The Rangers needed Monday night to be a breather for Dylan Garand. Instead, it turned into a mess that left him back in the crease anyway.
New York had planned to give Garand his first night off after seven straight starts since Igor Shesterkin’s season-ending knee injury. James Reimer, fresh off a 35-save shutout in Hartford, was supposed to handle the load against the Los Angeles Kings while the Rangers bought time for Joonas Korpisalo’s recovery and reached the club’s rare six-day layoff.
That plan fell apart fast in a 6-3 loss, New York’s first home defeat of the 2026-27 season.
Reimer was off from the jump, allowing goals on the first two shots he faced and giving up three on eight shots in the opening period. Mike Sullivan then made the move that defined the night: he pulled Reimer after the first intermission and sent Garand back out there.
The result was exactly what the Rangers were trying to avoid. Garand was forced into his ninth straight game appearance dating back to his relief outing in Washington, and he entered cold.
He was beaten twice in the second period, first by former Ranger Artemi Panarin on a power-play goal that carried over from the first period, then by Mikey Anderson about six minutes later. After that, Garand settled in and finished with 15 saves on 17 shots over 38:05 of ice time.
Tye Kartye gave New York a little life with a late goal to make it 5-3, but Joel Edmundson’s empty-netter shut the door.
The biggest issue here wasn’t that Reimer struggled. It was that the Rangers signed him to absorb minutes, not to be protected from them.
He’s a 17-year pro with 539 NHL regular-season games on his résumé. This wasn’t supposed to be a delicate confidence-building assignment.
It was supposed to be a night off for Garand, plain and simple.
Before the game, Sullivan made clear why Reimer was getting the start.
"We're asking a lot of Dylan. He just had 7 starts in a row... I think there's a physical challenge to it, but there's also a mental challenge to it."
Afterward, the coach acknowledged the mistake.
"I put him in a tough spot and that's on me"
He expanded on that point, saying:
"Let's just acknowledge we're in a difficult circumstance when our top two goalies are injured. So, we're trying to find a way to shore this thing up as best we can.
I think Dylan has given us some really good games, and as I said to you guys, his workload is mounting. And then for Reims to come in the way he has, in short order, going into a game like this, it's not an easy challenge.
It's a tough challenge, and I just felt like the way the game was going, I just felt like maybe Reims needs a little bit more preparation before we put him in that circumstance. … I put him in a tough spot.
That's that's on me."
That confession only raises more questions. If Reimer needed more prep to handle game speed, why was he the choice over another stopgap?
Why not give him another start in Hartford? The Rangers clearly needed somebody - anyone - not named Dylan Garand to cover the crease, even if the solution was temporary.
The loss dropped New York to 7-6-1 and put them on a three-game slide. That’s not a season-breaker in late October. But the way this goaltending plan unfolded was all wrong, and now the Rangers go into the break needing Garand to be ready again when they return Sunday.
In Other News...
Ducks Moving On From Chris Kreider Looks More Telling Now
Chris Kreiders post-Rangers stop in Montreal has been a quiet one so far, and not in the way the Canadiens hoped when they added him on a one-year deal in September. Through 11 games, the veteran winger has managed just one goal and three assists, a line that looks especially light for a player who once brought dependable scoring punch during his years in New York and later helped fuel Anaheims playoff push.
The numbers underneath the surface have been even less flattering, with his shot-share and chance-generation metrics landing below what Montreal is getting from most of its regulars. For a player who was released by the Ducks and quickly claimed by the Canadiens, the early returns are a reminder that the fit never quite took hold in Anaheim, and they make that decision look a little more revealing in hindsight. [Read more 🡒]
Canadiens Crease Debate Just Got More Interesting After Fowlers Statement
The Rangers goaltending depth became a talking point almost immediately after Igor Shesterkins injury opened the door for a new backup plan, and James Reimer is now part of that picture on a one-year deal. The veteran arrived after a professional tryout with Hartford and had already shown he could still give a team a steady night in net, which is exactly the kind of insurance New York wanted to add with Shesterkin sidelined.
Elsewhere in the Eastern Conference, Montreals crease picture picked up a little more intrigue when rookie Jacob Fowler turned in a 33-save performance in an outdoor game against Winnipeg. For a division already full of unsettled questions in goal, that kind of showing only adds to the pressure on everyone trying to sort out where the next reliable option comes from. [Read more 🡒]
Rangers Suddenly Have A Goalie Question They Did Not Expect
The Rangers latest home setback came with an unexpected wrinkle in net, as Los Angeles rolled into Madison Square Garden and handed New York a 6-3 loss to snap a six-game home winning streak. The Kings controlled the tempo early and never really let the Rangers settle in, turning what had been a tough building for visitors into a game the home side was chasing from the start.
James Reimer was making his Rangers debut and immediately became part of the nights storyline, with the club facing a goaltending conversation it probably did not anticipate this soon. New York still got offensive contributions, including from Artemi Panarin, but Darcy Kuempers 22 saves helped Los Angeles keep control, leaving the Rangers to sort out where the crease picture goes from here. [Read more 🡒]