, are said to be weighing their own needs as they listen, with pitching likely the key if they decide to move him. For the Yankees, it leaves the situation in the familiar deadline holding pattern: exploring possibilities, staying active, and trying to find a fit that makes sense without making the wrong move just for the sake of urgency. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Deadline Idea Could Finally Address Two Problems At Once
The Yankees are once again in the position of needing help in more than one place, and this time the conversation has drifted across town. Luke Weaver and Tyrone Taylor have emerged as speculative trade fits, with Weaver drawing interest for what he can do on the mound and Taylor standing out as a possible answer in the outfield. It is the kind of deadline idea that makes sense on paper because it speaks to two separate roster needs without forcing New York to shop from one thin area to patch another.
Weavers appeal is tied to his performance and the questions that have followed him, while Taylor brings a different value proposition as a useful bat and a strong defender. For the Yankees, the attraction is obvious: a move like this could help stabilize the pitching staff and add a more complete option in center field or a corner spot. Whether the Mets would even entertain that kind of deal is another matter, but the fit is enough to keep the idea in circulation as the deadline chatter builds. [Read more 🡒]