The Yankees used the 10th overall pick in 1990 on Carl Everett, and for a while it looked like they might have landed another big piece for the franchise’s future. Instead, Everett’s New York story wound up being a strange one: he never played a game for the Yankees, then spent the bulk of his career with the Mets after both clubs moved on from him early.
Everett’s path out of the Yankees organization started fast. After three seasons in the minors, New York left him unprotected in the 1992 Expansion Draft, and the Miami Marlins grabbed him. That was the first sign that the Yankees had bailed on the player too soon, even if the bigger issues surrounding Everett’s life later made the whole situation less tidy than a simple baseball mistake.
The Mets got him next, landing Everett from the Marlins on November 29, 1994, in exchange for Quilvio Veras. He stuck around long enough to matter, piling up more than 300 plate appearances in 1995, a little over 200 in 1996 and nearly 500 in 1997.
But he never truly exploded in New York. By the time the Mets gave up on him, he was already in his age-26 season and hitting .250/.326/.402.
On December 22, 1997, they shipped him out for reliever John Hudek.
That decision looked shaky almost immediately. Everett headed to the Houston Astros and delivered the kind of production the Yankees and Mets never got out of him: a .296 average, 15 home runs and 76 RBIs. He followed that with an even better season, batting .325 with 25 homers and 108 RBIs, and finished 17th in MVP voting.
Everett would go on to make two All-Star teams and bounce around from club to club, but his longest stay ended up being with the Mets, where he played 322 games. That’s the most he ever played for any organization, which says plenty about how unusual his career became.
The on-field talent was never the question. Everett had plenty of it.
What made him memorable for other reasons were the headlines away from the diamond - including questioning the existence of dinosaurs, multiple arrests tied to domestic issues and, in 1997 while still with the Mets, an accusation of child neglect. That background may have helped explain why the Mets were ready to move on, with Brian McRae taking over in center field the next year.
In the end, Everett is one of those names that fits the messy middle of Yankees and Mets history: a first-round pick both teams let slip away, a player who flashed real upside, and a career that never stayed inside the lines long enough to make him a New York staple.
In Other News...
Another David Stearns Outfield Decision Is Starting To Sting For Mets Fans
Chicagos outfield picture has a way of making old decisions look sharper in hindsight, and Tristan Peters is the latest example. The 26-year-old rookie has worked his way into center field for the White Sox after arriving this offseason for cash considerations, a low-cost move that suddenly looks a lot more interesting as his bat and glove have started to settle in.
For the Mets, the sting is less about a glaring hole than a reminder of how quickly value can surface elsewhere. New York does have A.J. Ewing and Carson Benge moving through its own outfield pipeline, but Peters is the kind of player who can make a front office wonder whether it let another useful piece slip by before the rest of the league noticed. [Read more 🡒]
Mets Suddenly Have More Trade Chips In Play Than Fans Realized
The Mets trade picture has a lot more moving parts than it first appears, and Bo Bichette is only the biggest name in the mix. Once you start sorting through the roster, the bullpen alone offers several different paths, from Cionel Perez as a low-cost arm with little contractual baggage to left-handers A.J. Minter and Brooks Raley, both of whom could draw interest if New York decides to retool rather than simply stand pat.
Clay Holmes adds another layer because his value depends on timing as much as talent. He has been out since May 15, and the way his return lines up with the rest of the season could shape how aggressively another club would pursue him, especially with his player option hanging over the decision. Beyond that, the Phillies keep surfacing as a logical fit for multiple Mets pieces, which is a reminder that one front offices surplus can quickly become another clubs shopping list. [Read more 🡒]
Mets May Be Overthinking One Obvious Trade Decision
With the trade deadline picture starting to come into focus, one Mets outfield name deserves a harder look than it has gotten so far. Tyrone Taylor may not be the flashiest piece on the roster, but he checks a lot of boxes that contenders usually want in July: he can handle center field, he gives you competent at-bats in a reserve role, and he is on an expiring deal that makes him the kind of movable depth teams often circle.
Chelsea Janes of SNY grouped Mets trade candidates into the usual buckets, but Taylor landing in the longshot tier feels like a misread of his market. A veteran fourth outfielder with defensive value and a manageable salary can be useful to a club looking for stability on the bench, and the Mets have enough roster flexibility to consider moving him if the right offer comes along. The question is whether they see him as too important to keep around, or simply as one of the more obvious ways to add value before the deadline. [Read more 🡒]