Pete Alonso turned Citi Field into his own stage again Tuesday night, and the homecoming ended with a rare road curtain call - one that Mets starter Sean Manaea clearly didn’t appreciate.
Alonso, now with Baltimore after leaving New York this past offseason, launched his 300th career home run off Kodai Senga in the top of the ninth. The blast tied the game at three and sent the ball into the Citi Field seats, where the former Met once again drew a roar from the crowd. Alonso, who had spent 2019-25 with the Mets and hit 264 home runs for the club, soaked in the moment before stepping back out for a curtain call in front of the same fans who used to chant his name.
Per ESPN, Alonso became the third player to hit his 300th home run against a team for whom he played in 1,000 or more games.
The reaction in the ballpark was mixed, though the cheers were loud enough for Alonso to hear. Fans also broke into “fire Stearns” chants, aimed at David Stearns, the Mets president of baseball operations who let Alonso leave in the offseason.
After the game, Alonso said the scene still meant something to him.
"There's a lot of history here with me," Alonso said postgame, per ESPN. "It doesn't matter where and when, I just want to help the team win. I'm just really, really happy for us to come back the way we did."
"Everyone in the dugout was saying go out there. And they were right."
Alonso also spent time after the game with the fans who caught the milestone homer, trading autographs, bats and signed jerseys, and even bringing beers and offering them tickets to games in Baltimore.
Manaea, who started for New York on Tuesday, didn’t hold back when asked about the curtain call. He called it "crazy" and said he’d never seen anything like it.
"As the 2026 Mets, I know we have definitely underperformed. But we are -- the guys in here work their ass off every single day, and to have that kind of reaction to an opposing player, could be anybody, is crazy to me," Manaea said, per ESPN."
Again, I've got nothing but respect for Pete. But yeah, just never seen anything like that before."
He added that the former Mets slugger simply wasn’t part of the team anymore.
"Pete's not here," Manaea added. "He's just not here.
So I know everybody loves him. He's the man.
But yeah, he's not here. So to see the reaction from the fans like that, I don't know, it's just different."
Baltimore remained four games under .500 after Tuesday’s win, but Alonso’s return to Queens was the night’s defining scene - a milestone homer, a curtain call, and a former teammate left shaking his head.
In Other News...
Mets Manager Search Just Became A Huge Offseason Gamble
The Mets are heading into a managerial search with a lot more uncertainty than a typical offseason reset. After being eliminated from postseason contention and moving on from Carlos Mendoza in June, the club installed Andy Green as interim manager, and he is expected to slide back into a front office role once the search is complete.
Now the focus has shifted to who gets the job next, and the list includes some eye-catching possibilities. Reports say Carlos Beltran and Albert Pujols are among the candidates under consideration, even though neither has Major League Baseball managerial experience, leaving Steve Cohen with the final call and David Stearns involved in shaping a hire that could define how the organization moves forward. [Read more 🡒]
Mets Players Just Weighed In On Citi Fields Pete Alonso Problem
Pete Alonsos 300th career home run at Citi Field should have been a straightforward celebratory moment for a former Met returning to a familiar setting, but it ended up becoming something more complicated for everyone in the building. Sean Manaea and Francisco Lindor both said they were surprised, and in some ways frustrated, that a slice of the crowd was cheering for Alonso in the middle of a series that already had a restless feel around it.
Andy Green took a broader view of the reaction, calling it unusual but also a sign that fans appreciate players who do something impressive, even if they are wearing a different uniform now. The mixed response around the ballpark, including chants aimed at team president David Stearns, underscored how quickly the mood can shift at Citi Field, and why even a milestone as big as Alonsos can become part of a larger conversation about where the fan base is at right now. [Read more 🡒]
Mets Fans Just Reignited The Pete Alonso Frustration
Jonah Tong turned in one of the better nights of his young Mets tenure, working six innings without allowing an earned run against the Orioles and giving New York exactly the kind of steady outing a club wants from a top prospect. Still, the bigger conversation around the game had little to do with the line score. Pete Alonso, now facing his former team, drew a warm reception from the crowd as he came close to his 300th career home run off Tong, a moment that brought an odd mix of appreciation and frustration back to the surface.
Later, Alonso reached that milestone at Citi Field and was cheered again, a reaction that only sharpened the split feelings around his departure and how Mets fans continue to process it. For the players in uniform, it was a reminder that the Alonso story still lingers around this team, even when the baseball itself gives them plenty else to talk about. Tong did his part on the mound, but the crowds response ensured the night carried a familiar layer of tension. [Read more 🡒]