Gerrit Cole’s slide is arriving at the worst possible moment for the Yankees.
On Saturday, the 2023 AL Cy Young Award winner was knocked around again in a 12-2 loss to the New York Mets, a rough outing that only deepened the questions surrounding New York’s postseason rotation. Cole, making his 20th start of the season, worked just 4.1 innings and allowed five earned runs on nine hits, with three of those hits leaving the yard.
The damage started almost immediately. Francisco Lindor opened the game by sending an 85 mph changeup 359 feet to right field on the third pitch Cole threw.
In the second inning, Cole surrendered a two-run homer, his sixth home run allowed across his last two starts after giving up 13 in his first 16 outings. Then rookie Mets outfielder Carson Benge added another blast in the third, punishing an 89 mph slider.
This wasn’t an isolated blip. Over Cole’s last four starts, dating back to a 5-1 loss to the Houston Astros on Aug. 27, he owns a 6.08 ERA with only 17 strikeouts in 22.2 innings. He has now given up at least three earned runs in four straight starts, and the home run total is piling up fast.
One start earlier, at the San Diego Padres, Fernando Tatis, Jake Cronenworth and Manny Machado went back-to-back-to-back to open the game against him. MLB.com Yankees reporter Bryan Hoch noted that Cole’s seven home runs allowed over his last two starts are the most in a two-game span of his career.
The Yankees are not getting much margin for error, either. They’ve averaged just 3.67 runs of support when Cole takes the mound, turning starts that once looked like sure things into something far less stable.
With October approaching, the rotation picture is becoming clearer - and Cole’s spot in it is not as secure as it used to be. Likely AL Cy Young winner Cam Schlittler, who leads the league with a 2.06 ERA, should be the anchor. Max Fried, at 2.73, and Carlos Rodon, at 2.94, look like stronger choices for Games 2 and 3 of a wild-card series.
In most seasons, having Cole as a fourth option would be a luxury. This year, though, the Yankees may need much more from him if they’re going to navigate an extended ALDS or push into the ALCS.
Instead of building momentum, Cole is trending the wrong way. And the clock is ticking.
In Other News...
Juan Soto Still Knows Why This Yankees Return Feels Complicated
Juan Sotos return to the city comes with a familiar mix of warmth and tension, and he seemed to recognize both sides of it before a Subway Series matchup. After choosing the Mets in free agency following his time with the Yankees, Soto acknowledged what he has already felt in the stands and around the team he left behind: some Yankees fans still appreciate what he gave them, while others have not been quite as forgiving.
The bigger backdrop only sharpens the contrast. Since Sotos decision in 2024, the Yankees have generally looked like the club with the steadier process, while the Mets have had a harder time matching that standard. Soto still left a real imprint during his Yankees run, and enough respect remains there to make this feel less like a clean break than a complicated reunion. [Read more 🡒]
Juan Soto Gave Yankees Fans A Brutal New Subway Series Talking Point
Juan Sotos first Subway Series game in Yankees pinstripes was the kind of night that can linger with a fan base, especially in a city where every swing and every misplay gets magnified. He went 1-for-5 with multiple strikeouts and never found the sort of impact at-bat that usually comes with his name, leaving the Yankees searching for a bigger moment from one of their most important bats.
The glove work in left field only added to the frustration, with some of the attention going to lapses in effort and positioning that stood out in a tight, emotional matchup. It was an ugly opening chapter against the Mets, though the larger story remains unfinished, and the Yankees will be hoping this is the low point rather than a sign of what the rivalry has in store. [Read more 🡒]
Mets Yankees Game Took A Disturbing Turn Fans Wont Forget
A Yankees-Mets game at Yankee Stadium on the 25th anniversary of September 11 took an unsettling turn when a fan ran onto the field carrying a Palestinian flag and wearing a No Kings jersey. Security quickly tackled the man, later identified as 38-year-old Kelly Marcucci, and the interruption brought a brief but jarring pause to a night that was already carrying extra weight because of the date.
Marcucci was charged with trespassing and a local ordinance violation, while the Yankees declined to comment afterward. It was the kind of scene that can overshadow everything around it, especially in a rivalry game at a ballpark where the crowd came expecting baseball, not a security response playing out in front of everyone. [Read more 🡒]