Aaron Judge is back in the Yankees’ lineup, but the numbers from his first week tell the same story the eye test does: he’s playing, not quite rolling yet.
On Sunday, Judge went 0-for-3 with three strikeouts as New York beat the Mets 2-0 at Yankee Stadium. Cam Schlittler delivered six scoreless innings, Ben Rice and Austin Wells each homered, and David Bednar locked down his 34th save. The win pushed the Yankees to 86-63 and trimmed their postseason magic number to one.
Judge’s line since coming off the injured list on Sept. 8 is still a work in progress. In five games back after missing 84 games with a stress fracture in his right first rib, he’s 3-for-17 with one walk, nine strikeouts and no extra-base hits.
His OPS in that stretch is .398. The Yankees have gone 4-1 with him back, which has kept the slow start from turning into a bigger problem.
None of that is especially shocking. Judge hadn’t played since May 31, and the Yankees skipped the usual minor league rehab assignment.
Instead, he returned after batting practice, machine work and live pitching. With just 19 regular-season games left when he was activated, the club didn’t have much calendar to spare.
Sending the three-time AL MVP away for several days would have meant fewer chances to get him back in rhythm against major league arms.
So the rehab process moved into the games themselves. The Yankees accepted the rough at-bats because the alternative was even less time for Judge to sharpen up before October. That tradeoff is showing up now: New York keeps winning, and Judge is still trying to rediscover the pitch recognition and swing decisions that faded during his long absence.
The timing matters even more because the division race is still alive. The Yankees sit four games behind Tampa Bay in the AL East, and the final week could swing on their head-to-head meeting. There isn’t much margin left for Judge to work through the rust while the standings keep tightening.
In practical terms, the Yankees have given him a six-game runway before that showdown.
New York opens a three-game set in Minnesota on Monday, then heads to Arizona for three more from Sept. 18-20.
The club is off Sept. 21, and then Tampa Bay comes to Yankee Stadium for four games in three days starting Sept. 22.
Those games are not tune-ups. The Yankees are still chasing the division, and for Judge they function as the closest thing to a rehab assignment he never got: live reps against velocity, breaking stuff, different matchups and late-inning relievers.
The Rays have made the clock even less forgiving. They enter Monday at 90-59 after sweeping Houston, four games ahead of the Yankees, and they’ve already clinched a postseason berth. New York is close to joining them.
Tampa Bay also holds the upper hand in the season series, 6-3. With MLB no longer using a Game 163, the Rays need only one win in the final four meetings to secure the head-to-head tiebreaker.
If the Yankees want the season series, they have to sweep all four games Sept. 22-24.
That stretch includes a split doubleheader created by the May 23 rainout, plus single games on Sept. 23 and Sept. 24.
That’s why the next week carries so much weight. A slow first few games back was manageable. A slow final stretch before Tampa Bay would be a lot harder to stomach.
The Yankees have already shown they can keep winning while their captain works his way back. Their pitching has held the line, and Rice, Wells and others have picked up enough slack to keep the club in strong shape.
That gives Aaron Boone some breathing room. Judge does not have to carry the lineup right away.
But the standard changes quickly now. The Yankees are close to clinching a playoff berth, and the conversation shifts from just getting there to how they line up for the division and October.
When Judge is right, he changes everything. Pitchers have to be more careful.
The lineup gets deeper. One swing can decide a game.
Right now, he doesn’t look like that version yet.
So Sept. 22 is the real checkpoint. Minnesota and Arizona give the Yankees six games to see how much progress Judge can make while staying in the major league environment. Every plate appearance helps the team now and helps Judge get closer to the hitter New York needs when Tampa Bay arrives.
The Yankees didn’t wait for the Rays to bring Judge back. They brought him back early enough to give him a runway before the Rays.
That’s the whole plan. By the time Tampa Bay gets to Yankee Stadium, New York needs more than Judge’s name in the lineup. It needs his timing, his power and the version of Aaron Judge that can shape a season-defining series.
In Other News...
Derek Jeters Quiet 25-Year Yankees Bond Gives This 9/11 Tribute New Weight
The Yankees 9/11 remembrance at Yankee Stadium carried the kind of weight only time can deepen, especially with members of the 2001 team back on the field to honor first responders and mark the 25th anniversary of the attacks. One of the most personal moments came when Brielle Saracini, whose father was the captain of United Airlines Flight 175, threw the ceremonial first pitch with her husband, who also lost his father on 9/11.
Saracinis presence also underscored a quieter layer to the afternoon, one built on a long relationship with Derek Jeter that began when she was a child and has endured ever since. In a ceremony full of public remembrance, that private bond gave the tribute an extra measure of meaning, a reminder that for some in the Yankees orbit, the connection to 9/11 has never really faded. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Dynasty Standard Looks Safer As Dodgers Face Ohtani Doubt
Shohei Ohtanis knee issues have become a nagging subplot for the Dodgers at the worst possible time, with the two-way star landing on the injured list after the problems first surfaced in June. Since then, his effectiveness has dipped both on the mound and at the plate, and the broader downturn in Los Angeles offense in the second half has only sharpened the sense that the reigning standard out West is suddenly looking more fragile.
Ohtani is eligible to return on September 23, but the bigger question is what kind of impact he can still make if October arrives with the Dodgers still leaning on him to be their difference-maker. For a Yankees team that measures dynasties by how long they can keep pressure on the rest of the sport, the uncertainty around Ohtani only adds to the idea that the old benchmark is holding up a little better while a new one tries to stay healthy enough to catch it. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees May Be Letting A Dynamic Star Drift Toward Free Agency
Jazz Chisholm Jr.s time on the Yankees injured list has added another layer to a season already shaped by uncertainty around his future. The dynamic infielder is sitting with a sprained right thumb, and the missed time matters because he is working through a contract year while trying to stay visible and productive for a club that has every reason to keep watching his development closely.
The bigger wrinkle is what has not happened behind the scenes. The Yankees and Chisholm have not opened formal extension talks, and general manager Brian Cashman has pointed to a club policy against early deals. Chisholms 2026 production has made the evaluation even trickier, with his power slipping while his stolen bases have climbed, leaving the front office to weigh a player whose value still feels very much in motion. [Read more 🡒]