Yankees Old-Timers’ Day still carries the same name, but the feel around it has changed.
The annual celebration no longer features the kind of legends who once made the afternoon feel like a roll call from Cooperstown. Joe DiMaggio, Mickey Mantle, Yogi Berra and Whitey Ford are gone. These days, the spotlight falls on names from later Yankees eras - Reggie Jackson and Mickey Rivers from the 1970s, then Mariano Rivera, David Cone, Jorge Posada, Bernie Williams, Tino Martinez, Hideki Matsui and Joe Torre from the 1990s.
Derek Jeter was missing again, after also sitting out last year because of what he said was a schedule conflict with his daughter’s birthday. The alumni game returned last season and remained part of the day this year.
What stood out on Saturday, though, was the turnout. With the temperature sitting around 90 degrees and the festivities starting at 12:45 before the 3:05 game against the Atlanta Braves, fans were being asked to commit to roughly six hours in the heat. Even with about 45,000 tickets sold, fewer than half that number were in their seats for Old-Timers’ Day.
Michael Kay, who emcees the event, addressed it on his radio show and made clear he noticed the difference.
“I don’t get it. It’s been a problem,” Kay said.
He pointed back to the old days, when his notes included names like Berra, DiMaggio, Phil Rizzuto, Mantle and Ford.
“It’s different than when I had that script in front of me in the mid-90s, and I’m introducing Yogi Berra, Joe DiMaggio, Phil Rizzuto, Mickey Mantle, Whitey Ford,” Kay added. “These are all-time greats! The names and the games, they echo in the halls of Cooperstown.”
Kay said the younger generation may simply not connect with nostalgia the same way.
“Maybe today’s younger fanbase is not into nostalgia,” Kay said. “I’m not sure, but how could you not be into the 1996, ‘98, ‘99, 2000 teams?
The final three people introduced at the stadium Saturday, Reggie Jackson, Joe Torre and Mariano Rivera. It’s a little different.
Although those are all Hall of Famers, it’s not Mantle, it’s not Berra, it’s not Ford, it’s not DiMaggio. It’s different.
Times change, people pass away.”
He said he wasn’t trying to tell anyone how to spend their money, but the empty seats still bothered him.
“These men that have created so many great memories for Yankee fans of all ages, they deserve more than this. They do,” Kay said.
“I’m not here to scold you, I’m not here to lecture you, not at all. I’m just here to point out that the place was half empty when I started introducing these great players.”
Kay’s concern is that the trend may not reverse soon. A Jeter appearance would obviously add some juice, but for now, the event seems to be dealing with a different era and a different kind of fan turnout.
In Other News...
Yankees Bullpen Depth Just Took Another Hit At The Wrong Time
The Yankees bullpen picture got a little thinner again, this time at Triple-A, where Scranton has moved on from veteran reliever Rafael Montero. The right-hander never got fully on track in 2026, turning in a rough stint marked by uneven results even as he still showed swing-and-miss stuff with 33 strikeouts across 27 innings.
Monteros season started late because of visa issues, and the delay only added to the uncertainty around what he could provide. For New York, the timing is less than ideal after recent trade deadline subtractions chipped away at the big league relief depth, leaving the organization with fewer experienced options to turn to if the bullpen needs another arm. [Read more 🡒]
Anthony Volpes Path Back To The Yankees Just Got More Complicated
Anthony Volpes road back to the Yankees has already taken a turn, and it may not be a simple one. After being optioned to Triple-A Scranton/Wilkes-Barre, the former shortstop prospect is now getting looks at second base as the club tries to broaden his options while reshaping its infield around George Lombard Jr., who has been promoted to take over at shortstop.
For the Yankees, the timing matters as much as the position change. They are in the middle of a pennant race and sorting out a new infield hierarchy, with Volpes offensive production still central to any path back to the majors. If he can show he fits elsewhere on the diamond, it could help, but his bat will likely decide how quickly the door reopens. [Read more 🡒]
Michael Kay Calls Out Yankees Fans As Old-Timers Day Debate Grows
The Yankees Old-Timers Day has long been one of the most recognizable dates on the club calendar, a chance for fans to see former stars reconnect with the franchise and bring some nostalgia back to the ballpark. But the annual alumni game has drawn a noticeably thinner crowd in recent years, even with plenty of tickets sold, and that drop-off has started to raise questions about how much appeal the event still has when the old guard is not quite as deep as it once was.
Michael Kay has made clear he is among those frustrated by the decline in turnout, pointing to the missing star power from earlier generations as part of the issue. The conversation has only grown louder with Derek Jeter absent from recent editions, a detail that can matter a great deal for fans who still buy into the idea of Old-Timers Day as a must-see tradition rather than just another ceremonial stop on the summer schedule. [Read more 🡒]