Chris Drury spent the offseason reshaping the Rangers, but the moves may still not be enough to push New York into true Stanley Cup territory.
Drury made it clear in January that a roster retool was coming, and the months that followed brought a noticeable shift. Artemi Panarin, Vincent Trocheck and Will Borgen are gone, while Pavel Dorofeyev, Oliver Bjorkstrand, Sean Durzi and Marcus Pettersson are in.
On paper, the group looks better than it did a year ago, and in the Metropolitan Division a playoff berth is definitely within reach. The bigger question is whether this version of the Rangers can actually threaten the top of the East.
The Athletic’s Harma Dayal doesn’t sound convinced. In a look at seven NHL teams that could be stuck in the middle, Dayal grouped the Rangers in that category and suggested the ceiling may not be much higher than a postseason appearance.
He wrote that the lineup is not close to the best teams in the Eastern Conference, and that even if Igor Shesterkin bails them out in a short series, a deep run feels highly unlikely. His view is even starker than that: the Rangers could be locked into being a "'mid' team for the foreseeable future."
"The current lineup isn’t close to the level of the best teams in the Eastern Conference. Sure, there’s a long-shot scenario where Shesterkin steals a series if they squeak into the postseason, but the odds of a deep playoff run feel slim to none," writes Dayal.
"The bigger issue is that their core is aging - Mika Zibanejad, J.T. Miller, Fox, Shesterkin and Vladislav Gavrikov are all in their late 20s or early 30s - and there isn’t enough of a strong youth movement coming, as the team’s prospect pool is average and they’ve already traded away two of their next four first-round picks."
That prospect-pool issue is central to the whole conversation. Drury’s retool was built, at least in part, to address a system that struggled last season, especially in the AHL.
The Rangers did add young pieces through trades, including Liam Greentree, Jacob Battaglia and Cole Beaudoin, and they used the fifth-overall pick on defenseman Alberts Smits. The hope is that those players become real contributors down the line.
For all the talk about rebuilding the supporting cast, there’s still one giant reason the Rangers can’t fully drift toward the bottom: Igor Shesterkin. As long as he’s in net, tanking isn’t really an option. He’s too good, and last season showed exactly how often he can keep New York in games even when the rest of the team isn’t firing on all cylinders.
Adam Fox also appears to like where things are headed. After being noncommittal earlier in the season, he later pointed to the youth movement as a positive and said he was looking forward to skating with the new group.
That matters because the window with Fox and Shesterkin is right there in front of the Rangers. Both are among the best at what they do, and both are in the prime stretch of their careers.
Fox is signed through the 2028-29 season, while Shesterkin is under contract through the 2032-33 season. The pressure is obvious: build something worthy of that timeline before it slips away.
New York is also banking on a star breaking through. Dorofeyev was brought in to be the top scorer, and he showed over the past two seasons in Vegas that he can fill that role. But the Rangers are still waiting on a true superstar to emerge - or to choose them.
They tried this offseason to land Detroit Red Wings center Dylan Larkin and Ottawa Senators winger Brady Tkachuk, but neither player had the Rangers on his wishlist. That leaves New York with more convincing to do if it wants to reclaim the kind of appeal it once had.
Connor McDavid is the name that hangs over that discussion. He has only two seasons left on his contract, and after Edmonton went to the Stanley Cup Final in 2024 and 2025 before being knocked out in the first round this year, there’s at least the possibility he could want out.
If that happens, every team will be in the mix. The Rangers need this season to show they’re moving in the right direction - and that they’d be one McDavid away from a championship.
For now, though, improved on paper is not the same as legitimate contender. New York looks better.
It may even make the playoffs. But based on how the roster sits today, the Rangers still don’t look like a true threat in the Eastern Conference.
In Other News...
Rangers May Be Heading Toward Another Painful Braden Schneider Decision
Braden Schneiders place in the Rangers long-term picture is suddenly looking less secure than it once did. The 24-year-old defenseman has not quite matched the early expectations that came with him, and with New York already carrying several blueliners on long-term deals while younger options continue to push into the conversation, his path to a steady role has become harder to define.
For a front office still trying to balance roster construction with salary cap reality, that creates a difficult kind of decision. Schneider is no longer just a player to monitor on the back end, but part of a larger equation about how the Rangers can address other needs without thinning out their defense too much, and the next stretch of his play could go a long way toward determining how aggressively management moves around him. [Read more 🡒]
Rangers Could Still Make One Intriguing Move Before Camp
With training camp approaching, the Rangers are still leaving room for one more move up front, and Shane Wright has emerged as a name worth watching. The Seattle center was the No. 4 overall pick not long ago, and at 22 he still fits the kind of young, controllable talent New York has tended to value when looking to deepen its forward group. For the Rangers, the appeal is obvious: a player who could slide into a third-line center role and give the lineup another option down the middle.
How New York would get there is the part still worth tracking. Any serious pursuit would likely force the Rangers to weigh pieces from a defense corps that already has its own internal value, and that kind of decision is never simple this late in the summer. Wrights situation has opened the door for speculation, but the real question is whether the Rangers decide the fit is strong enough to part with a useful young defender before camp opens. [Read more 🡒]
Mike Sullivan Fixed One Rangers Problem But Created Another
Mike Sullivans first season behind the Rangers bench did deliver one clear change: the team became harder to play against defensively. After coming in with a more structure-first approach, he helped tighten things up on that end compared with the previous season, giving New York a more reliable foundation even as the rest of the roster kept searching for rhythm.
The problem was that the same system did not solve everything else, and the Rangers spent much of the year fighting for consistency on offense. Injuries to key players helped trigger a long losing stretch, and the lineup decisions that followed only added to the uncertainty as the club tried to balance short-term results with player development. What looked like one problem fixed quickly turned into another one waiting for answers. [Read more 🡒]