Anthony Volpe’s path with the Yankees got a lot less cloudy by the end of the season, even after what had been his roughest year in the Bronx.
The 25-year-old endured a major step back in 2025, struggling at the plate and in the field while also trying to play through a shoulder injury that eventually required surgery. The season reached a low point when the Yankees brought up George Lombard Jr. and optioned Volpe to Triple-A, a move that made his standing with the club look shaky at best.
But that stint in the minors clearly mattered. Volpe returned with a rebuilt swing and a little more flexibility around the diamond, then went .348 over his next seven games while handling second base cleanly. He cooled off before the postseason, but he still made his mark in the winner-take-all Game 3 of the ALDS.
That night featured the play everyone noticed first: a fan-interference RBI double in the sixth inning that had originally been scored as a game-tying two-run homer. Volpe also scored on Spencer Jones’ double after opening the sequence with an infield single, and later shifted to third base, where he picked up his first MLB putout at the position.
The finish wasn’t as clean. Volpe ended his night by striking out in a seven-pitch battle with Bryan Baker in the ninth inning.
Still, the larger point is hard to miss. Volpe’s late push came in a tiny sample, and the Yankees shouldn’t hand him anything simply because he flashed for a stretch. But after the way his season went, he looked like a player who was running out of chances - and did enough to earn another one next year.
The roster picture could help him, too. The Yankees are likely to let Jazz Chisholm Jr. walk in free agency after a deeply disappointing season, and they might eat the rest of Ryan McMahon’s contract just to move on from him.
That would clear openings at second and third base. If you ignore the pending free agents on the roster, Volpe would be the team’s starting second baseman right now.
Even so, the Yankees still need help at both spots. Luis Arraez is set to be the top second baseman on the market, and Gleyber Torres, a familiar name, should be available too. At third base, the free-agent board is thin, though the Yankees could take a shot at Japanese star Teruaki Sato or work the trade market for a bigger move.
Addressing only one of those positions feels more likely than fixing both, which leaves Volpe with a real lane to compete. Jose Caballero also remains under team control through 2030, so Volpe won’t be handed anything at either second or third.
That’s where things stand now: the Yankees want more than a brief late-season spike, but they also have a player who found something that worked when it mattered. Volpe’s next chapter will come down to whether that offensive surge is real enough to stick.
In Other News...
Yankees Suddenly Have A Real Third Base Debate On Their Hands
The Yankees postseason infield issues have left them with a familiar dilemma at third base: keep leaning on Ryan McMahons glove, or chase more offense and risk giving up some of the defense that helped stabilize the position. McMahon remains under contract through 2027, but his bat has not matched the kind of production New York wants from the hot corner, so the front office is at least weighing outside answers instead of treating the spot as settled.
One name to watch is Teruaki Sato, a Japanese third baseman who has drawn attention from multiple MLB teams after a huge season at the plate. Even with the appeal of his offense, there are real hurdles before anything becomes concrete, and the Yankees would also have to account for the adjustment risk that comes with bringing in a player from overseas and asking him to handle third base in New York. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Face A Costly David Bednar Decision With Mets Watching
After a season in which David Bednar stabilized the late innings for the Yankees, the club is suddenly staring at a familiar offseason question: how far is it willing to go to keep its closer in pinstripes? Bednar is a free agent, and the Yankees have to weigh whether to extend a qualifying offer while also sorting out the bigger picture of bullpen construction and the rest of their winter plans.
The interest around him does not stop in the Bronx, either, which only raises the stakes for a decision that could ripple beyond one roster spot. The Mets have been mentioned as a possible suitor, but for now that remains just speculation, with no reported contact or offer, leaving the Yankees to decide whether they want to bet on continuity before the market has its say. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Offseason Blueprint Signals A Roster Reset Fans Saw Coming
The Yankees postseason exit has already turned the conversation toward 2027, and the early read on the roster is pretty clear: there is work to do, especially in the bullpen. The relief group is a priority because the front office will have to sort through uncertainty around David Bednar and Paul Blackburn, both of whom are headed for free agency, while also considering outside help if the market offers the right fit.
Second base and catcher are part of the same larger reset, with the club weighing its internal options alongside possible additions. Anthony Volpe remains in the mix, Ryan Jeffers is among the names being floated behind the plate, and the broader picture suggests a roster that may look meaningfully different by the time the next run begins. [Read more 🡒]