Jacob Trouba’s path out of New York ended with a fresh payday in San Jose, but The Athletic doesn’t think the bill makes much sense.
The former Rangers captain, traded to the Anaheim Ducks in December 2024 to clear the final 1 1/2 seasons of his seven-year, $56 million deal, wound up landing a four-year, $33 million contract with the Sharks this summer. That $8.25 million average annual value was supposed to be a step down for a 32-year-old defenseman entering free agency. Instead, with the cap climbing, Trouba came out ahead.
The Athletic’s Dom Luszczyszyn ranked the NHL’s 10 worst contracts on Thursday after releasing his best-contract list earlier in the week, and Trouba checked in at No. 5. Luszczyszyn acknowledged the edge and intangibles that have long been part of Trouba’s appeal, writing that “he has some great intangible elements and plays the game with a fierce edge.”
That edge helped define Trouba’s run in New York. He was named captain in August 2022, wore the “C” when the Rangers won the Presidents’ Trophy in 2023-24 and reached the Eastern Conference Final for the second time in three seasons, and won the 2024 Mark Messier NHL Leadership Award, given to the player who best exemplifies leadership on and off the ice and in the community.
But the ending was messy. Rangers general manager Chris Drury had already pushed toward moving Trouba, even threatening waivers the way he did with Barclay Goodrow a few months earlier.
Trouba eventually accepted a move to Anaheim, but he said on ESPN that the public back-and-forth made it harder to lead the team. “I wasn’t really thrilled with how it went down.
In my opinion, things could have been handled better,” he said. “It’s unfortunate how it all happened.
But it’s a rite of passage to get fired from MSG.”
Trouba’s time with the Ducks was better than the Rangers clearly expected when they moved on. He posted 10 goals and 35 points in 2025-26, his best offensive season since his career-high 11 goals and 39 points in 2021-22, his third year with New York after arriving in a trade from Winnipeg. He averaged 22:50 of ice time across 81 games, led Ducks defensemen with 149 blocked shots, tied for the team lead in goals and finished second among Anaheim blueliners in points, assists and hits with 143.
Anaheim also made the playoffs for the first time since 2018 and won a round before being eliminated by the Utah Mammoth. Even so, the Ducks decided Trouba’s bounce-back wasn’t enough to justify a major long-term investment in a 32-year-old defenseman.
San Jose saw the situation differently, or at least saw a need. The Sharks were thin on the blue line and had cap space to spend, even with a young forward group led by Macklin Celebrini.
Still, Luszczyszyn wasn’t sold on the fit, arguing that Trouba’s value is more in the range of a No. 4 or No. 5 defenseman than the No. 2 role his contract suggests. “It’s been a very long time since Trouba has been that.
He had a one-off season at that level in 2021-22. But not since his time in Winnipeg has Trouba consistently put up top-pair numbers.”
Trouba’s résumé is still substantial. He has played 906 regular-season games with the Jets, Rangers and Ducks, and among defensemen from the 2012 NHL Draft, he ranks fourth in goals with 84, third in assists with 274 and third in points with 358. He also has 20 points, including five goals and 15 assists, in 85 playoff games.
His shot-blocking has remained a calling card, too. Outside of the Covid-shortened 2020-21 season, Trouba has reached at least 100 blocked shots every year and leads all defensemen with 1,943 since his NHL debut in 2013-14.
That’s the kind of production the Sharks were banking on. The question, as Luszczyszyn put it, is whether they paid too much for it: “just because a defenseman gets top-pair minutes and top-pair money doesn’t mean he’s actually top-pair quality.”
In Other News...
Rangers May Have Just Dodged Their Worst Free Agency Mistake
The Rangers came up empty in their pursuit of Alex Tuch, but there may be a silver lining in how the market shook out. Tuch landed elsewhere on an eight-year deal, and the early reaction around the league has not been kind. The Athletic recently slotted the contract among the NHLs worst, citing concerns about how it could age and whether the value will hold up over the long term.
For New York, the miss looks a little less painful because the club moved quickly to address the same need by trading for Pavel Dorofeyev and locking him in on a seven-year contract. The Rangers were clearly shopping for a major addition, and while Tuch would have brought name value, the combination of term and risk attached to his new deal makes this one of those rare free-agent near-misses that can feel like a break instead of a setback. [Read more 🡒]
Marcus Pettersson Already Sounds Like Exactly What Rangers Needed
Marcus Pettersson did not need much convincing once the Rangers entered the picture. After waiving his no-movement clause to make the move to New York, the defenseman sounded genuinely excited about landing with a team whose coaching staff he already knows well, and his comfort level with Mike Sullivan clearly mattered in the decision. For a player changing cities in-season, that kind of familiarity can make a new situation feel a lot less like a leap.
Pettersson also has wasted little time getting acquainted on the player side, saying he has already had conversations with Mika Zibanejad and J.T. Miller since the trade. For the Rangers, that matters as much as the on-ice fit, because integrating a defenseman quickly is about more than systems and pairings. The bigger question now is how smoothly all of those connections translate once he gets into the room and onto the ice. [Read more 🡒]
Sean Durzi Feels The Pressure Of Fixing A Rangers Problem
Marcus Pettersson and Sean Durzi met the New York media for the first time since their trades, and Durzi arrived sounding like a player eager for a reset. He called the NHL a prove-yourself league, said the move gives him a fresh start, and framed the opportunity in the biggest possible terms, with the Stanley Cup as the goal. For a Rangers team looking to tighten up its blue line, Durzi is expected to step in as the No. 2 right-handed defender behind Adam Fox, which makes his adjustment more than just a personal storyline.
Durzi also made clear that the trade came with some added motivation, even if it landed as a bit of a surprise. That matters in New York, where every new defenseman gets measured not just by fit, but by whether he can help solve a long-running problem on the back end. The Rangers are counting on him to bring stability and a little urgency to a role that carries real pressure, and the first public signs suggest he understands exactly what is at stake. [Read more 🡒]