Pete Alonso's career trajectory draws intriguing parallels to some of the Mets' all-time greats. While comparisons to Darryl Strawberry are inevitable due to their shared slugging prowess and home run records, Alonso's path might more closely mirror another Mets legend-Mike Piazza-but in reverse.
Piazza, who dons a Mets cap in the Hall of Fame, had his most productive years with the Los Angeles Dodgers, despite his deep connection with New York fans. His 32 bWAR with the Dodgers overshadows the 24.6 he posted with the Mets. Similarly, Alonso's prime years may be tied to the Mets, yet his legacy could be shaped by his time with the Orioles.
Having spent seven years with the Mets and only five under team control with the Orioles, Alonso's situation isn't a carbon copy of Piazza's. However, with potential contract extensions, his tenure in Baltimore could stretch significantly.
Alonso's 23.3 bWAR with the Mets is strikingly close to Piazza's during his New York stint, but numbers only tell part of the story. Piazza's .331 batting average with the Dodgers versus .296 with the Mets highlights his prowess. His consistent top finishes in MVP voting from 1993 to 1997 underscored his dominance.
Alonso, on the other hand, has already carved out a memorable playoff moment against the Milwaukee Brewers, something Piazza never achieved with the Dodgers despite his regular-season brilliance. If Alonso can replicate his impact in Baltimore, leading the Orioles to multiple playoff appearances, he could well be remembered more as an Oriole than a Met.
The question of which cap Alonso might wear into Cooperstown will depend on his future accomplishments. Meanwhile, the Mets may soon face a similar scenario with Juan Soto, who is expected to leave a lasting impression in New York, much like he did with the Nationals.
Ultimately, how Alonso is perceived by fans in 2040 is still unfolding. His career could resonate with both Mets and Orioles fans, similar to how Keith Hernandez is cherished by both the Mets and the Cardinals. His broadcasting presence and New York championship have cemented his legacy in a unique way, and Alonso's journey might just echo that multifaceted impact.