Luis Gil’s latest comments have put a fresh spotlight on one of the Yankees’ most painful offseason misses.
The pitcher, who shared the field with Aaron Judge and Juan Soto during New York’s 2024 pennant run, made it clear the desire to keep Soto in pinstripes went beyond the front office. In Gil’s telling, the clubhouse wanted the star right fielder back after the season, and the feeling inside the room was strong.
“All the Yankees players wanted to see Juan Soto back on the team,” Gil said via MLB insider Mike Rodriguez.
He made the point even more directly a moment later.
“We love Juan Soto!” Gil said.
That matters because it frames Soto’s departure as more than a roster decision. The Yankees didn’t just lose a big bat. They lost a player the team had grown attached to during a season that carried them to the American League pennant.
New York did make a massive push to keep him. In December 2024, the Yankees offered Soto $760 million over 16 years.
The Mets ultimately won the bidding with a 15-year, $765 million deal that included a $75 million signing bonus and a higher average annual value. New York’s offer came out to $47.5 million annually, while the Mets’ agreement checked in at $51 million a year.
At the winter meetings, Brian Cashman defended the effort and said ownership had gone farther than expected.
“Certainly went well beyond what I would have expected,” Cashman said.
Still, the result never changed. The Yankees’ preferred outcome, backed by ownership and wanted by the players, did not happen. Soto crossed town and left behind a clubhouse that had clearly valued him.
That loss is easier to measure on the field. Soto hit .288 with 41 home runs, 109 RBIs and 129 walks in his lone Yankees season.
Batting next to Judge, he gave New York two elite on-base threats and helped fuel the club’s first American League pennant since 2009. The Yankees then lost the 2024 World Series to the Los Angeles Dodgers in five games.
It is also a reminder of what the Yankees had to replace. Soto entered free agency at 26, and his departure forced the organization to rebuild both production and chemistry.
The club responded by adding Max Fried and Cody Bellinger, among other moves, instead of putting the full Soto money into one player. Those additions changed the roster, but they did not recreate the Judge-Soto pairing or the relationships that had formed during the 2024 run.
Now the organization is back in another round of self-examination after its 2026 postseason exit. Aaron Boone is set to return as manager in 2027, while the front office faces more decisions about the lineup, bullpen and rotation depth.
Gil’s own situation is part of that picture too. The 2024 American League Rookie of the Year went 1-2 with a 4.61 ERA in nine major league appearances in 2026, including four starts, and his role remains uncertain enough to fuel offseason trade and roster talk.
Even so, his comments landed as a blunt reminder of what the Yankees couldn’t preserve. They spent big, they pushed hard, and they still lost the player their clubhouse wanted most.
In Other News...
Yankees Still Have One Catching Question This Trade Idea Could Solve
The Yankees have spent plenty of time sorting through the edges of their roster, and the backup catcher spot remains one of the more obvious areas to monitor. San Diego may have the kind of catching surplus that can create movement, with Freddy Fermin and Luis Campusano both mentioned as possible trade candidates, and Fermin in particular stands out as a glove-first option who could fit a need in New York.
For the Yankees, the appeal is straightforward: add a catcher who can handle the defensive side of the job and provide some stability behind the plate without asking him to carry the offense. Fermins bat has not been a strength, but his reputation as a strong defender makes him the sort of depth piece contenders often look for as the season wears on and every bench spot starts to matter a little more. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Are Already Being Tied To A Massive 2027 Infield Move
The Yankees are already being pushed toward a different infield picture for 2027, even with plenty of baseball still to be played before then. Jazz Chisholm Jr. is not expected to be part of that mix at second base, and the club is also weighing whether third base needs a real upgrade after Ryan McMahons uneven production left that spot looking less settled than the Yankees would prefer.
One name that keeps surfacing in the conversation is Corey Seager, which tells you how ambitious the thinking could get if New York decides to chase a bigger bat and a cleaner fit on the left side of the diamond. The idea is still rooted in projection rather than anything concrete, but it underscores how the Yankees may be preparing for an infield overhaul that could reshape the roster well beyond next season. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Suddenly Face A Clarke Schmidt Decision That Could Reshape Bullpen Plans
Clarke Schmidts place on the Yankees roster has become one of those winter questions that can ripple beyond one player. Entering his final year of arbitration, he is no longer viewed with the same level of control or upside he carried earlier in his career, and the combination of injuries and age has changed the calculus around how New York values him. For a team trying to balance immediate pitching needs with long-term roster flexibility, Schmidt sits in a tricky middle ground.
The trade market only complicates matters, since clubs are generally wary of paying meaningful prospect capital for a one-year rental with uncertainty hanging over the sports labor landscape. That leaves the Yankees weighing another path theyve used before with other former starters: moving Schmidt into the bullpen. It is a move that could help in the short term, but it would also force the club to make a real decision about how much it wants to sacrifice starting depth and whether the relief corps is strong enough to absorb the shift. [Read more 🡒]
