Matt Rempe Debate Just Got More Complicated For Rangers Fans

Amidst criticism from fans, former Ranger Mike Rupp steps up to defend Matt Rempe, highlighting the forward's role and urging a more balanced view of his performance.

Matt Rempe drew plenty of heat after Monday’s game against the Montreal Canadiens, but one former Ranger wasn’t buying the criticism.

The 6-foot-9 forward ended up on the ice for Montreal’s only goal in the Rangers’ win, with Lane Hutson skating around him before setting up Phillip Danault. That was enough to send social media into its usual spiral, with Rempe once again becoming the easiest target in the room.

Mike Rupp pushed back hard on that narrative during an appearance on Daily Faceoff’s "Tri-State Hockey Podcast." His point was simple: Rempe did what he could against a tough matchup, and the online reaction was overblown.

"My whole thing is that people online, it’s just a lazy take where you’re like ‘oh he put him through the spin cycle. Oh he danced the enforcer.’

People are all over him," said Rupp. "He handles that and defends that almost perfectly.

The one thing he could do a better job of is right when that shot is about to come...he’s got a big five hole. And you talk about his stick and his reach, he’s going to have that big triangle.

He’s going to have some holes that you’ve got to close up. So dropping to a knee, turning sideways, he blocks that shot.

And would the same group of people say, ‘hell of a play by Matt Rempe?’ I don’t think so."

Rupp made the same case again on "NHL Now" on NHL Network, where he said Rempe was matched up with a legitimate Norris Trophy-caliber defender and handled the situation as well as he could have. He also pointed to the praise Rempe has received from head coach Mike Sullivan and the previous regime for the work he has put in.

That’s the reality with Rempe. He’s not going to be the kind of enforcer who piles up goals and punishes opponents the way Tom Wilson has throughout his career with the Washington Capitals.

His 11 points in 91 career games make that pretty clear. But he does have a role, and Rupp’s defense centered on that idea: Rempe was put in a spot by Jaroslav Chmelar, had to deal with Hutson, and did enough on the play.

The scrutiny around Rempe isn’t going away anytime soon, either. He’s in the final year of his two-year, $1.95 million contract extension and will be a restricted free agent this summer, leaving the Rangers with a decision to make on his future.

Trade chatter has already started. In late October, NHL insider Frank Seravalli reported that Edmonton Oilers head coach Mike Babcock is believed to want to add Rempe and his toughness. And Edmonton likely won’t be the only team with interest in a player of Rempe’s size and style.

That puts the Rangers in a familiar spot: decide whether Rempe is part of the long-term picture or whether his value is better used in a trade. With Gabe Perreault, Will Cuylle, and Tye Kartye also needing new contracts next summer, the front office has other business to handle as well.

For now, though, Rupp made sure Rempe had a voice in the conversation. And he did it loudly, on two different platforms.

In Other News...

Rangers Trade Watch Just Got More Interesting With One Familiar Winger

The Rangers strong start has them in an interesting spot as the season settles in. With the club looking for ways to deepen its forward group and add more scoring punch, the trade market is already worth watching, especially for a team that looks capable of pushing deeper if it can find the right fit.

Rickard Rakell is one name that keeps making sense on paper. The Penguins winger has ties to Rangers coach Mike Sullivan, and his recent decision to use his no-trade clause to block a move to Chicago only adds another layer to the situation. He is still in Pittsburgh for now, but if New York decides to chase a forward before the deadline, this is the kind of familiar target that could quickly move to the front of the line. [Read more 🡒]

Rangers Already Facing Early Heat Over Their Summer Bet

The Rangers summer gamble on Pavel Dorofeyev has already become one of those moves that gets a little louder when the results are uneven. New York paid up in a trade with the Vegas Golden Knights, sending multiple draft picks to land the forward before committing to him on a seven-year contract, and the early returns have been a mixed bag through 21 games.

Dorofeyev has produced six goals and six assists, but the bigger number attached to his start is the minus-18 rating that sits at the bottom of the league. The underlying data does not point to a dramatic collapse in his defensive work or possession game, which leaves the Rangers sorting through whether this is mostly a rough stretch, a fit issue, or the kind of early-season bounces that can make a big bet look shakier than it really is. [Read more 🡒]

Braden Schneider Is Suddenly Central To The Rangers Search For Help

Braden Schneider has quietly become one of the more interesting names in the Rangers search for help, not because he is suddenly on the outs, but because his contract situation and third-pairing role make him one of the few pieces New York could realistically use to address a bigger need. The Rangers have been looking for center depth, and that has pushed the conversation beyond simple roster shuffling and into the kind of trade talk that can reshape the back end of the lineup.

Montreal has surfaced as a possible fit, which makes sense given the kind of young talent the Canadiens could offer in return. Oliver Kapanen and Owen Beck are among the names being discussed as possible pieces in a deal, but the actual shape of any trade remains very much unsettled. For now, Schneider sits at the center of a broader Rangers question: whether they can turn a defenseman with value into the kind of help they have been chasing up the middle. [Read more 🡒]