Anthony Volpe Is Forcing Yankees To Revisit A Tough Decision

While Jasson Dominguez draws lofty comparisons between Anthony Volpe and Barry Bonds, the Yankees' emerging star may soon prove his mettle beyond Triple-A.

Anthony Volpe’s bat is making noise in Triple-A, and Jasson Domínguez just turned that noise into a headline.

Volpe has been on a ridiculous tear for Scranton/Wilkes-Barre, homering five times over his last five games entering Saturday. That kind of run is hard to ignore anywhere, but especially for a player whose major league track record has been under a microscope. Domínguez, watching it unfold from the same clubhouse, reached for the biggest comparison possible.

"He became Barry Bonds all of a sudden," Jasson Domínguez said of Anthony Volpe, who entered today with 5 HR in his last 5 G at Triple-A.

The Martian added that Volpe is "working his ass off to to get better." #Yankees

  • Gary Phillips (@GaryHPhillips) September 5, 2026

Domínguez was clearly joking around, but the point behind it lands. Volpe has been overwhelming Triple-A pitching, and right now he looks like a hitter who is simply too locked in for that level. For a former first-round pick, it’s a reminder that the bat talent everyone once talked about is still in there.

The Yankees, of course, are not short on moving parts. They’re set at shortstop with George Lombard Jr., but Volpe could still factor at second base if New York wants another look at him in September or October.

Third base, though? That’s not the place to go.

His glove is not what’s driving the conversation anyway. It’s the bat, and the numbers in Scranton back it up. Volpe has 11 homers and a .948 OPS in 139 at-bats this year, and his recent power binge has pushed some to argue he’d be a better platoon option than Amed Rosario right now.

That’s where the debate gets interesting. Volpe’s critics can point to the .224 career MLB batting average, the .660 career OPS, and the defense that has dipped since his 2023 Gold Glove season. Those concerns aren’t going away just because he’s tearing up Triple-A.

But the flip side is impossible to dismiss: he’s producing loudly after a demotion that could have rattled him. Instead, he’s answered with authority.

Volpe never matched the 21 home runs from his rookie season in any of his next MLB campaigns, which led plenty of people to treat that year like the outlier. Now, at least for the moment, he’s giving the Yankees a reason to wonder if the power is coming back.

Domínguez’s Barry Bonds line was exaggerated, sure. But it also captured the larger story: Volpe is seeing the ball well, hitting it hard, and reminding everybody that there’s still real offensive upside here. For a Yankees club thinking about a playoff push in 2026, that matters.

In Other News...

Yankees Have A Surprise Pitching Option As Return Timelines Drag On

The Yankees are still sorting through the ripple effects of a roster that has been stretched by injuries and rehab timelines, and the next move may come from an unexpected place. After optioning rookie Elmer Rodriguez to Triple-A, the club is weighing right-hander Trevor MacGregor, a non-roster arm with no major league experience, as a possible solution while it waits for more established pieces to work their way back.

Aaron Judge and Clarke Schmidt are both expected to return soon, but neither is an immediate answer because their rehab work is still ongoing. New York also has no opening on its 40-man roster, which means any eventual return will require another move, and that leaves the Yankees juggling short-term pitching needs against the longer view of getting key players back without boxing themselves in. [Read more 🡒]

Yankees Still Face One Aaron Judge Concern Boone Couldnt Dodge

The Yankees wrapped up their California trip at 3-3 after a 4-3 loss to the Padres, but the bigger storyline remained Aaron Judges slow march back from a stress fracture in his right rib. Judge has been out since May 31, yet he has started ramping up again with batting practice and defensive work, signs that his recovery is moving in the right direction even if the club is still keeping its timeline guarded.

New York opened a roster spot by optioning pitcher Elmer Rodrguez to Triple-A, which only sharpened the focus on Judges status. The next checkpoint is expected to be live pitching, a meaningful step for a lineup that has felt his absence for weeks, but the Yankees still have not put a return date on him. [Read more 🡒]

Yankees Just Reopened A Giancarlo Stanton Decision That Changes Everything

Giancarlo Stantons rehab has kept him in the conversation around the Yankees even as the roster picture has stayed crowded. Aaron Boone said Stanton has not been ruled out for the season after the slugger picked up a right-calf strain, and Stanton has already been back in the cage hitting as he works his way forward.

The harder part is not the bat, but the path back onto the active roster. The Yankees do not have room for him right now, so any return will hinge on the kind of roster moves and injuries that can change a clubs depth chart in a hurry, which is why Stantons status keeps circling back into bigger questions about his future in New York. [Read more 🡒]