Ben Rice’s season has become a study in contradiction, and Saturday in Toronto only sharpened the split.
The Yankees first baseman-turned-DH squared up two balls against the Blue Jays and got nothing for it. One came off his bat at 105.4 mph and disappeared into center field.
The other reached the warning track in right before dying in a glove. By the end of the night, Rice was hitless for the second straight game, and New York had dropped its third in a row, 4-1.
That’s the frustrating part for the Yankees: the swings still look dangerous, but the damage keeps missing. Rice’s season now lives in two very different places at once.
On one side is the version that looked like an All-Star, with a .883 OPS, fifth-best in the American League, and 32 home runs, third-most in the league. On the other is the recent stretch that has dragged his production into a ditch.
Over his last 21 games, Rice has hit .130, with 10 hits in 77 at-bats, a .494 OPS and two home runs. Expand it to 46 games, and the line is still rough: .193 with a .694 OPS and 10 homers.
The season totals still scream breakout. The recent numbers say something else entirely.
That disconnect is what makes this such a tricky read for the Yankees. Rice isn’t flailing around and missing everything.
He’s hitting the ball hard and watching it get tracked down. Against Toronto, that was the whole story.
New York didn’t have much else going Saturday. The Yankees managed four hits, all singles, against a Blue Jays bullpen game.
Rookie shortstop George Lombard Jr. drove in the lone run. Cam Schlittler gave them 5 1/3 innings of one-run ball and struck out seven, and it still wasn’t enough.
The loss dropped the Yankees to 68-55, second in the AL East and six games behind the Tampa Bay Rays.
Rice’s slump has become more than a bad week. It has stretched across the calendar, and the timing matters.
He was mashing earlier in the year, when the lineup around him was healthier. Now he’s doing it in a Yankees order that has been among the worst in the majors since Aaron Judge went down.
Manager Aaron Boone is seeing the same thing everyone else is seeing: hard contact, wrong angles.
“Definitely been going through it here in the second half,” Boone said. “Just getting under some balls or getting on top of balls. Just got to make sure he gets on a line.”
Rice isn’t backing off from the idea that the swing is still there. After the loss, he said he feels good even if the results haven’t matched.
“I’ve felt increasingly good,” Rice said. “Over the last couple series, I feel like the swing has felt good and I’m hitting some balls hard, not getting rewarded for it.
Just got to keep going. That’s literally the only thing you can do is just keep going.
It’s all you can do in this game.”
There’s also the position issue underneath all of this. Since the Yankees acquired Luis Garcia Jr. at the trade deadline, Rice has been pushed almost entirely to designated hitter.
He reached his 57th game at DH and has only played first a handful of times since. His splits suggest the change may matter: .270 with a .561 slugging percentage in 229 plate appearances at first base, compared with .244 and a .520 slugging percentage in 249 plate appearances as the DH.
The Yankees have still kept him there. Rice has graded as a poor defender at first, even if he has only three errors in more than 455 innings. So the glove question has been set aside, at least for now.
The roster picture keeps getting more crowded, too. Cody Bellinger, out with a hamstring strain, is expected to start a rehab assignment next week.
Giancarlo Stanton, recovering from a calf strain, stayed back at Yankee Stadium and continued his running progression, which now includes the bases. Aaron Judge is still working back from a fractured rib.
All of that only raises the stakes for Rice. More healthy bats mean more pressure on the DH spot he has been occupying.
If he snaps out of this, the decision gets easier. If not, the Yankees have a real problem on their hands.
For now, they’re banking on the contact and waiting for the hits to follow. That was the bet Saturday, and it came up empty again.
In Other News...
Yankees Fans Just Got A Bittersweet Didi Gregorius Update
Didi Gregorius has officially retired from professional baseball, closing the book on a career that took him from the majors to the Mexican League and, most recently, to the Netherlands in the World Baseball Classic. For Yankees fans, the news lands with a little extra weight because Gregorius remains best known for his five seasons in New York, where he became a steady presence at shortstop from 2015 to 2019.
His MLB run stretched across 11 seasons and also included stops with the Reds, Diamondbacks and Phillies, but the Yankees years are the ones that still shape how he is remembered in the Bronx. Gregorius finished with a .257 batting average, 134 home runs and 530 RBIs in 1,077 games, a solid career line for a player whose time in pinstripes gave the club one of its more dependable everyday performers of that era. [Read more 🡒]
LeMahieu Just Added An Awkward Twist To His Yankees Exit
DJ LeMahieu found a different kind of success in his first season as a manager, leading the Royal Oak Leprechauns to a Northwoods League championship and adding a new line to a baseball rsum that already had plenty of major league mileage. After years with the Yankees, the veteran infielder has shifted into a dugout role and immediately shown he can still guide a team through a long summer grind, with the Leprechauns leaning on the kind of grit and consistent effort he said carried them all the way to the title.
For Yankees fans, the awkward part is what comes next. LeMahieu was released by New York in 2025 and never played another major league game, but the financial piece of his departure has not fully disappeared, since he is still being paid by the Yankees under his existing contract. So while his on-field exit from the organization is already in the rearview, the last chapter of his Yankees tenure is still showing up in the team's books. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Prospect Is Forcing A Tough Debate About The Teams Future
Luis Durangos rise through the Yankees system has become one of the more intriguing development stories in the organization this season. The 23-year-old outfielder has hit .338/.396/.411 across three levels while swiping 43 bases, and his style is hard to miss: a high-contact approach built more around putting the ball in play and using the ground than trying to drive it over the fence. It is the kind of profile that can stand out in an era obsessed with power, especially when it keeps producing against better competition.
The debate for the Yankees is less about whether Durango has improved and more about how much of this can carry over to the majors. His unconventional swing path draws obvious comparisons to Ichiro Suzuki, but there are real questions about whether his body type and contact-first game will translate the same way against big league pitching. For an organization always weighing present needs against future upside, Durango has made himself impossible to ignore, even if the answer on his long-term fit is still unsettled. [Read more 🡒]