The Yankees want Cody Bellinger back in pinstripes - but they’re not planning to break the bank to make it happen. And that measured approach might just open the door for their crosstown rivals to make a serious move.
According to multiple reports, the Yankees have settled on what they believe is a fair offer for the former MVP: five years, $160 million, with two opt-outs. It’s a strong deal, but they’re not looking to get into a bidding war. If another team - like the Mets - decides to push the number higher, the Yankees are reportedly comfortable walking away.
That’s a bold stance, especially considering Bellinger’s potential impact on both sides of the ball. But it’s also a reflection of the Yankees’ current roster situation.
With young outfielders like Jasson Dominguez and Spencer Jones knocking on the door, the team has internal options they’re excited about. Letting Bellinger walk wouldn’t leave them empty-handed - it would just accelerate the youth movement in the Bronx.
Meanwhile, the Mets have a more pressing need in center field. They’ve been searching for a long-term answer at the position since the start of the 2025 season, and Bellinger fits the bill as a left-handed bat with Gold Glove-caliber defense. From a roster construction standpoint, he makes a lot of sense in Queens.
And let’s not forget - the Mets have already shown they’re willing to go toe-to-toe with the Yankees when it comes to marquee names. They won the Juan Soto sweepstakes last offseason, pulling off a stunner that shifted the balance of power in New York. If they decide to go all-in on Bellinger, it could be another seismic move.
There’s been some light chatter about other teams - the Blue Jays, for instance - potentially entering the mix. But as of now, the spotlight is squarely on the Yankees and Mets.
If the Mets swoop in and land Bellinger, it would be a huge win for Steve Cohen’s front office and another gut punch for Yankees fans still smarting from the Soto saga. But if the Yankees hold firm and Bellinger returns on their terms, it could be a savvy move that balances win-now talent with long-term flexibility.
Either way, the battle for Bellinger is shaping up to be another chapter in the ever-evolving New York baseball rivalry. And with both teams looking to make a statement this offseason, it’s a storyline worth watching closely.