The Yankees’ latest October exit has once again put Brian Cashman in the crosshairs, but one of baseball’s most recognizable executives sees the situation very differently.
Billy Beane, the former Oakland Athletics general manager who became the face of the Moneyball era, didn’t just defend Cashman in a recent interview - he went all the way to the top. Beane, now an A’s minority owner and senior adviser, said his longtime rival belongs in a class of his own.
“Cash is the greatest general manager in the history of the game,” Beane said to NJ.com. “He has more championships (four) than any GM in the game today.
He has more 100-win seasons (seven) than anyone else. More regular-season victories (2685).
The fact that Brian has been doing this with one team longer than anyone else is pretty remarkable.”
That kind of praise lands in sharp contrast to the mood around the Yankees after another season that ended without a title. New York won 93 games, swept Boston in the wild-card round, then got rolled by Tampa Bay in a three-game American League Division Series. The Yankees scored just five runs in 27 innings against the Rays after putting up 18 runs in two games against the Red Sox.
For fans frustrated by the franchise’s 17-season championship drought, the postseason collapse revived the same familiar questions about roster building, defense and whether regular-season success is enough. Owner Hal Steinbrenner answered with continuity. Cashman agreed to a new contract on Oct. 21, and manager Aaron Boone is set to return in 2027.
Beane’s view is built on the idea that October can warp the conversation. In his eyes, a short series can flatten the value of six months of work, especially in a format that gives more teams a shot at knocking off clubs with better records.
The Yankees’ record under Cashman gives Beane plenty to point to. Since taking over as general manager in 1998, Cashman has never overseen a losing season. New York has won 15 AL East titles and reached seven World Series during his tenure, with four championships coming before 2010.
Still, Beane didn’t ignore the obvious frustration. The Yankees haven’t won the World Series since 2009, and the repeated trips to October have not produced another parade.
He also pushed back against the idea that a power-heavy offense is a flaw by itself. Beane argued that teams that out-homer their opponents usually win, and he pointed to Milwaukee’s home run edge during its 2026 championship run.
The 2026 ALDS, though, offered the counterargument in brutal fashion. New York committed four errors in Game 2 and never held a lead in the series. Tampa Bay finished 4 1/2 games ahead of the Yankees in the AL East and won seven of 13 regular-season meetings.
Beane also gave a window into the kind of operator Cashman has been for decades. He described a GM with an almost unnerving memory and a habit of keeping notes from conversations, even with friends.
“Brian’s mind is like a steel trap, ” Beane said. “The little bastard keeps notes on every conversation he’s ever had - including with his friends. He’ll say, ‘You told me this in 2007’ - and of course he’s always right.”
That’s the part of Cashman that rivals respect: the preparation, the recall, the constant attention to detail. But in New York, that only goes so far.
The Yankees’ postseason numbers tell the story as clearly as anything else. They scored 9-0 and 9-2 wins over Boston in the wild-card round, then crashed to 1.67 runs per game against Tampa Bay.
Aaron Judge’s postseason absence after a calf injury only made the offensive drop-off more severe. And with free-agent decisions ahead and changes coming on the coaching staff, Cashman’s role in shaping the next roster matters just as much as the debate over his legacy.
Steinbrenner has already chosen the path of continuity. Beane’s endorsement gives that decision a prominent ally from outside the organization. But for Yankees fans, the argument remains the same: respect for the process is one thing, and championships are another.
In Other News...
Yankees Face A Massive Gunnar Henderson Decision With Their Future At Stake
The idea of the Yankees making a run at Gunnar Henderson has become one of the more intriguing possibilities on the board, and it makes sense why. He is already performing like a centerpiece, and with contract control through 2028, he would give New York the kind of long-term answer at shortstop that teams spend years trying to find. For a club that always has to weigh present urgency against future planning, Henderson checks a lot of boxes at once.
The catch is the price. A deal with Baltimore would likely require the Yankees to part with multiple top prospects, which is exactly the kind of move that can reshape a farm system in a hurry. The Orioles have shown a willingness to listen on trades, though not when it comes to first baseman Pete Alonso, and that only sharpens the focus on how aggressive New York wants to be. For the Yankees, the real question is whether adding Henderson now is worth the kind of prospect loss that could echo for years. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Suddenly Have A Real Shot At An Infield Upgrade
The Yankees are at least worth watching here, because Oaklands willingness to listen on Jacob Wilson opens a door that did not seem especially wide a short time ago. The Athletics are looking to strengthen their starting pitching, and that is the kind of need New York can potentially help address if it decides to get aggressive with its pitching inventory.
Wilson is not being shopped in a rush, and the As have made clear they do not have to move him. Still, the fact that they would consider offers gives the Yankees a possible path to an infield upgrade if the right package comes together, even if nothing has been finalized and the talks remain in the early stages. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Fans Still Feel Relief Over These Recent Departures
For a fan base that has spent plenty of time second-guessing roster moves, there is at least a little comfort in looking back at a few recent Yankees departures and feeling better about what came next. Jazz Chisholm Jr., Mark Leiter Jr., Devin Williams, Gleyber Torres, Alex Verdugo and Frankie Montas all passed through the Bronx with varying degrees of expectation, but the common thread was frustration. Some never found a consistent rhythm, some arrived with bigger reputations than results, and some simply left behind more questions than lasting memories.
The reaction from the stands has been telling, because these exits were not met with much regret. In a market that remembers both production and disappointment, the Yankees recent turnover has mostly been viewed through the lens of relief, especially when the performances never matched the hype or the role never quite fit. For a team that is always trying to balance urgency with patience, the fan response says plenty about how quickly a player can lose the benefit of the doubt in New York. [Read more 🡒]