J.J. McCarthy gave Minnesota fans exactly the kind of Sunday they didn’t want to see.
In his first real action for the New York Giants - not counting a random gimmick package - the former Vikings quarterback nearly dragged his new team all the way back from a 24-point hole against the New Orleans Saints. New York was trailing by that margin with less than 12 minutes left in the fourth quarter when the Giants benched Jameis Winstion and handed the offense to McCarthy.
The first flashpoint was rough. On his fourth pass attempt, McCarthy was picked off by Saints cornerback Martin Emerson.
He shook it off fast.
On his next drive, McCarthy helped the Giants string together a six-play, 45-yard march that ended with a five-yard rushing touchdown from Tyron Tracy. New York then went for two, and McCarthy delivered by finding Isaiah Likely on the right side of the end zone.
After the Giants’ defense forced a 3-and-out, McCarthy got another shot and cashed it in for his first touchdown pass of the 2026 season.
That set up a tense finish. New York still trailed by seven and had one final chance to tie or win it in the closing minutes. McCarthy moved the offense all the way to the Saints’ 14-yard line, but with 12 seconds left, he took the snap on 4th-and-1 and threw incomplete into the back of the end zone, ending the comeback bid and sealing the win for New Orleans.
Still, the box score was enough to stir up the Vikings conversation all over again.
McCarthy finished with 243 passing yards, one touchdown, one interception and a 52.4 percent completion rate, plus 26 rushing yards. And even though he was on the field for only about 75 percent of the fourth quarter, his showing was enough to get Minnesota fans talking during the Vikings’ bye week.
A few of them were loud about it online, including this reaction: “I just wanted to see another game or two before calling him a bust, and a bunch of people deemed that to be an idiotic stance 🤷🏼♂️”
Another wrote, “If this is how he plays for the rest of the year, this team legit needs to win the SB or Teasley and KOC can both go.”
Bob “The BS Show” Sansevere added, “J.J. McCarthy just engineered two TD drives in under two minutes, with the second one a 24-yard TD pass. Why can't the Vikings find a QB like McCarthy?”
It’s still early, and the source of this story doesn’t pretend otherwise. There’s no final verdict on whether Minnesota made the right call by trading McCarthy to New York earlier this season. But Sunday’s performance absolutely gives fuel to the people in Minnesota who think the Vikings let something slip away.
And if the Giants stick with McCarthy, the next step could come quickly. Given how he played against the Saints, it wouldn’t be a surprise if New York names him the starter over Winston for Week 7 against the Houston Texans. If that happens, plenty of Vikings fans will be watching closely to see what McCarthy does next.
In Other News...
Yankees Just Lost A Key Coach In A Troubling Development Blow
The Yankees are losing one of the more quietly important figures in their development pipeline, as the Astros have hired Spencer Medick away from Triple-A to become their new director of pitching. Medick had been in the organization since 2022 and spent time working with Cam Schlittler during the right-handers rise through the minors, a stretch that helped shape one of the most encouraging young pitching stories in the system.
Schlittlers 2026 season only sharpened the interest around that work, finishing with a 1.95 ERA, the lowest qualifying mark for the Yankees since 1978. So while the move is being made at the staff level rather than on the major league roster, it still lands as a meaningful development loss for a club that has leaned heavily on continuity in its pitching instruction. [Read more 🡒]
Aaron Boone Just Made Jazz Chisholms Yankees Future Feel Clear
Jazz Chisholm Jr.s first full run in pinstripes never quite settled into the kind of season the Yankees were hoping for, and it ended with more questions than answers. His uneven 2026 performance was already under the microscope before a costly throwing error in the ALDS only added to the scrutiny, making the fall feel even steeper for a player brought in to bring energy and production.
Then Aaron Boone said the quiet part out loud. The Yankees manager made it clear that Chisholms approach has rubbed him the wrong way, pointing specifically to the kind of behavior that can grate inside a clubhouse, and the comments only sharpened the sense that Chisholm may not be part of the teams long-term plans. For a player whose talent still makes him intriguing, the issue now is whether the Yankees see enough fit beyond the flashes to keep the relationship going. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Fifth Starter Battle Comes Down To Upside Or Reliability
The Yankees have plenty to like at the top of their rotation, with recent All-Stars like Gerrit Cole, Carlos Rodn and Max Fried headlining a group that also includes Cam Schlittler. The question now is less about star power than about how to round out the back end, where the fifth-starter spot has turned into a familiar kind of camp debate: do the Yankees lean into upside, or do they choose the arm they trust most to take the ball and keep them in games?
Ryan Weathers looked like a real candidate after a solid 2026 season, but the forearm injury he suffered late in the year complicates his case. Will Warren, meanwhile, brings the kind of durability teams value in April and beyond, having topped 150 innings in each of the past two seasons, even if his command can wander at times. For a club built to expect excellence from the front of the rotation, the final choice may come down to whether it wants the ceiling of a comeback candidate or the steadier profile of a workhorse who does not always have perfect feel. [Read more 🡒]