The Blue Jackets are still waiting on the missing piece that changes the whole picture.
After Sunday night’s 2-1 loss to the Minnesota Wild, Columbus heads back home for a week that includes practice and two more games, hosting Kirill Marchenko and the Toronto Maple Leafs on Tuesday night before welcoming the Vegas Golden Knights on Saturday night. At 3-4-0 through seven games, the early results have been uneven - but the larger issue is simple: this team has not been whole.
Two defensemen are on injured reserve, Dante Fabbro and Ivan Provorov, and the Provorov absence is the one that keeps rippling through everything else. Fabbro has been skating on his own and was with the club Saturday morning for the optional skate as he works back from a broken bone in his hand. Provorov, though, is the bigger loss by far after blocking a shot in the preseason and being unavailable ever since.
That missing body on the blue line has had a cascading effect. Provorov isn’t just another defenseman.
He’s the kind who handles heavy minutes, takes on the tough assignments and shows up in every critical situation. Without him, Columbus has been forced to patch things together all over the lineup.
The numbers from last season make the point. When Provorov and Denton Mateychuk were together at 5-on-5, they logged a little over 299 minutes and the Blue Jackets outscored opponents 17-7 in those minutes.
Their goal share sat at 64.78%, with only the Zach Werenski-Damon Severson pairing doing better at 67.15% across just over 394 minutes. The team save percentage of .933 in that Provorov-Mateychuk sample was on the high side, but the pair still gave Columbus real value when the group was intact.
That’s the problem now: the top four hasn’t stayed intact. Severson missed the first two games of the season, but since returning he has posted 1-3-4 and looked like one of the team’s better defenders.
Werenski, meanwhile, has been forced into huge workloads. He logged 61:01 over the weekend against the Rangers and Wild, a load he can handle, but one the Blue Jackets would rather not ask of him every night.
The lack of Provorov has pushed other defensemen into roles they weren’t necessarily meant to carry. Carson Soucy, signed out of camp after attending on a PTO, has had some costly turnovers that led to goals against, including the 1-0 goal in Minnesota on Sunday night.
Soucy sat as a healthy scratch on Saturday. Emil Andrae, acquired in the Matthew Knies trade, has played but with limited minutes.
Mateychuk has recently been paired with Jake Christiansen, who has bounced in and out of the lineup early this season, while Erik Gudbranson has also cycled through different partners.
That instability has made it tough for Columbus to put together a steady bottom four beneath Werenski and Severson, and the results have reflected it at both ends of the ice.
The context matters here. Provorov had played in 375 straight games before the injury.
He offers more than just ice time, too - over 24 minutes a night, penalty-kill work and 30-plus points a season are all part of what he brings. Replacing that on the fly is almost impossible, and the Blue Jackets have been forced into exactly that kind of scramble.
The team’s last official update on Provorov was that he was week-to-week, and his presence at Saturday’s skate without being on the ice suggested there is still time to go before a return. For now, Columbus has to keep treading water and keep its goals against down. The Blue Jackets did hold opponents to two goals total this weekend, with only one coming at 5-on-5, which at least gives them something to build on while they wait.
Until Provorov is back and up to speed, though, this team can’t really be judged on what it is. The full version still hasn’t been on the ice.
Once it is, if the inconsistency remains, then the conversation changes. For now, the verdict should wait.
In Other News...
Rangers Suddenly Have A Tye Kartye Decision They Didn't Expect
Tye Kartye arrived in New York as a waiver claim from Seattle, the kind of low-risk pickup teams make to deepen a roster and see if a hard-working winger can carve out a niche. Instead, the undrafted left winger has quickly turned into much more than depth, earning trust with the Rangers for the way he competes, handles his defensive responsibilities and helps steady the kind of line that can tilt a game.
What makes the situation interesting is how quickly Kartye has moved from hopeful addition to someone the staff has to keep in a meaningful role. His fit with the clubs top offensive players has already changed the conversation around what the Rangers thought they were getting, and now the bigger question is whether this early stretch is a real sign of staying power or simply the latest surprise in a season that is still taking shape. [Read more 🡒]
Sean Durzi Solves One Rangers Need While Exposing Another
Sean Durzi has already given the Rangers what they hoped to get when they brought him in over the summer: a steadier blue line and a presence that seems to fit naturally in the room. The comparison to Vincent Trocheck is obvious enough for anyone around the team. Both are similar in build, both play with a similar edge, and both come with the kind of workmanlike reputation that tends to travel well in New York. Durzi has also brought a little of the same personality and energy that made Trocheck so useful to the Rangers beyond the stat sheet.
What the move has also done, though, is shine a brighter light on the other side of the ledger. Trochecks departure left a hole down the middle, and the Rangers are feeling the effects in their center depth as the season goes along. Durzis past injury history is part of the broader picture too, because the Rangers know the upside is real but the margin for error is thin when a player has had to battle through health issues before. [Read more 🡒]
Rangers Hot Start Still Hasnt Solved One Bigger Problem
The Rangers strong start has done plenty to build optimism in New York, but it has not yet changed the way star players view the organization when bigger decisions come up. Dylan Larkin has reportedly widened his trade wishlist from three teams to 10, and the club on Broadway still is not on it, a reminder that early-season momentum does not automatically make a team a destination for elite talent.
The latest list apparently does include several familiar Eastern Conference names, with the Hurricanes, Devils and Capitals among the teams Larkin is open to. For the Rangers, that leaves a familiar kind of frustration: they can look like a contender on the ice and still find themselves on the outside when the leagues top names start narrowing their options. [Read more 🡒]