With Jaxson Dart sidelined for the rest of the regular season, the Giants are already staring at their next quarterback question, and J.J. McCarthy’s name has surfaced in the conversation. But the early read around the league is pretty clear: this doesn’t look like a move New York is likely to make.
That’s a rough turn for a Giants team trying to get its footing in Week 3, especially with John Harbaugh trying to make his first real impression as the new head coach in New York. Dart’s injury has forced the organization to think ahead fast, and the focus has already shifted to the 2026-27 season.
McCarthy, meanwhile, has become a speculative option because he’s not starting for the Vikings and is currently just waiting on the bench. Even so, the people around the league who’ve weighed in don’t see the fit.
Ryan Dunleavy of the New York Post wrote on X on Wednesday, "Never say never. But J.J. McCarthy is one available QB I cannot see #Giants pursuing."
Dan Duggan of The Athletic echoed that view in a feature published Thursday. He pointed out that the Giants did a deep dive on McCarthy before the 2024 draft, when they ultimately used the sixth pick on Malik Nabers instead. "That type of pedigree sticks with a player, even when the start of his career has been as rocky as McCarthy's."
Duggan also noted that McCarthy is coming off a quarterback battle he lost to Kyler Murray and is now third on the Vikings’ depth chart behind Carson Wentz. In his view, even a modest trade package would be too much. "even parting with one of the 2027 sixth-rounders or a late-round pick in a future draft for McCarthy seems wasteful. He'd need to come in and learn a new offense on the fly during the season."
For now, the buzz doesn’t line up with the logic. McCarthy is a name to watch only because the Giants need answers, but the reporting so far suggests this one is fading rather than building.
In Other News...
Yankees May Get A Huge Opening In Game 1 Vs Boston
The Yankees could be staring at an opening in Game 1 of the Wild Card Series if Boston is forced to go without Wilson Contreras, whose hand injury has put his status in doubt. The Red Sox first baseman was hurt a week ago and has not been able to swing over the last two days, leaving the matchup in question as the postseason gets underway.
Boston manager Chad Tracy said Contreras is still sore but making subtle improvements while working with trainers, and the club is hoping to have him back for October. For the Yankees, the uncertainty matters because it could change the shape of Bostons lineup right from the start, especially in a short series where every edge carries extra weight. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees May Have Found Their Aaron Judge Stopgap At Last
The Yankees keep waiting for Aaron Judge to return, but Tuesdays comeback against the Rays offered a glimpse of how they might survive in the meantime. Rookie George Lombard Jr. was right in the middle of it, helping spark the offense with his legs and his bat, including a two-run homer that energized a rally New York badly needed.
Lombard ended up touching four of the six runs the Yankees scored, a striking level of involvement for a young player thrust into a bigger role by Judges absence. For a club built around its captain, nights like this matter because they show the lineup can still find production from unexpected places while it waits for its MVP centerpiece to get healthy. [Read more 🡒]
Austin Wells Gives Yankees Fans A Feel Good Moment At Last
Austin Wells gave Yankees fans something lighter to smile about this week, sharing a personal milestone with longtime partner Caroline Nielson. The catcher and Nielson publicly announced their engagement on September 23, and the reveal confirmed that Wells proposed earlier in the month, on September 3.
Nielson, a former collegiate equestrian athlete who competed at Oklahoma State and SMU, has been part of Wells life long before the public announcement. The couple also has a daughter, Lucy Marie, born in January 2026, adding another layer to a moment that feels bigger than baseball for one of the Yankees young backstops. [Read more 🡒]