The Yankees’ latest October flop has done more than end another season early. It’s also opened the door for something this franchise usually avoids: a public reckoning from its own former players.
Anthony Rizzo already went after Jazz Chisholm Jr. and argued that the same cycle cannot keep repeating year after year. Now CC Sabathia and Dellin Betances have added their voices, and they didn’t come with the usual polished postseason clichés.
On a discussion with Chris Young, the two former Yankees talked about the sweep and the larger condition of the organization. The message was blunt: the old idea of a Yankees standard doesn’t feel as strong as it once did.
“It was like there's a standard that's set here, and we didn't meet that standard. No disrespect, but they don't know what that standard is.
You know why? Because there's nobody in there that keeping that standard.
Once [Brett Gardner] Gardy left, it's been a wrap. When I first came, it was Ron Guidry, Reggie Jackson, Mickey Rivers, Willie Randolph.
It was not only the Core Four, it was those guys, too. So, you knew what the standard was because the standard was sitting in the [expletive] room right next to you,” Sabathia said.
Sabathia’s point went beyond one bad series. He also noted that more recent Yankees icons such as Derek Jeter, Mariano Rivera and Jorge Posada have not stayed around the organization the way earlier generations of legends did.
He and Betances also touched on the team’s lack of practice time at Tropicana Field, Aaron Boone’s habit of defending his players so fiercely that accountability gets blurred, the way other teams mock the Yankees, and what they saw as a missing killer instinct.
The criticism lands because it’s coming from people who know the expectations that once came with the uniform. Sabathia, in particular, has the kind of credibility that makes his words hit hard.
That is where the bigger issue comes into focus: Boone is only part of the problem. The larger failure sits with the structure around him, the system that is supposed to pass along the franchise’s standards and make them stick. That burden falls on Hal Steinbrenner and Brian Cashman.
Cashman has also been responsible for assembling the kind of roster that can handle the spotlight, and the source of this frustration is not hard to find. Jazz Chisholm Jr., through both his play and his Game 3 postgame comments, became the clearest example of a player who looks better suited to be elsewhere this winter.
That leaves the Yankees facing a simple truth: something has to change.
Cashman’s contract expired when New York was eliminated, and Boone has one year left on his deal. Even so, Boone cannot be allowed to head into 2027 as a lame duck, because that would only deepen the same problems former Yankees are now calling out.
Whether Steinbrenner has the appetite to make a bold move is another question entirely. At minimum, the backlash from Rizzo, Sabathia, Betances and others has put the organization under a bright light. If that noise doesn’t lead to real change, then the frustration around the Yankees won’t be aimed at the roster alone.
In Other News...
Yankees Fans Can Dream On One Wild Ronald Acua Trade Idea
The idea arrived the way most big-market daydreams do, on social media and with plenty of imagination attached. Former Yankees outfielder Cameron Maybin floated a path that would bring Ronald Acua Jr. to the Bronx and reshape the lineup around him, with Aaron Judge shifting into a different kind of everyday role to make the fit work. It is the sort of thought experiment that instantly grabs attention because it involves two stars who can change the tone of a franchise in a hurry.
Acua, the 2023 NL MVP, would obviously be the prize in any such discussion, but the backdrop matters here too. He has made it clear he wants to stay with the Braves, even as Atlanta faces a complicated future around his contract, including club options for 2027 and 2028 and the possibility of a trade if the club does not extend him after next season. For Yankees fans, it is an enticing what-if, but for now it remains exactly that, a wild idea hanging out there until the Braves decide what kind of future they want to build. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Left Field Question Could Reveal Cashmans Real Priority
The Yankees are already looking at the same left-field question that helped define their early postseason exit, and it may end up saying as much about their larger offseason plan as it does about one spot on the roster. The choice in front of them is familiar: chase a full-time corner outfielder or lean into a more versatile type of addition that can cover ground in multiple places and give the lineup some flexibility.
One name that has come up as a possible fit is Mauricio Dubon, a former World Series champion whose defensive range and utility value could make sense for a club trying to patch holes without boxing itself in. Still, there is no verified sign the Yankees have made an approach or offer, and for now the idea serves more as a hint at what kind of player Brian Cashman may actually prioritize than as evidence that a move is close. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Legend Calls Out A Clubhouse Problem Fans Know Too Well
CC Sabathia has weighed in on the Yankees in a way that will sound familiar to plenty of fans who have watched this club stumble through too many stretches where the on-field talent never seems to match the noise around it. The former ace pointed to a clubhouse culture that he believes has lost some of the accountability it once had, saying the Yankees no longer have the same kind of veteran presence they used to count on when figures such as Derek Jeter and Mariano Rivera were still around.
The concern is less about one bad series or one hot week and more about whether the current group is holding itself to the right standard behind the scenes. David Ortiz and ESPN analyst Buster Olney both added to that conversation by stressing that players need to be more invested in one another and in the expectations that come with wearing a Yankees uniform, leaving the broader question of how that gets rebuilt still hanging over the team. [Read more 🡒]