With Igor Shesterkin out for the rest of the regular season, the Rangers suddenly have a massive question in goal - and one name that keeps popping up is Connor Hellebuyck.
The idea has obvious appeal. New York’s starter is sidelined after an injury he suffered last week, and general manager Chris Drury now has to decide whether to patch things together behind Dylan Garand or swing bigger and try to land a proven No. 1.
Hellebuyck, though, brings his own complications. He is sitting out after requesting a trade from the Winnipeg Jets, and like Shesterkin, he has term on his contract beyond this season.
That means any deal for him would not be a simple rental move. It would either set up a difficult decision in the summer or leave the Rangers trying to carry two elite goalies on the books.
On Tuesday’s episode of Daily Faceoff LIVE, Tyler Yaremchuk and Carter Hutton dug into whether that kind of move is even realistic.
Yaremchuk set the table by pointing to the obvious fit on paper, asking: “Let’s go to fill-in-the-blank, because I see the YouTube chat is buzzing with this, and I understand it’s kind of the logical thing to point a figure to, but the idea that the Rangers lost one of the best goalies in the sport, Igor Shesterkin, the other one, Connor Hellebuyck, he’s sitting at home with nothing to do. Call up the Winnipeg Jets. So let me throw you your first fill-in-the-blank, the Rangers getting Connor Hellebuyck would be [BLANK]?”
Hutton didn’t buy it.
“I think… not happening. I just don’t think it is.
I just think with the factor of how much they’d have to give up to get Hellebuyck, and he has term on his contract, right? So then you have to give up assets, you get him, and then you have Shesterkin back when he comes back next year?
There’s not enough seats at the table. I just don’t think it’s manageable to get Hellebuyck with what you’re going to give up to really help your team.
It’d be different if we were sitting here and this was the Carolina Hurricanes, and it’s like we’re trying to win a Stanley Cup. I still don’t think the Rangers are in that window, so I just think getting Connor Hellebuyck is kind of realistic, Ty.”
Yaremchuk agreed that the concept sounds far better in a video game than in real life.
“Yeah, I’ll say the Rangers getting Connor Hellebuyck would be cool if this was a video game. If you could just go to the trade finder and put in a couple of first-round picks, and yeah who cares?
It sounds great in theory, and it would be fun, and whatever, but you’re going to get him for one year, and then what? Next summer, all of a sudden the headache is on you to go and trade a goalie?
Then there’s also going to be the conversation, like you’re signing yourself up for a lot of drama I think, too.”
For now, the Rangers are left weighing whether to search for help in goal or trust Garand to handle the job while Shesterkin is out. The Hellebuyck option may be the splashiest one, but both voices on Daily Faceoff LIVE saw the same problem: it would take a lot to pull off, and even more to sort out afterward.
In Other News...
Rangers Bring Early Heat Back To MSG Against Tampa Bay
The Rangers are back at Madison Square Garden on Tuesday to face the Tampa Bay Lightning, and the building should again have the feel of a team that has started fast and fed off its home ice. New York is unbeaten in its four games at MSG so far, and the early numbers around the club have matched the eye test, with the Rangers sitting near the top of the league in a handful of key categories.
Alexis Lafrenire has been a big part of that surge, earning the NHLs Third Star of the Week after scoring in three straight games and giving New York another top-line threat to lean on. Tuesday also brings Hispanic Heritage Night to the Garden, with a pregame community program and a check presentation tied to the celebration, adding another layer to a matchup that already carries plenty of energy. [Read more 🡒]
Rangers Are Backing Up Contender Talk With A Start Fans Will Love
The early chatter around the Rangers as a contender is getting louder for a reason. They have opened the season undefeated in their first five home games, a start the franchise has matched only twice before, and they are pairing that kind of home-ice surge with production and structure across the board. New York sits atop the league with six wins and has also shown up near the top in goals against, goals scored and penalty kill percentage, which is the sort of across-the-board profile teams usually need if they want to look the part in the spring.
There has also been no shortage of individual momentum helping fuel it. Alexis Lafrenire, Dylan Garand, Mika Zibanejad, Adam Fox, Will Cuylle, J.T. Miller and Tye Kartye have all had notable stretches or milestones already, giving the roster a steady stream of contributors instead of leaning on one hot line or one standout night. Lafrenire, in particular, has become one of the most interesting pieces of that mix, and the way his scoring pace is building has added another layer to a team that is starting to feel like it may be backed by more than just a good first impression. [Read more 🡒]
Scott Morrow Is Stuck In A Rangers Roster Squeeze
Scott Morrow is still waiting for his first game of the season, and the logjam in front of him explains why. The Rangers have kept their blue line intact, with Sean Durzi and Braden Schneider both entrenched in the lineup, and there is little indication either one is headed for the press box anytime soon. For a club that has leaned on its defensive structure while searching for more consistency on the offensive side, Morrows profile still stands out as the kind of player who could help tilt the ice the other way.
The catch, of course, is that his game comes with questions on the defensive end, which makes the roster decision more complicated than simply finding an open spot. Unless the Rangers create room through an injury or a trade on the back end, Morrow may remain in a holding pattern while the group in front of him stays healthy and intact. For now, he is the lone skater on the roster without an appearance this season, which says as much about the teams depth chart as it does about his own place in it. [Read more 🡒]