Aaron Judge was back in the Yankees’ lineup Tuesday night, and the scene at Yankee Stadium looked like it had been pulled straight out of 2022. The crowd rose to its feet, phones came out, and chants of “MVP…MVP” rolled down from the upper deck.
Then the noise stopped.
This time, the moment wasn’t about a home run chase. It was about what comes next for Judge and for the Yankees, with 18 regular-season games left and the playoffs waiting right around the corner.
Judge returned from the injured list after 99 days away, recovering from a fractured rib, and the Yankees beat the Rockies 5-3. But the win came with the same big-picture questions hanging over the club.
Is Judge ready-truly ready-to carry the Yankees toward a championship?
And if he isn’t at full Aaron Judge level, do the Yankees have any real chance against the Rays in the Division Series, or against one of the five National League powerhouses they could see in the World Series?
Judge didn’t exactly provide a booming answer at the plate. He went 0-for-3 with two strikeouts and said afterward, “I’ve got work to do,” and “I’ve got to improve.”
His first trip to the box was a reminder that even a player built like a force of nature doesn’t always look like one. Judge struck out on a 93-mph fastball from Gabriel Hughes, a rookie who entered the game with a 0-7 record and a 6.19 ERA. The cameras that had been lifted into the air came back down fast.
There would be no storybook blast. In the fourth inning, Judge got a pitch he seemed to drive, sending a towering fly ball to right-center, but it died at the warning track. Later, in his third and final at-bat, he was caught looking at a called third strike from left-hander Mark Manfredi.
Judge sounded upbeat enough about being back, saying he was “feeling great” at the plate and happy to return. But he also made it clear he wasn’t thrilled that Aaron Boone pulled him after six innings.
“I respect Booney, so whatever he says, I’m going to do,” Judge said, “But I’m not happy about it.”
He said it again moments later on YES Network: “I hope I’m playing every day,” Judge said. “We’ll see, but I’m not the manager, so you gotta talk to him. Hopefully, I can get more than six innings.”
That wasn’t insubordination. It was impatience.
Judge wants every at-bat he can get, because he knows there isn’t enough time to fully sharpen up before October. The Wild Card Series begins September 28, and the Yankees are almost certainly headed there, likely against the Red Sox.
Boone, though, is taking the long view and easing Judge back in carefully, almost as if it were spring training. September matters, but October is where the real accounting happens in the Bronx.
Tuesday’s win also locked in the Yankees’ 34th straight winning season, a streak that began in 1993. That’s the second-longest run in the four major sports, behind only the Yankees’ own 39 straight winning seasons from 1926-64.
But regular-season milestones don’t move the needle much in New York. Fans have seen plenty of winning summers.
Boone’s 761 career victories don’t change the bigger question, either. The standard is championships, and Boone still has none.
That’s why the Yankees are being careful with Judge. Boone knows the team goes nowhere without him healthy and locked in in the middle of the order.
And the rest of the picture isn’t exactly comforting. The Yankees have had a good, at times very good, summer, but this doesn’t look like one of those clubs that overwhelms everybody in October. Even the Red Sox loom as a threat, especially if their injured ace Garrett Crochet is back for the Wild Card Series.
The Rays are in front of the Yankees by four games in the East with 18 left, and while Tampa Bay has a tougher remaining schedule, the teams still have a four-game series from September 22-24. Even so, catching them looks like a long shot.
There are other warning signs, too. The Yankees are 36-36 against teams above .500, 15-17 in one-run games, and 2-10 in extra-inning games.
Judge can help fix a lot of that, but only if he gets back to being himself. He has 18 games to find another gear. If he doesn’t, another year of his prime could slip away.
In Other News...
Yankees May Have Quietly Found Their Next Outfield Prospect To Watch
Yostin Pea has put himself on the radar as one of the more interesting outfield names in the Yankees system, thanks to a strong run between the Dominican Summer League and Single-A. The early returns have shown the kind of mix clubs love to see in a young outfielder: power, speed, and a bat that has already produced at a healthy clip.
Baseball Americas Josh Norris recently singled Pea out as a player who could rise to the top of the Yankees prospect conversation next year, with Dax Kilby also in the mix. Peas path is worth watching for another reason, too, since he was once tied to a possible deal with the Cardinals before ending up in pinstripes, a turn that is starting to look increasingly important for New Yorks pipeline. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Bring Back Powerful 2001 Memories For Mets Game On 9/11 Anniversary
The Yankees and Mets will share a stage on Thursday night that carries far more weight than a typical subway series matchup. On the 25th anniversary of the September 11 attacks, Yankee Stadium will host a pregame ceremony honoring first responders and related organizations, while select alumni from the 2001 Yankees are set to take part in an evening designed to connect the present-day club with one of the most emotional periods in New York sports history.
Current Yankees players will also place a wreath at the September 11 monument in Monument Park, a quiet gesture with a powerful reminder behind it. The game arrives with memories still tied to the 2001 World Series, when baseball helped give the city a sense of rhythm in the weeks after the attacks, and to President George W. Bush's ceremonial first pitch at Yankee Stadium, one of the enduring images from that stretch. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Face A Risky Infield Call As Luis Garcia Jr. Keeps Rolling
With Jazz Chisholm Jr. on the injured list, the Yankees are choosing to keep Luis Garcia Jr. right where he has been thriving rather than ask him to shift from first base back to second. It is a small alignment decision on paper, but one that says plenty about how the club views Garcia right now after his productive start since arriving at the trade deadline.
Instead of moving him around the diamond, New York is covering second with Jose Caballero and Anthony Volpe, a setup that keeps Garcias bat in the spot the Yankees want most. It also leaves the club balancing short-term defensive flexibility against the risk of disrupting one of its steadier offensive additions at a time when every run still matters. [Read more 🡒]