Rangers Already Facing Early Heat Over Their Summer Bet

As Pavel Dorofeyev adjusts to life as a New York Ranger, his mixed early-season performance raises questions about the implications of his high-profile trade from Vegas.

The Rangers knew exactly what they were buying when they paid a steep price for Pavel Dorofeyev last summer: a 25-year-old coming off a 37-goal season, plus the kind of contract that puts immediate pressure on every shift. New York sent over Dallas’ 2026 first-round pick (26th overall), Buffalo’s 2026 third-round pick (92nd overall), and a top-10-protected 2028 first-round pick to pry him away from the Vegas Golden Knights, then locked him into a seven-year deal worth $11MM annually before he ever played a game for them.

So far, the results have been mixed at best. Dorofeyev has six goals and six assists through 21 games, which is serviceable production, but the number that jumps off the page is his minus-18 rating - worst in the NHL.

That alone is enough to make Rangers fans uneasy, especially with Braden Schneider sitting next on the team at minus-3. Still, plus/minus only tells part of the story, and in Dorofeyev’s case it may be the least useful part.

The more pressing issue is that his scoring pace has slipped. He’s tracking toward 25 goals and 50 points, a clear step down from what he delivered in Vegas.

One obvious culprit is his shooting percentage, which sits at 9.4% - a career low by 4% and almost half of last season’s rate. That kind of dip usually doesn’t stick forever, and his shot volume hasn’t fallen off.

Dorofeyev has 64 shots in 21 games, which is right in line with the pace he established with the Golden Knights. If the finishing normalizes, the goals should follow.

The defensive side hasn’t cratered, either. His possession and defensive numbers look a lot like they did during his last few seasons in Vegas, and he’s still helping his teammates tilt the ice in the right direction.

His +5.3 relative Corsi at even strength this season is close to the +5.6% he posted last year and the +4.2% he posted in 2024-25, according to MoneyPuck. His expected goals percentage at even strength is also steady at 55%, compared with 56% in each of the last two years.

The real outlier is what’s happening around him. Dorofeyev’s on-ice goals percentage has crashed to 35.7% from 63.9% last year, and his on-ice SV% is down to 79.9% from 87.9%.

That points to a simple early-season problem: the Rangers are not getting saves when he’s on the ice. That kind of thing tends to swing back over time.

There’s also the human side of it. A player can need time to settle in with a new team, new city, and new linemates, and the Rangers seem to be searching for the right fit.

Mike Sullivan has rotated Dorofeyev through the lineup and tried him in different combinations, which may not be helping him find a rhythm. His absence from Monday night’s game adds another wrinkle, since he could be dealing with a nagging injury or something similar.

For now, the numbers say Dorofeyev is still driving play even if the box score hasn’t been kind. He’s generating shots and chances, and his defensive work hasn’t disappeared.

That doesn’t erase the fact that Rangers fans have every reason to be frustrated with how this has started, but it does make it hard to call the trade a bust after only 21 games. Whether New York overpaid Vegas for Dorofeyev is a question that will take more than a rough opening stretch to answer.

In Other News...

Rangers Trade Watch Just Got More Interesting With One Familiar Winger

The Rangers strong start has them in an interesting spot as the season settles in. With the club looking for ways to deepen its forward group and add more scoring punch, the trade market is already worth watching, especially for a team that looks capable of pushing deeper if it can find the right fit.

Rickard Rakell is one name that keeps making sense on paper. The Penguins winger has ties to Rangers coach Mike Sullivan, and his recent decision to use his no-trade clause to block a move to Chicago only adds another layer to the situation. He is still in Pittsburgh for now, but if New York decides to chase a forward before the deadline, this is the kind of familiar target that could quickly move to the front of the line. [Read more 🡒]

Braden Schneider Is Suddenly Central To The Rangers Search For Help

Braden Schneider has quietly become one of the more interesting names in the Rangers search for help, not because he is suddenly on the outs, but because his contract situation and third-pairing role make him one of the few pieces New York could realistically use to address a bigger need. The Rangers have been looking for center depth, and that has pushed the conversation beyond simple roster shuffling and into the kind of trade talk that can reshape the back end of the lineup.

Montreal has surfaced as a possible fit, which makes sense given the kind of young talent the Canadiens could offer in return. Oliver Kapanen and Owen Beck are among the names being discussed as possible pieces in a deal, but the actual shape of any trade remains very much unsettled. For now, Schneider sits at the center of a broader Rangers question: whether they can turn a defenseman with value into the kind of help they have been chasing up the middle. [Read more 🡒]

Matt Rempe Debate Just Got More Complicated For Rangers Fans

Matt Rempes night in Montreal became another flashpoint for Rangers fans already split on what he is and what he can become. He was on the ice for the Canadiens only goal, and for some supporters that was enough to reopen the familiar debate about his defensive reliability and whether he fits into the long-term picture in New York.

Former Ranger Mike Rupp pushed back on the criticism, arguing that defending against a fast opponent is never simple and saying Rempes overall play deserved more credit. The timing only adds to the noise around him, with Rempe in the final year of his contract and trade chatter already circling, including reported interest from the Edmonton Oilers. [Read more 🡒]