Dave Maloney has never been the kind of Rangers voice to sand down the edges. That’s part of why Blueshirts fans have always gravitated to him. He played with edge, captained with edge, and now he breaks down the team with the same straight-ahead honesty on MSG Network.
So when the former Rangers defenseman and captain looks at the club’s retool, he isn’t reaching for big promises. He’s doing what he’s always done: sizing up the roster, measuring it against the league’s best, and calling it like he sees it.
“I think they’ve done a pretty good job,” Maloney told Forever Blueshirts on the Rink Rap podcast this week. “The reality is I go into each season and say how do [the Rangers] match up to the top teams? If you’re realistic, and even with that eternal optimism, you’ve got to come to an honest assessment and go from there, and then root like a bastard!”
That’s classic Captain Dave - blunt, loyal, and not interested in pretending the picture is prettier than it is.
The Rangers are coming off a last-place finish in the Eastern Conference, and Maloney’s benchmark remains the same one that matters every year: how close are they to the teams at the top? Even with the offseason additions of Pavel Dorofeyev, Sean Durzi and Marcus Pettersson, he sees Carolina as the standard.
“I always say there’s only one team that starts at the starting line that doesn’t have to answer to anybody, and this year it’ll be Carolina,” Maloney explained. “Now to varying degrees down to 32 you have a lot more things to answer to, and there are 16 teams that don’t make [the playoffs], that’s 50 percent of the League don’t get a chance.
“Not to kill the dream of winning the Stanley Cup, but how close are [the Rangers] when you go down the roster in experience and makeup to Carolina? And that’s OK, it’s where you’re at. I think it’s fair to assess where you are, make your changes, and just go play.”
That’s not exactly a ringing playoff forecast, and Maloney didn’t try to dress it up. Looking ahead to 2026-27, he said, “Finishing 30th overall, the bar is pretty low,”
Still, he doesn’t see the coaching staff as part of the problem. In fact, he pushed back hard on the idea that Mike Sullivan was the issue.
“There’s an observation out there that maybe the coach was the issue [last season],” Maloney offered. “Let me tell you something, that season, which cratered to where it got to, held some sense of responsibility and character and compete because of Mike Sullivan and his staff. He was terrific.
“By no stretch of anyone’s imagination was Mike Sullivan or his staff an issue.”
Maloney also drew a clear line between the Rangers’ two recent disappointments. In his view, the 2024-25 season was the real mess.
“The most disappointing season wasn’t last year. To me, the year before was a disaster,” he explained.
“There were so many things going on. They had no business having that December of 2024 with the roster they had, winning four games (actually, 3-10-0).
NO BUSINESS!”
As for last season, he pointed to the team’s rough start at home and the injuries that hit key pieces, especially Adam Fox and Igor Shesterkin. J.T. Miller, he added, was also dealing with injury issues throughout the year.
“You can only put so many fingers in the dyke. You need your best players to win.
And the Rangers were so leveraged to those two. And J.T.
Miller was banged up all season.”
So while Maloney isn’t selling a dream season, he isn’t shutting the door on one either. After two rough years and a reset that has already lowered expectations, he sees a team that has work to do - and a fan base that, as always, will keep rooting hard.
In Other News...
Rangers Suddenly Have A Goalie Problem Fans Were Not Expecting
The Rangers added another wrinkle to their goaltending picture on July 1, bringing in veteran Joonas Korpisalo from the Bruins as they continue sorting out life behind Igor Shesterkin. It is the kind of move that looks straightforward on paper, since Korpisalo arrives with two years left on his deal and is expected to enter the mix for the backup job, but it also changes the way the team has to think about its depth chart and roster construction.
Dylan Garand suddenly finds himself in a tougher spot, because the Rangers now have a more crowded path to the role he had been chasing. And with both Garand and Korpisalo needing waivers before any assignment to Hartford, the team may have to carry extra goaltending insurance longer than planned before the situation settles into something cleaner. [Read more 🡒]
Rangers Fans Have Seen This Ruthless Offer Sheet Movie Before
The latest offer-sheet drama around Leo Carlsson has a familiar ring for Rangers fans, because this kind of aggressive move has been part of the leagues playbook before. The Flyers took a big swing, and Anaheim answered by matching, turning what looked like a bold outside bid into a costly retention decision for the Ducks and another reminder that these deals are as much about leverage and structure as they are about talent.
For New York, the comparison inevitably drifts back to the 1997 Joe Sakic episode, when the Rangers tried to use the same ruthless tactic to pry away a star. The names and numbers change, but the lesson is the same: an offer sheet can force a contender to make an uncomfortable financial choice, and it can leave the team making the bid staring at the risk of having spent all that effort for nothing. [Read more 🡒]
Rangers Just Created A Massive Pavel Dorofeyev Dilemma
Pavel Dorofeyevs arrival gives the Rangers exactly the kind of finishing punch they have been looking to add, but the bigger question now is how they turn that investment into production. After landing his rights as a restricted free agent and locking him up on a seven-year, $77 million deal, New York is already weighing what kind of linemates can help unlock the goal-scoring touch that made him such an attractive target in the first place.
The challenge is less about Dorofeyevs talent than about fit, because his best work has come when he has had the right kind of support around him. The Rangers are sorting through lineup possibilities in search of a playmaking center or a creative winger who can keep feeding him looks, and the answer to that puzzle may end up shaping not just his numbers, but how quickly this new-look offense finds its rhythm. [Read more 🡒]