New York Rangers fans may have big expectations for Alberts Smits, but they’re not exactly lining up to throw the 18-year-old straight into the NHL.
That’s the message from the latest fan poll, which pointed to Matthew Robertson as the favorite to open the 2026-27 season on the blue line. Fans were asked which player should be the sixth defenseman when the Rangers begin the season in Boston against the Bruins on Sept. 29, with the assumption that Adam Fox, Vladislav Gavrikov, Sean Durzi, Marcus Pettersson, and Braden Schneider are already locked into the top five spots.
Robertson ran away with it, collecting 57.8 percent of the vote across X and Facebook. Smits finished second at 26.3 percent, while Scott Morrow and Urho Vaakanainen were separated by just one vote. Morrow received 8.0 percent, and Vaakanainen got 7.8 percent.
The result lines up with the cautious approach Chris Drury laid out in July, when the general manager made it clear the Rangers won’t force their top prospect into action before he’s ready. That stance makes sense on paper, even if fans don’t always agree with Drury’s thinking.
“Give Smits some time in the Wolfpack,” Jessie Hazen stated on Facebook. “See how he does there before potentially bringing him up. Robertson should start opening night.”
Mike German offered a similar view: “Smits should start in Hartford. Play Robertson until Smits is ready, which might not be very long.”
Robertson gave supporters plenty to like last season. The late bloomer played 72 games as an NHL rookie at age 25, averaged 17:24 of ice time, and ranked third among Rangers defensemen with six goals and 18 points.
He also finished fourth on the team with 80 blocked shots and posted a 49.79 expected goal share, according to Natural Stat Trick. That’s a solid resume for a left-side third-pair defenseman, and it explains why so many fans are comfortable starting there.
“The highest probability: Smits will need some baking in the AHL oven. But he’ll probably be with the team soon enough,” TBone DeMayo EsKargo shared on Facebook.
“Robertson earned his spot on the roster, last season. Overall, played well in his first NHL season.
I expect he will do so again this training camp (sans injury) and hopefully take another step forward in his development.
“It’s Robertson’s job to win or lose.”
Still, the appetite for Smits is real. The Rangers used the No. 5 overall pick on the big defenseman, and plenty of scouts viewed him as the most NHL-ready player in the draft - maybe even more ready than No. 1 overall pick Gavin McKenna of the Toronto Maple Leafs.
At 6-foot-3 and 205 pounds, Smits brings the kind of size and bite that can make people dream on the spot. He also proved himself against men in two European professional leagues last season and represented Latvia in the 2026 Milan-Cortina Olympics and 2026 IIHF World Championship.
That doesn’t mean the Rangers should hurry the process. If Smits makes the opening-night roster, it would likely be in a third-pair role.
Long term, he projects as a top-four defender and could eventually become the left-side answer behind Gavrikov on the top pair. But that’s a future conversation, not a current one.
As Wayne Rosenberg noted on Facebook, “Right now Robertson, but the lineup at the end of the season is much more important and never the same as it started.”
There were also fans who liked the idea of seeing Smits challenge for a job right away if he has the camp to back it up.
“If Smits show(s) he can compete during camp he should start! Look at him, he could be a monster,” Joe Brancato said.
Greg Torrey went even further, suggesting a specific partner for the rookie: “Personally, I’d love to see Smits be paired with Schneider,” he shared on Facebook. “I think there’s an opportunity there for Smits’ hard hitting style to awaken that side of Schneider’s game. If it worked out, they could be a real thorn for opponents.”
The poll also showed little enthusiasm for Morrow or Vaakanainen jumping into a top-six role on opening night, though some fans said Morrow could fit as the extra seventh defenseman. One commenter viewed Vaakanainen as the best candidate for that seventh spot if Robertson takes the third pair and Smits starts in Hartford, while another said the 27-year-old shouldn’t be in the organization at all.
Rookie Drew Fortescue and Vincent Iorio, who signed a one-year contract with the Rangers on Friday, were not included in the poll. Even so, there’s no guarantee they’re out of the picture entirely when camp opens.
For now, though, the fans have spoken: Robertson is the safe bet, and Smits is the one they’d rather see brought along at the right pace.
“Whomever gets the nod, its nice to see the team has options,” Ted Hochwalt noted. “The pressure on the players is equally important, play or go (down or out).”
In Other News...
Henrik Lundqvists Greatest Rangers Season Still Feels Like A What-If
Henrik Lundqvists 2011-12 season still sits near the top of any Rangers conversation about modern greatness, because it had the kind of steadiness and star power that defined his peak years. Over 62 games, he was the backbone of a team that leaned on him night after night, and the numbers matched the eye test: he looked like one of the leagues elite goaltenders, the type who could swing a game by himself and keep New York in contention no matter the opponent.
Even so, the season carries a little bit of what-if energy because the stretch came amid monthly swings that kept it from feeling like a perfect march from start to finish. Lundqvist earned the hardware that recognized how dominant he was, and he also landed in the mix for one of the leagues biggest individual honors, which only deepens the sense that this was a year good enough to be remembered alongside the best of that era. [Read more 🡒]