Aaron Judge is back in the Yankees’ lineup, but the real story around his return is the tug-of-war over how much he should do and how fast he should do it.
Judge wants to get rolling like the star he is. Aaron Boone wants to keep a tight hand on the workload. That’s the tension as the Yankees chase the AL East with 18 regular-season games left and their three-time American League MVP back after an 84-game absence.
Tuesday at Yankee Stadium gave fans their first look at Judge since May 31, and 46,211 were there to see the Yankees beat Colorado 5-3. Judge hit third, played six innings in right field and went 0-for-3 with two strikeouts. Heliot Ramos, his replacement, delivered the swing that mattered most, a three-run homer in the eighth.
The comeback has been anything but automatic. Judge’s fractured right first rib traces back to a diving attempt in Houston on April 26.
He was reinstated from the 60-day injured list Monday, but even though he is asymptomatic, he still has to rebuild game-level endurance. The Yankees chose to do that in the majors instead of sending him out on a rehab assignment.
That decision came with built-in friction. After Trent Grisham re-injured his right hamstring Friday in San Diego, Judge went to Boone’s hotel door and offered to play the next day. Boone turned him down because Judge still had rehab boxes to check, including live hitting.
Judge had only resumed on-field batting practice that week. On Monday, he faced live pitching, ran the bases and went through defensive work at Yankee Stadium. Once the medical side cleared him, Boone checked with general manager Brian Cashman and owner Hal Steinbrenner before activating him.
Judge has made his preference clear all along. After Tuesday’s game, he said:
“I wanted to come back a couple months ago, but I’m not a trainer, so I gotta check whatever boxes they got.”
Boone still kept the reins. Before the game, he said Judge would leave early and get a day off during the Colorado series.
When Boone pulled him before the seventh with the Yankees ahead 2-1, the two talked at length on the dugout steps. Judge pointed to Cam Schlittler’s strong outing and questioned what the difference really was between six innings and nine.
Boone didn’t hide the reaction afterward.
“He was not real pleased with me for taking him out.”
Judge was frustrated, but he also made it clear he would follow the manager’s call.
“I respect Boonie so whatever he says I’m gonna do, but not happy about it.”
There’s no sign of a clubhouse split here, no evidence of anyone refusing instructions or teammates lining up on one side or the other. What exists is a star who wants to play every inning and a manager who isn’t willing to let that dictate the plan.
Tuesday showed both the upside and the downside of Boone’s approach. Judge got three plate appearances before Ramos took over. Then, in the eighth, Ben Rice walked, Cody Bellinger doubled and Ramos launched Brennan Bernardino’s pitch into a three-run homer that turned a 2-1 game into a 5-1 cushion.
That cushion mattered because Colorado kept coming. Hunter Goodman hit a two-run homer off Tim Hill in the ninth, but David Bednar struck out Mickey Moniak for his 32nd save.
Schlittler was excellent, improving to 13-6 after allowing one run on three hits in seven innings with 10 strikeouts and no walks. Gabriel Hughes dropped to 0-7.
Still, Boone’s choice came with a cost. Judge lost his fourth trip through the order, and that came with two runners in scoring position.
Ramos bailed the Yankees out this time. Nobody can promise that again, especially against a division opponent.
The urgency around Judge’s return is easy to understand from the numbers. The Yankees went 45-39 without him, compared with 36-23 through his last appearance.
During his absence, they ranked 26th in MLB in runs scored. Judge had been hitting .248 with 17 home runs, 38 RBIs and a .907 OPS in 59 games.
He also gives the lineup a right-handed force it badly needs. New York has been leaning lefty-heavy, with Rice and Bellinger batting ahead of Judge Tuesday and Luis García Jr. in the cleanup spot.
Boone plans to keep using Judge mostly in right field, which preserves some designated hitter flexibility. Spencer Jones has moved to center while Grisham remains sidelined.
The Yankees are also being careful on defense. Boone wants Judge in right field, but without unnecessary diving risks. The club says Judge is asymptomatic, though that doesn’t mean he’s ready for the grind of full games after three months away.
Judge said after the opener that the body felt good, even if the timing is still catching up.
“I felt great; I just haven’t been in a live game or seen live pitching in three months, so it’s kind of like the start of the year.”
New York enters Wednesday at 82-62, four games behind Tampa Bay and three ahead of Boston for the top AL wild-card spot. The Yankees have already locked up their 34th straight winning season, but the seeding race is still alive.
Colorado is back in the Bronx Wednesday with Will Warren set to face Tomoyuki Sugano. Boone has not publicly committed to Judge’s rest day. Then comes the Mets on Friday for a three-game Subway Series, another chance for the Yankees to see how this managed return holds up when the stakes and the spotlight rise.
For now, Boone has the final word. Judge may not love it, but he’s following it.
In Other News...
Yankees May Have Quietly Found Their Next Outfield Prospect To Watch
Yostin Pea has started to move from a name buried deep in the Yankees system to one worth tracking a lot more closely. The young outfielder has put together a strong run in the Dominican Summer League and Single-A, flashing the kind of power, speed and batting production that makes a player stand out even in the crowded early stages of a farm system.
Baseball Americas Josh Norris has already singled Pea out as a serious candidate to become the Yankees top prospect next year, with Dax Kilby also in that conversation. It adds another layer to Peas rise, considering he was once tied to a possible signing with the Cardinals before ultimately landing with New York, and now the Yankees may be the ones with an emerging outfield talent worth watching closely. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Have A Gerrit Cole Concern They Can't Ignore In October
Gerrit Cole is back on the mound for the Yankees after Tommy John surgery, and the encouraging part is easy to see: his fastball velocity has held up at roughly the same level it was before the operation. On the surface, that is exactly what New York needed from its ace as October approaches, especially with the club built to lean on frontline pitching when the games get tighter and every batter gets more expensive.
The deeper read is a little less comforting. Even with solid overall results, the underlying indicators have pointed to some vulnerability, including how often hitters are squaring him up and the way some of his breaking pitches have played. The Yankees do not need Cole to be perfect, but they do need confidence that his stuff will still miss bats and survive the kind of lineup pressure that defines the playoffs. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Bring Back Powerful 2001 Memories For Mets Game On 9/11 Anniversary
The Subway Series returns to Yankee Stadium on the 25th anniversary of the September 11 attacks, and the night will carry a weight well beyond the standings. Before the Yankees host the Mets, the organization plans a pregame ceremony to honor first responders and related organizations, while select alumni from the 2001 Yankees are set to take part in the tribute. Current players will also place a wreath at the September 11 monument in Monument Park, tying the present-day club to one of the most consequential days in franchise and city history.
For Yankees fans, the date instantly brings back the 2001 postseason run, when the team played through the emotional aftermath of the attacks and the World Series became part of the citys healing process. It also calls to mind President George W. Bushs ceremonial first pitch at Yankee Stadium, one of the defining images of that era. With the Mets coming across town on such a solemn anniversary, the game will be about more than baseball, and the atmosphere should reflect how deeply the memory of that fall still lingers in the Bronx. [Read more 🡒]