Nolan McLean’s 2026 pitch mix looked a lot different from the version the Mets saw in 2025, and the biggest shift came with a simple truth: the sweeper stopped working, so the rest of the arsenal had to do more of the heavy lifting.
In all, McLean threw eight different pitches for New York in 2026, with the old standbys mostly still in the mix and two new offerings changing the shape of his profile. Some of the results held steady.
Others fell off hard. And in a few cases, the numbers made the answer pretty obvious about what should stay and what probably should go.
The sinker remained his go-to weapon, and the production stayed close to what it was a year earlier. Hitters batted .193 against it in 2025 and .191 in 2026.
The bigger change came on the ground: his ground-ball rate on the pitch dropped from 60% to 45.9%. Even so, the sinker still did its job, especially with an average exit velocity of 87.2 mph compared with 92.4 mph in 2025.
His four-seam fastball, though, was a different story. McLean leaned on it more, but hitters did much more damage.
They hit seven home runs off the pitch and posted a .460 slugging percentage against it, after nobody homered against it in 2025 and opponents slugged just .154. The whiff rate also slid from 37.1% to 27.2%.
If that pitch is going to be a bigger piece of the puzzle, it has to get sharper.
The curveball stayed right around the same usage level, and it still looked like one of his best pitches. Opponents hit just .132 against it in 2026, which is nowhere near the .074 mark it held in 2025, but it remained a real weapon. McLean clearly knows what he’s doing with that pitch.
The sweeper, on the other hand, never found its footing. Batters hit .361 against it in 2025 and .366 against it in 2026. The expected numbers offered a little more hope, with a .259 xBA this year compared with .380 last year, but the actual results were ugly enough to make the pitch feel expendable.
The cutter also became more of a regular part of the mix, and that didn’t go well. Hitters posted a .338 average and a personal-worst .554 slugging percentage against it.
That was a sharp drop from 2025, when the cutter held opponents to a .250 average. For now, it looks like another pitch that may need to be rethought.
McLean’s changeup got a little harder, jumping from 86.8 mph to 88.2 mph, but the added velocity didn’t translate into better results. Its Put Away percentage dropped from 36% in 2025 to 13% in 2026, and opponents hit .262 against it after managing just .143 the year before.
The most encouraging development was the slider. New to McLean’s arsenal, it immediately looked like something worth keeping.
Batters hit only .077 against it, and the pitch generated a 37% whiff rate, just behind the 37.8% mark on his curveball. In practical terms, it seems to have taken the place of the sweeper.
There was also a slow curve in the mix, though only four were thrown, which is nowhere near enough to draw much of a conclusion. It flashed as a possible occasional out-getter, but nothing more.
Taken together, McLean’s best pitches still stood out and his weak spots became easier to spot. The slider may be the biggest win from the year, especially if it continues to replace the sweeper.
From there, the next step is clear enough: either the four-seamer or cutter has to improve, or the sinker has to become so dominant that it defines the whole arsenal. The sinker already carried a 27 Run Value and was the best pitch in the sport this past season that wasn’t a 4-seamer.
In Other News...
Mets Trade Return Suddenly Looks A Lot Better After Cubs Exit
The Cubs quick exit from the Wild Card Series only sharpened the view from Queens. Chicago was swept by the Padres, and for the Mets, that result offers a fresh lens on the trade deadline deal that sent Clay Holmes and Tyrone Taylor to the North Side in exchange for prospect Jefferson Rojas. Holmes and Taylor were brought in to help a postseason push, but their impact was limited when it mattered most.
Rojas, meanwhile, is the piece New York can point to as it looks beyond this October. He is regarded as a promising young player who could fit into the Mets future roster, and Chicagos short stay in the playoffs makes the return feel even more relevant in hindsight. For a club still balancing present needs with long-term planning, that kind of upside is exactly what can make a deadline move age well. [Read more 🡒]
Mets Bullpen Problem Puts David Stearns Under Winter Pressure
The Mets spent the trade deadline moving several bullpen arms out of the picture, and the group theyre left with has only reinforced how much work still needs to be done. President of baseball operations David Stearns has already acknowledged shortcomings in the way the roster was built, and with the relief corps looking shaky, the winter figures to be shaped by how aggressively he chooses to address it.
Free agency should give Stearns a chance to add proven help rather than hope for internal fixes alone, and there are a handful of relievers who fit the profile of possible targets. Chris Minter, Adam, Abreu and Taylor Clarke are among the names to watch as the Mets try to steady a unit that has become one of the clearest pressure points on the roster. [Read more 🡒]
Mets May Be Running Out Of Time With Ronny Mauricio
Ronny Mauricios place with the Mets has quietly become one of the more interesting roster questions on the board. After appearing in 20 major league games in 2026 and showing some pop with four home runs, the young infielder still has not found the kind of regular role that would let the club properly evaluate him over time.
Because Mauricio has no minor league options left, the Mets may soon have to make a tougher call than simply sending him back down. A trade has started to look like the likeliest path, and the Seattle Mariners have come up as a possible fit with needs at both shortstop and third base, which could push this situation toward a resolution sooner rather than later. [Read more 🡒]