The Rangers are already staring at a familiar problem, and it may be getting worse before it gets better: the top of next summer’s free-agent market is starting to close up on them.
Chris Drury has already done the heavy lifting on the roster retool. Artemi Panarin and Vincent Trocheck are gone, while Pavel Dorofeyev, Sean Durzi, and Marcus Pettersson are in.
That’s the pro roster as training camp gets closer, but it still leaves New York with a hole in the top six. Reporting around the team has made that clear.
The trade-off for moving on from Panarin and Trocheck was always going to be thinner forward depth, and even with Dorofeyev added, there’s still an opening. Unless a legitimate option pops up before the season starts, the Rangers may have to look inward.
If they’re thinking bigger picture, next summer was supposed to be the better swing.
That’s why Alex DeBrincat stood out as such a tempting target. He’s been one of the NHL’s most reliable scorers, and he just turned in a career season with 41 goals and 44 assists for 85 points in 82 games.
That kind of production would fit the Rangers’ need in a hurry. The price would be steep, but with the salary cap rising, a long-term deal could still age nicely.
The catch is that DeBrincat may never make it there.
During a recent appearance on NHL Network, Red Wings expert Bob Duff said the signs point toward DeBrincat staying in Detroit, helped by the fact that he’s a Michigan native and wants to keep his family close.
"From talking to Alex at the end of the season, he wants to be here," said Duff. "He's from Michigan.
He's a homebody. He likes having his family close.
He likes living here. He's got a wonderful home on waterfront property.
He's very, very happy here... Now, that being said, he also acknowledged it is a business and he's got to look out for himself and get paid.
So I think as long as the Wings are willing to pay him market value, I think he'll lean towards staying here. Again, if they want him, and I think they do."
That leaves Detroit holding the cards, and there are two important pieces to that puzzle. One is money: the market keeps moving, especially with the contracts being handed out this offseason, including Macklin Celebrini and Cale Makar.
The other is the front office situation. Steve Yzerman stepped down, so a new general manager will be the one deciding whether keeping DeBrincat is part of the plan.
If Detroit gets the price right and chooses to keep him, New York loses one of the cleaner answers it had circled.
And that would be a problem for a Rangers team that could be looking at a second straight summer with a weak forward market. This year, they hoped names like Connor McDavid, Jack Eichel, and Kirill Kaprizov might actually reach free agency. Instead, each of them signed extensions before last season began, and the Rangers pivoted to the trade market, which is how they landed Dorofeyev.
If DeBrincat comes off the board early, the list gets thin fast.
Nikita Kucherov is the headliner, fresh off a Hart Trophy-winning season, but the fit is hard to see. Would he really leave the Tampa Bay Lightning?
Would the Rangers want to hand out a massive deal to a player entering his age-34 season? The answer to both questions feels like no.
Mark Stone is next, but he’s been a fixture in Vegas since the 2018-19 season, and he’d be entering his age-35 season. On top of that, the Golden Knights look built to stay in the Cup picture for a long time.
Sidney Crosby is in the mix too, but he has been open about wanting to finish his career with the Pittsburgh Penguins. After Pittsburgh made the playoffs last season against the odds, that path seems even less likely to open up.
There is at least one name that looks more realistic: Drake Batherson.
The Senators winger has flown a little under the radar because of Brady Tkachuk and Tim Stutzle, but the production is there. Over the past four seasons in Ottawa, he has posted 267 points, with 109 goals and 158 assists, in 325 games.
That’s the kind of scoring punch plenty of teams would love in their top six. And there may be a path for him to reach the market, since Batherson and the Senators reportedly remain far apart in contract talks.
Jason Robertson is another possibility, though only if he wants out of Dallas.
Beyond that, the Rangers are looking at a fantasy land. McDavid or Auston Matthews would have to demand a trade from the Edmonton Oilers or Toronto Maple Leafs, respectively, for anything truly elite to shake loose. That’s the dream scenario, but it’s just that - a dream.
For now, DeBrincat still looks like the best fit on paper. But unless the situation changes dramatically, the Rangers may have to cross him off the board before free agency even begins.
In Other News...
Will Cuylle Faces A Rangers Role That Could Shape His Value
Will Cuylle spent much of the 2024-25 season in a familiar place on the Rangers third line, and that usage fit his game. His even-strength work stood out on the defensive side, where he looked more comfortable handling tougher minutes without the same offensive expectations that come with a top-six assignment. When he was pushed higher in the lineup, his production dipped, which only sharpened the conversation around where he can help this team most.
Next season, the Rangers appear set to keep Cuylle in that middle-six lane, even if he gets a look at one of the top spots in camp. Oliver Bjorkstrand is also in the mix for the last opening up front, and Cuylle should remain part of the penalty kill either way. If he lands back on the third line again, the matchups could be better for him and give him a cleaner path to building on the value he already showed. [Read more 🡒]
Rangers Near Another Forward Move As Drury Reshapes The Top Nine
The Rangers offseason push to remake their forward depth appears to be continuing, with another experienced winger reportedly on the verge of joining the mix. Eeli Tolvanen, who has spent time with both the Predators and Kraken and also skated for Finlands bronze medal-winning Olympic team, would fit the profile of the kind of low-cost, useful addition New York has been targeting as president and general manager Chris Drury reshapes the top nine.
For a club that has already brought in several forwards this summer, the appeal is obvious: more options, more competition and more flexibility as camp approaches. Tolvanen has enough NHL experience to help stabilize a middle-six role, and if the fit works, the Rangers could get more than just another body in the room. [Read more 🡒]
Rangers Are Suddenly Counting On One Prospect More Than Ever
The Rangers spent the offseason trying to add both immediate help and a longer runway for the future, and the prospect side of that equation has become especially important. Along with signing winger Pavel Dorofeyev to a long-term contract and bringing in defenseman Sean Durzi, the club also used the draft to add defender Alberts Smits, part of a broader push to reshape the roster while keeping an eye on what comes next.
At the center of that outlook is Cole Beaudoin, the young center prospect whose development now carries extra weight as the Rangers look to strengthen their depth down the middle. His arrival gives the organization another piece to monitor closely, and with the team still sorting out its long-term answers, how Beaudoin progresses could end up mattering more than ever. [Read more 🡒]