The Philadelphia Phillies are staring down a pivotal offseason, and it starts with a major question: will Kyle Schwarber be back in red pinstripes next season?
After a strong 2025 campaign that saw Schwarber finish as the MVP runner-up, the slugger is now hitting free agency. And while there’s a real chance he returns to Philly, the front office can’t afford to sit still. They’ve got to prepare for all scenarios-including the possibility of replacing one of the most consistent power bats in the game.
One name that makes a lot of sense if Schwarber walks? Pete Alonso.
Let’s break it down. Over the last four seasons, Schwarber has been one of the top four home run hitters in baseball.
That kind of production doesn’t grow on trees. But if you’re the Phillies and you want to replace Schwarber’s thunder in the lineup, why not go after another member of that elite power-hitting group?
Enter Alonso, the New York Mets’ All-Star first baseman, who just wrapped up a monster 2025 season. In 162 games, he posted a .272/.347/.524 slash line with 41 doubles, 38 homers, and 126 RBI.
That’s not just solid-it’s elite. And it’s remarkably close to what Schwarber brings to the table, with one key difference: Alonso can hold his own defensively at first base.
That opens up some intriguing possibilities for the Phillies. Signing Alonso would allow Bryce Harper to shift back to right field, a move that could help the team defensively.
It also potentially solves the lingering Nick Castellanos dilemma. Castellanos has had his moments at the plate, but his glove has been a liability.
If Alonso comes in and Harper returns to the outfield, the Phillies could finally shore up a defense that’s been shaky at times.
Of course, this all hinges on whether Schwarber stays or goes. But make no mistake-if he does walk, Alonso isn’t just a replacement. He’s a legitimate sidegrade, someone who can match Schwarber’s offensive output while giving the Phillies more flexibility in the field.
This is the kind of move that could define the Phillies’ offseason. They’re already a contender. But with the right piece-or the right replacement-they could take another step toward October glory.