PHOENIX - Luke Pettitte’s path to the draft took a hard turn when his arm gave out, but that detour may have revealed something even bigger about his game.
The 21-year-old Dallas Baptist product, son of Yankees and Astros pitching great Andy Pettitte, went into last year expecting to build his future on the mound. Instead, a stress fracture in his back and then Tommy John surgery shut down that plan, and with it any realistic shot at pitching before he became draft eligible this July.
“It was brutal. I got the MRI back.
I remember I just broke down,” Luke Pettitte said. “It was just reinstating in my mind that I’m gonna be fine.”
What followed was the surprise. While his pitching future was on hold, Pettitte got a real look at what he could do as a hitter against Division I arms, and the results were loud. In 42 games as DBU’s DH this season, he hit 16 home runs and posted a 1.096 OPS.
That kind of production has forced a rethink. Andy Pettitte said his son would have told you six months ago that he only wanted to pitch, but the bat has changed the conversation.
“If you would have asked him about (hitting professionally) six months ago, he would tell you, ‘No, I just want to pitch,’” Andy Pettitte said, who also coached his son throughout high school. “But I think he’s gotten a lot of confidence in what he was able to do with the bat.
“We’ll see how it all plays out, but I think that he would love to have the opportunity to see where that goes.”
Different teams are seeing him differently, too. Pettitte said the Astros view him strictly as a pitcher, while other clubs are open to letting him try both.
He believes he would have been a third-round pick if he had stayed healthy and pitched all season, but as of mid-June he expected to go somewhere between the fourth and ninth rounds. Whether a team calls him a pitcher, a hitter or a two-way player is still up in the air.
“I think the biggest thing is just letting the game dictate,” Pettitte said. “A lot of (teams) say they let guys do both for as long as they can, and the game will end up making the decision for them. I’m kinda just waiting for that to happen.”
The baseball roots run deep in the family. Luke will be the third of three sons to play at a high level.
Jared Pettitte, 28, spent two seasons in the Marlins’ system after signing as an undrafted free agent and reached Low A. Josh Pettitte, 31, was drafted by the Yankees in the 37th round out of high school in 2013 but didn’t sign, later pitching one season at Rice and never reaching pro ball.
Luke, though, may have the best chance to carry the family name forward. He was 8 when Andy’s MLB career ended, so he doesn’t remember much of it firsthand, but he knows the pedigree. That hasn’t stopped the father-son back-and-forth over baseball.
“In my mind, I’m like, ‘I got this figured out. You’re my dad.
I don’t want to hear it,’” Luke said. “But a part of me is like, ‘This guy did it for 18 years at the highest level, I should probably listen to him.’”
Andy said he tries not to load his kids with expectations, and he’s come to appreciate the way Luke has handled the setbacks. On the pitching side, he said, it’s hard to fully enjoy it until the arm is completely out of the game. The bat, though, is easier to watch.
“You really can’t enjoy (him pitching) until he’s completely out of the game,” Andy said. “The hitting side of it, I feel like, is much easier to watch. I mean, he’s got a really good approach.”
Pettitte was already a strong hitter in high school, and when he arrived at Dallas Baptist, the idea was initially that he could play first base. But the Patriots’ lineup was crowded, and he ended up moving into a full-time pitching role.
This season, it took about a month for him to realize the bat might be more than a side note. Then came a stretch of eight homers in 16 games, and the thought hit him: “Shoot, maybe I can do this.”
“I definitely surprised myself,” Pettitte said. “I knew I could hit, but I didn’t think I could do what I did this year, especially for not hitting in two years.
I hadn’t seen live pitching in a game setting since my senior year of high school. It definitely surprised all of us.”
He could have taken a different route after the surgery. Pettitte could have redshirted the 2026 season, pitched for DBU as a redshirt junior in 2027 and returned to the draft next summer with two years of eligibility left, giving him more leverage for a signing bonus. He also could have sat out the entire 2026 season, rehabbed and still entered this year’s draft as a pitcher.
Tommy John surgery is common enough that it doesn’t automatically erase a player’s draft value, and Pettitte is expected to be able to pitch again in about a month. But once he got the chance to hit this season, the injury started to look less like an ending and more like an opening.
“I’m just gonna be myself and play my game, and it’s either gonna bring me to the big leagues or it’s not,” Pettitte said. “I’m gonna have a minor-league career, or I’m gonna play 10-15 years in the big leagues. That’s my mindset.”
In Other News...
Yankees Suddenly Linked To A Catching Move Fans Would Absolutely Hate
The Yankees have spent plenty of time looking for ways to balance a roster that has often leaned too heavily to one side, and the catching situation is no exception. A right-handed bat behind the plate would make sense for a club that keeps circling back to lineup fit, and one possible trade target has enough offensive punch and edge to stand out if he ever became available.
What makes the idea interesting is that this is not just about filling a seat at catcher, but about adding a player with a left-handed swing, real production in expanded duty, and a fiery presence that would change the tone of the position. The catch, of course, is whether the timing ever lines up for a move and whether the Yankees would be willing to jump into a market where other clubs are already watching closely. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Fans Already Hate What The Rays Just Pulled In The Draft
The top of the 2026 MLB Draft went the way plenty of Yankees fans probably feared, with the first two picks both landing on shortstops and the division-rival Rays once again taking a swing at a premium up-the-middle talent. Chicago opened the night by taking UCLA shortstop Roch Cholowsky first overall, then Tampa Bay followed by adding another highly athletic shortstop to a system that has built a reputation for finding and developing this kind of player.
What makes it sting from the Yankees side is the familiar shape of it all. Tampa Bay got the type of prospect it tends to covet, the sort with a ceiling that draws obvious star-level comparisons, while New York has to sit and wait until No. 35 for its first selection. For a fan base already braced for the Rays to keep churning out impact talent, this was the kind of draft-night move that immediately set off the usual reaction: here we go again. [Read more 🡒]
Anthony Volpe Is Forcing A Yankees Decision Fans Wont Like
Anthony Volpes season has given the Yankees a familiar kind of dilemma: the glove is making the case, even if the bat still leaves plenty to be desired. After a rougher defensive showing last year, Volpe has taken a clear step forward at shortstop, enough that his overall value looks very different now than it did a season ago. For a player whose offensive inconsistency has been a constant talking point, that kind of bounce-back in the field changes the conversation around him.
It also complicates the long-term picture. If Volpe keeps defending at this level, the Yankees have a player who is easier to justify in the lineup and easier to imagine as a piece other clubs would want. At the same time, the organizations thinking at shortstop is not standing still, and that makes Volpes place in the future a little less settled than his recent play might suggest. [Read more 🡒]