Dylan Garand did just about everything a team could ask for and still walked off with nothing to show for it.
The rookie goaltender turned in a brilliant outing Thursday night, but the New York Rangers still fell 1-0 to the Columbus Blue Jackets in overtime, undone by a late finish from Kent Johnson after a night in which both teams struggled to find a breakthrough. The Rangers also got Taylor Raddysh back in the lineup for his season debut after a recall from the Hartford Wolf Pack, while Matt Rempe and Scott Morrow were in the press box.
The game opened as a tight, low-event fight. Through the first five minutes, neither side generated much, with Adam Fantilli’s shot the only real threat and Garand handling it cleanly. Columbus managed just one shot in that stretch, while New York put three on net.
The Rangers’ best early work came from effort and structure rather than flash. Tye Kartye was active on the forecheck, helping New York recover pucks, and Will Cuylle later turned in a strong shift of his own after the Blue Jackets had put together their best sequence of the period. But Jet Greaves was steady when called on, and the first period stayed scoreless despite the Rangers finishing with a 9-7 edge in shots.
New York also had to kill the game’s first penalty when Vladislav Gavrikov was called for holding with 6:13 left in the opening frame. Gavrikov left for the locker room after taking a hook from Charlie Coyle on the same sequence, but Columbus never got comfortable on the advantage.
The Rangers’ penalty kill kept its strong season going, with Cuylle helping clear the zone, and the Blue Jackets managed only two shots on goal. Gavrikov later returned.
The second period brought more energy from the Rangers, who opened with a few solid shifts and forced Columbus to answer with its own extended possession. Early in the frame, Cuylle drove the net and was bumped into the goal by Zach Werenski, knocking the net loose. Still, the score stayed 0-0.
Garand had to be sharp again when Sean Durzi took a penalty, and he delivered. He stopped a shot just before the power play, then turned aside Cole Sillinger shortly after Columbus finally set up. The Rangers’ penalty kill held firm again, and Garand followed with another save once the man advantage ended.
That pattern held for most of the middle period: pressure in stretches, but no finish. Braden Schneider made a strong defensive play to break up a Columbus rush that had danger written all over it, and Garand later came up with a pair of impressive stops during another Blue Jackets push. At the other end, Gabe Perreault produced New York’s best chance to that point, driving in after receiving a pass and working his stick well before being denied in close.
The Rangers’ fourth line also nearly cracked the game open, with Raddysh and Justin Dowling setting up a neat sequence that left Oliver Bjorkstrand with a look he couldn’t bury. The period ended just as it began: scoreless.
New York finally got its first power play 18 seconds into the third period after Fantilli was penalized, but the advantage didn’t break the deadlock. Columbus held up, and Garand had to make a save immediately after the opportunity expired.
A few minutes later, the Rangers got another chance when Jake Christiansen was called for tripping Adam Fox. The first unit moved the puck better this time, but the Blue Jackets still found ways to disrupt it.
Oliver blocked a J.T. Miller shot off the faceoff, Pavel Dorofeyev got a puck on goal, and then Werenski threatened shorthanded before Garand shut that down too.
Bjorkstrand later rang a shot off the crossbar, and the Rangers came away empty again.
At the halfway mark of the period, Columbus returned the favor by putting Sillinger in the box for hooking Durzi. That gave New York a third power-play chance, but the result was the same: no goal, and more shorthanded looks against. The Rangers never managed to turn any of their chances into the one puck they needed.
Garand kept bailing them out as the clock wound down. Fantilli had another quality chance denied, then Sillinger got loose on a three-on-two that ended with a sprawling stop.
Columbus kept pressing, even after Marcus Pettersson broke up a dangerous three-on-one. With 1:16 left, Kent Johnson hit Pettersson into the boards and left him down briefly, though Pettersson stayed on the bench.
The Blue Jackets then used their timeout.
The Rangers were nearly forced into disaster in the final half-minute when Cuylle was called for interference, giving Columbus a late power play. Werenski got a shot through, but Garand was there again. New York survived the kill and got to overtime.
The extra period opened with Columbus controlling possession, and Johnson tested Garand early. He was stopped again.
On the power play, J.T. Miller’s puck possession helped the Rangers change and create a shorthanded chance for Mika Zibanejad and Fox, but Garand kept Columbus off the board once more, this time turning aside Sean Monahan in the final second of the advantage.
Four-on-four play followed, and the Blue Jackets won the faceoff to set the tone. Garand even reached out to glove a pass and keep the sequence alive. New York had a brief push in Columbus territory, but it still couldn’t generate the one decisive play.
Then, with 1:33 left in overtime, Johnson finished it. The sequence ran through a slick pass from Johnson to Coyle, then back to Werenski, and finally back to Johnson for the winner in a 1-0 Columbus victory.
The Rangers return home Monday to face the Anaheim Ducks.
In Other News...
Rangers Add Veteran Goalie Depth As Bigger Questions Still Linger
The Rangers added a familiar veteran name to their goaltending pipeline when James Reimer joined their AHL affiliate in Hartford on a professional tryout agreement. It is a practical move for the Wolf Pack, which had been short on bodies in goal, and it gives New York some extra experience in the system as the organization continues sorting through its depth chart.
For now, the signing answers only part of the picture. It shores up Hartford while the NHL clubs own goaltending situation remains unsettled, and the Rangers could still look around for more help if needed. Reimers arrival buys the organization some breathing room, but it does not make the larger questions disappear. [Read more 🡒]
Rangers May Have A New Goaltending Question After Brutal OT Loss
The Rangers got exactly the kind of road effort they needed from Dylan Garand for most of the night in Columbus, but it still ended with only a point after a 1-0 overtime loss at Nationwide Arena. Garand was sharp throughout, turning aside 28 of 29 shots and helping the Rangers survive key penalty-kill situations, which at least gave a struggling road trip a chance to produce something.
New York still leaves with its record on the road sitting at 1-3-1, and the bigger takeaway may be less about the standings than about what comes next in goal. Garands showing was strong enough to keep the game within reach, but the manner of the finish only adds to the pressure around a position the Rangers suddenly have reasons to keep watching closely. [Read more 🡒]
Rangers Already Face Pressure Over Their Big Pavel Dorofeyev Bet
The Rangers made a major commitment to Pavel Dorofeyev after bringing him over from Vegas and locking him in on a long-term deal, the kind of move that comes with immediate scrutiny in New York. His track record with the Golden Knights suggested there was plenty of offense still to come, which is why the early returns have drawn attention even as the season is still young.
Through nine games, Dorofeyev has not yet looked like the finishing piece the Rangers are hoping for, and the pressure that comes with a seven-season, $77 million contract is already part of the conversation. Even so, there are reasons inside the organization to believe the scoring will follow, which leaves the Rangers balancing patience with the expectation that their big bet has to start paying off soon. [Read more 🡒]