Anthony Volpe’s late-season move to second base gave the Yankees something to think about, but it shouldn’t be enough to hand him the job outright.
After starting 2026 with plenty of heat on him from the New York fan base, Volpe found a second life once the Yankees sent him to Triple-A Scranton/Wilkes-Barre in August to work on his game. He resurfaced in the Bronx as an unexpected favorite when the club used him at second base during its late push, and that stretch was enough to get some people talking about him as the answer there next season.
That might be getting ahead of things.
Volpe absolutely showed he can handle the spot in a limited sample. When Jazz Chisholm Jr. went down with a hand injury in September, the Yankees turned to Volpe at second, and the 25-year-old responded with a revamped swing and a noticeably more comfortable look on the field. In 12 regular-season games at the position, he held his own on both sides of the ball.
But 12 games is 12 games. That’s not enough to declare him the full-time solution, especially with the Yankees having other paths to explore this offseason.
Chisholm Jr.’s future with the team is still unresolved, and general manager Brian Cashman could soon extend a qualifying option to him. There’s also the possibility of a trade for an established second baseman, including Xavier Edwards of the Miami Marlins.
In other words, the Yankees have choices. Volpe should be one of them, not the only one.
The case for him is real. Even in Triple-A this past season, he started only 19 games at second, so the club still doesn’t have a full read on how he’d handle the position over a full year.
Still, there’s reason to believe the fit could work. His arm strength has never been a strength, and at second base that might actually help him.
Shorter throws could reduce the kind of short-hopping issues that showed up often when he was playing shortstop.
That’s part of why the move has some appeal. Volpe has always been viewed as a major talent, and the Yankees treated him that way when they made him their answer at shortstop in 2023 after Isiah Kiner-Falefa drew criticism from fans. His fielding résumé is strong enough to back that up: +26 Defensive Runs Saved over his four-year career and a Gold Glove in 2023.
But the mistakes have piled up too. Volpe has gone through stretches of shaky defense during his Yankees tenure, whether from the arm or from something that looked a lot like the yips.
And because his bat never took off the way the organization hoped, those errors stood out even more. His career .661 OPS just didn’t come close to matching the standard Yankees fans expect from a shortstop, a standard forever shaped by Derek Jeter.
That pressure matters. It hangs over every shortstop in New York, where even routine hustle plays can get labeled “Jeter-esque.”
Volpe may not have to carry that burden at second base, and that alone could help him settle in. He looked a little more at ease there in 2026, and that counts for something.
Still, the Yankees can’t treat that late run as proof. They need to run through every option at second base before settling on anything for 2027.
Free agency, trade market, internal answers - all of it should be on the table. Volpe deserves a fair shot.
He just doesn’t deserve the job by default.
In Other News...
Yankees Risk Another Costly Fit Chasing Right-Handed Help For Judge
The Yankees are already looking at ways to reshape their offense around Aaron Judge after another early postseason exit, and the front offices priorities are clear: add a right-handed bat that can make the lineup less predictable. One name that has surfaced is Teoscar Hernandez, whose power and World Series experience would give New York a more proven middle-of-the-order option if the Dodgers were willing to deal him.
The fit is not as simple as the bat speed suggests. Hernandez comes with defensive limitations, a hefty salary for his lone remaining guaranteed season, and some recent slippage in home run production, all of which make him a more complicated target than a quick fix. For a Yankees club trying to build a deeper, more balanced attack around Judge, the question is whether the upside is worth the cost and the risk. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Prospect Dax Kilby Is Forcing A Much Bigger Conversation
Dax Kilbys Arizona Fall League run is doing more than helping him shake off a lost season. After missing most of 2026 with a hamstring injury, the Yankees prospect has come back looking sharper at the plate, hitting .288/.350/.558 with two home runs through 13 games while showing the kind of swing adjustments that can change how evaluators view a player in a hurry.
Eric Longenhagen has already taken notice, praising Kilbys progress and projecting him as a potential top-20 prospect when the next rankings come out. For a Yankees system always under the microscope, that kind of leap matters because it shifts Kilby from a name to monitor into one that could force a much bigger conversation about where he fits in the organizations long-term plans. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Are Being Warned Away From 3 Tempting Trade Targets
As the Yankees sort through an offseason that could shape the next phase of their roster, not every tempting name on the trade market deserves serious pursuit. CJ Abrams, Hunter Goodman and Spencer Torkelson all make sense at first glance, but each comes with a different kind of caution flag, whether it is Abrams defensive questions and likely price tag, Goodmans swing-and-miss issues and the Coors Field effect on his power numbers, or Torkelsons fit on a club already carrying depth at first base and designated hitter.
For a team trying to balance urgency with long-term planning, the better path may be to resist the urge to shop for a quick fix and instead keep leaning into internal options. George Lombard Jr. and Spencer Jones are among the players the Yankees can continue developing, and that approach carries its own risk, but it also avoids paying for a trade target who may not solve the problem cleanly enough to justify the cost. [Read more 🡒]