Rangers Suddenly Have A New Goalie Debate Fans Will Love

Rookie goaltender Dylan Garand could soon join the ranks of Rangers' scoring netminders as the team navigates recent trades and injuries amidst Eastern Conference challenges.

The New York Rangers have already given fans two goalie goals at Madison Square Garden this season, and somehow the conversation has turned to whether there’s another one coming.

Igor Shesterkin made history on Oct. 1 in the home opener against the Tampa Bay Lightning, scoring the first goalie goal in Rangers history and the 21st by an NHL goaltender, including the Stanley Cup Playoffs. That moment looked like pure joy at the time. Eight days later, it came with a gut punch when Shesterkin tore up his knee and is now out for the season.

Then came Henrik Lundqvist on Sunday afternoon at the Rangers Alumni Classic at MSG, when the Hall of Famer sent one into an empty net. It won’t count in the record books, but it was still a scene worth savoring: Lundqvist dropping to the ice in mock shock, getting back up, and skating over to join the post-goal celebration with his teammates for the fist bumps.

For a goalie who built a Hall of Fame career on elite shot-stopping and became the winningest netminder in Rangers history, puck-handling was never really his calling card. He was never the guy you expected to see threatening an empty net.

Maybe retirement has unlocked a new side of The King.

If the Rangers are going to get another goalie goal, Dylan Garand feels like the best bet. The 24-year-old rookie has the kind of swagger that makes the idea believable, and he’s also shown real ability with the puck. His outlet passes, especially on Rangers power plays, have helped spring teammates and stand out as a real part of his game.

He’s not on Shesterkin’s level with the puck - very few goalies are - but Garand is good, and he looks like the kind of goalie who might actually try it. Even after a rough turnover against Connor McDavid that led to an Oilers goal early in the game last week, Garand answered in the second period with two aggressive clears up ice that showed he wasn’t backing away from the puck.

So if the Rangers are staring at an empty net on the other end, especially when Garand is in the crease at MSG, keep watching. He might be the one to make it a Rangers triple play of sorts.

The Rangers also made a minor-league goalie swap, acquiring Arvid Soderblom from the Chicago Blackhawks in exchange for veteran netminder Spencer Martin. With Igor Shesterkin officially placed on season-ending IR, the move comes as the team opens up significant salary-cap space.

Elsewhere around the Rangers, Tom Castro looked at the tests and challenges ahead after a strong first quarter of the season, while John Kreiser broke down a week that includes tough matchups against two of the best teams in the Eastern Conference. Lou DiPietro also noted that the upcoming break in the schedule affects when Sean Durzi gets activated off injured reserve.

Around the NHL, Sportsnet’s Elliotte Friedman said the Ottawa Senators are looking to move struggling forward Andre Burakovsky and are also exploring additions to strengthen an already strong roster.

Friedman also reported that Flyers officials Danny Briere and Keith Jones traveled to Western Canada to meet Matvei Michkov on the team’s road trip, in part to tell him they have no intention of trading him. They also met with some of his younger teammates.

In New Jersey, James Nichols examined why Devils GM Sunny Mehta was right to have Connor Hellebuyck sit out his return to Winnipeg so he could be fresh for a home-and-home against the Washington Capitals, a series New Jersey swept with Hellebuyck in goal.

Sportsnet’s Justin Bourne offered five key takeaways as the NHL reached the quarter-mark of the 2026-27 season.

The Avalanche claimed veteran defenseman Mike Reilly off waivers from the Carolina Hurricanes after Cale Makar was ruled out for at least two weeks with a lower-body injury.

The Canadiens will be without Josh Anderson for 3-4 weeks because of a lower-body injury, and defenseman Mike Matheson is out 2-3 weeks with a lower-body injury as well.

The Athletic reported that Blue Jackets coach Rock Bowness stepped away from day-to-day duties because of health concerns, though he could return later this week.

And TSN reported that former player agent and Maple Leafs assistant GM Bill Watters died at 83. In later years, Watters became a familiar voice and presence on TSN, Sportsnet, and NHL Network Radio.

In Other News...

Rangers Were Right To Move On From A Painful What-If

Filip Chytils time with the Rangers always carried a sense of unfinished business, shaped as much by what he might have become as by what he was able to give them. Over eight seasons in New York, injuries repeatedly interrupted his progress and kept him from getting the kind of runway that would have made his future with the club easier to project. The Rangers eventually moved on, and Chytil is now with the Vancouver Canucks, a reminder of how often the organization had to weigh patience against practicality.

For a team trying to stay competitive, those decisions matter, especially when the roster around them keeps producing. New York has continued to find ways to win with other pieces, including J.T. Miller, while the Chytil chapter has become less a regret than a case study in why front offices cannot live forever on what-ifs. His story still lingers because of the talent that flashed through when he was healthy, but the Rangers have moved into a different phase, one where availability carries as much value as upside. [Read more 🡒]

Will Cuylle's Slide Just Made Rangers Decision Much Tougher

Will Cuylles first quarter of the season has made a once straightforward Rangers conversation a lot more complicated. After looking like a player whose next contract could be mapped out with some confidence, his scoring has dipped enough to lower his points-per-game pace and force the front office to reassess where he fits in the long-term picture.

The Rangers still have to decide how to approach his next deal, and the timing is awkward with teammate Tye Kartye turning in strong play and adding another layer to the discussion. Cuylles projected value sits around $6.5 million over four years, but the inconsistency has made both the term and the price feel less certain than they did earlier in the season. [Read more 🡒]

Rangers Just Made Igor Shesterkins Lost Season Even More Official

The Rangers have formally shifted Igor Shesterkin from long-term injured reserve to season-ending injured reserve, putting an official stamp on what had long felt inevitable after the lower-body injury he suffered in October. It is the latest sign of how far this season has drifted from the plan in net, where the club had already been operating without its No. 1 goalie for months.

For New York, the move also brings a practical benefit beyond the roster paperwork, opening up salary cap space by Shesterkins full cap hit. But the bigger takeaway is the one the Rangers have been trying to avoid since October: their season in goal is over with no chance of a late return, and the focus now shifts entirely to how they manage the rest of the year without him. [Read more 🡒]