The New York Rangers left Columbus with a point, but not the one they probably had in mind.
Dylan Garand turned in a brilliant response in net, the penalty kill stayed locked in and the team’s overall effort looked nothing like the mess from Thursday night. Still, the Rangers fell 1-0 to the Blue Jackets in overtime Saturday at Nationwide Arena, a bitter finish after a game they had every chance to steal.
That made this one a strange mix: better hockey, better compete, same result. The Rangers (6-3-1) showed up with a far cleaner approach 48 hours after their ugly 7-1 loss to the New Jersey Devils, and they avoided the kind of collapse that can linger. But they also missed openings, went 0 for 3 on the power play in the third period of a scoreless game and eventually watched Kent Johnson finish the job at 3:26 of overtime.
Johnson scored off a slick cross-ice pass from Zach Werenski, ending it before the Rangers could cash in on the work Garand and the penalty kill had already done.
“I thought it was a really hard-fought game,” captain J.T. Miller said postgame.
“The chances were greasy ones. There weren’t a lot of big ones.
We’re proud of the way we responded.”
The Blue Jackets deserve credit, too. They entered the night after being blasted by coach Rick Bowness for a 7-3 loss to the Florida Panthers earlier in the week, and they came out with their best effort of the season. But the Rangers matched that challenge for long stretches, even if they couldn’t close it out.
Garand was the headliner. After being pulled in his previous NHL outing, when he gave up four goals on 13 shots in 24:39 against the Devils, the 24-year-old looked composed from the start and finished with 28 saves on 29 shots. He stopped all seven shots in the first period, 10 in the second and nine more in the third, then made a pair of important saves on Sean Monahan and Johnson early in overtime before finally getting beaten.
He was tested early and often, and he kept answering. Garand challenged Adam Fantilli early in the first and robbed him with a sharp pad save.
Later, he made a sprawling stop along the goal line to deny what looked like a sure goal for Cole Sillinger at 13:22 of the third period. Against Fantilli in particular, Garand kept coming up with answers.
The Rangers also did a strong job killing penalties, with the entire unit playing a clean game and Garand leading the way. Columbus went 0 for 3 on the power play, including a late-third-period chance that carried into overtime after Will Cuylle was whistled for interference at 19:27. New York erased that one, too, but couldn’t finish the next shift.
What hurt most was the power play. Against a Columbus penalty kill that had already been roughed up by Florida earlier in the week, the Rangers couldn’t score on any of their three chances in the third period.
They generated only four shots during those opportunities and even gave up a dangerous short-handed chance to Werenski. Oliver Bjorkstrand also hit the crossbar at 5:29, but the Rangers never managed to turn sustained zone time into a goal.
That was the swing in this game. The Rangers did enough to survive defensively, but not enough offensively to cash in before overtime.
There was also a mixed night for the reworked top line. Mike Sullivan reunited Mika Zibanejad between Gabe Perreault and Alexis Lafreniere, but only Perreault really looked energized by the move. He led the Rangers with a season-high six shots on goal and nine attempts, and late in the second period he came close to putting New York ahead with a pair of tight chances that Jet Greaves turned away.
Zibanejad, meanwhile, had one shot on goal despite nearly 25 minutes of ice time, and Lafreniere finished without a shot on goal as his six-game point streak ended. Perreault also wound up minus-1 after jumping on the ice to replace Lafreniere seconds before Columbus scored the winner.
The Rangers come out of this one with their first winless stretch of the season at 0-1-1 and now turn to the Anaheim Ducks at Madison Square Garden on Monday. The frustration is obvious, because this was the kind of game they likely should have won. But after Thursday’s disaster, at least they played like themselves again.
In Other News...
Rangers Add Veteran Goalie Depth As Bigger Questions Still Linger
The Rangers added a familiar veteran name to their goaltending pipeline when James Reimer joined their AHL affiliate in Hartford on a professional tryout agreement. It is a practical move for the Wolf Pack, which had been short on bodies in goal, and it gives New York some extra experience in the system as the organization continues sorting through its depth chart.
For now, the signing answers only part of the picture. It shores up Hartford while the NHL clubs own goaltending situation remains unsettled, and the Rangers could still look around for more help if needed. Reimers arrival buys the organization some breathing room, but it does not make the larger questions disappear. [Read more 🡒]
Rangers Already Face Pressure Over Their Big Pavel Dorofeyev Bet
The Rangers made a major commitment to Pavel Dorofeyev after bringing him over from Vegas and locking him in on a long-term deal, the kind of move that comes with immediate scrutiny in New York. His track record with the Golden Knights suggested there was plenty of offense still to come, which is why the early returns have drawn attention even as the season is still young.
Through nine games, Dorofeyev has not yet looked like the finishing piece the Rangers are hoping for, and the pressure that comes with a seven-season, $77 million contract is already part of the conversation. Even so, there are reasons inside the organization to believe the scoring will follow, which leaves the Rangers balancing patience with the expectation that their big bet has to start paying off soon. [Read more 🡒]
Rangers Shake Up Their Lines Again After That Devils Embarrassment
The Rangers were back to shuffling their forward group before Saturdays game, with Jaroslav Chmela sent back to Hartford and Taylor Raddysh brought up after Igor Shesterkins move to injured reserve opened the door on the salary cap. It was another reminder of how quickly a rough night can force a reset, especially for a team still searching for the right mix up front.
Mike Sullivan also went back to a look he has leaned on before, restoring the Perreault-Zibanejad-Lafrenire top unit and sliding Pavel Dorofeyev back onto the second line. The move suggests the staff is still trying to balance the scoring pieces while getting more out of a group that has had stretches of production without finding much consistency. [Read more 🡒]