White Sox prospect Caleb Bonemer didn’t exactly put the Gerrit Cole chatter to bed this week, and neither did Chicago host Chuck Garfien.
Bonemer was asked about the moment during Cole’s rehab assignment this past season when the Yankees right-hander worked through a sequence that started with damage and ended with a hit-by-pitch. Bonemer homered off Cole in his first at-bat, then lined a single in his second before being hit on the elbow by a 98 mph fastball in his third trip.
“Right off the elbow. 98, right off the elbow. (pause) Yeah, I don't know ... I'm not one to say why, but that's what happened,” Bonemer said.
Garfien then pushed the moment into more suggestive territory, laughing as Bonemer reacted. “You don't need to say what happened.
I'll tell everyone what happened,” Garfien said. “That was a purpose -- like, 'Hey, minor-leaguer, I'm Gerrit Freaking Cole, you just homered off of me.
Now you got a single off of me. Now take that.'
That's a badge of honor.”
Bonemer didn’t bite on that version of events, but he also didn’t sound eager to make a scene.
“Everybody was telling me I should show some emotion, say something back, but ... what else can I say? I did my job. That's that,” Bonemer added.
The interview kept the controversy simmering without Bonemer flat-out accusing Cole of anything. Still, the exchange gave Chicago fans plenty to latch onto, with Garfien openly leaning into the idea that the pitch was intentional.
In Other News...
Carlos Rodon Just Gave Yankees Fans A New Reason To Wonder
Carlos Rodons 2026 season gave the Yankees plenty to feel good about when he was on the mound. In 16 starts, he went 7-3 with a 2.67 ERA, a reminder that when healthy, he can still look like a real difference-maker in the rotation. But the larger conversation around him has never been just about performance. It has been about availability, and whether the Yankees can keep counting on him in a role that demands both quality and consistency.
Ashley Rodons emotional Instagram post added another layer to that uncertainty, reflecting on 12 seasons in professional baseball and the passage of time as a family. The message did not point to any retirement or contract decision, but it did leave one obvious question hanging over the offseason picture: what does the next chapter look like for Rodon, and how firmly is it tied to the Yankees? [Read more 🡒]
Why The Yankees Still Trust Aaron Boone Right Now
Hal Steinbrenner has put a short-term end to any speculation about the Yankees leadership structure, confirming that Brian Cashman and Aaron Boone will stay in place through at least this offseason. For Boone, that means the public noise around his job does not match the internal view of him, where he remains respected and seen as someone who can handle the burden that comes with managing in New York.
Boone is already under contract through the 2027 season, but the bigger question is what comes next if the Yankees do not take a meaningful step forward. Even with the backing he has now, the expectations in the Bronx do not change, and another World Series run may be what ultimately determines how long this security lasts. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Have A Tempting Third Base Upgrade With One Big Catch
The Yankees are at least kicking around a familiar winter idea again: whether Nolan Arenado could be the answer at third base. After an offensive rebound in 2026, Arenado is back in the conversation as a legitimate upgrade, and the appeal is obvious for a club that has been weighing how to stabilize the hot corner while keeping the rest of the roster intact.
The catch is the same one that tends to follow any move of this magnitude. Arenado is still under contract through 2027 at a $15 million salary that year, so a deal would force the Yankees to sort through both payroll and roster fit, especially with Ryan McMahon already part of the picture. It is the kind of upgrade that looks clean on paper and gets complicated fast once the financial and personnel realities come into focus. [Read more 🡒]