MJ Melendez is making waves at the New York Mets camp, and he's got a real shot at cracking the Opening Day roster. With Carson Benge's status uncertain, Melendez could be a temporary solution in right field. Signed to a split contract, he’s a low-risk addition for the Mets, even if he doesn’t perfectly fit their offseason plans.
Melendez brings experience, a strong arm, and some pop to the plate, though his defense and hitting have been less than stellar. As a depth piece, his potential value is clear.
Carlos Mendoza, speaking highly of Melendez, noted, “I think there’s more in the tank. He’s coming off a couple of down years, but I remember when he first came into the league he was a pretty good player -- he’s going to get an opportunity here.”
Melendez is known for his catching background, which could be handy if the Mets need flexibility with Francisco Alvarez as DH. However, his performance as an outfielder and hitter has been inconsistent.
With a career .215/.297/.388 slash line, 19 home runs, and 163 strikeouts per 162 games, Melendez's upside lies in his occasional power. His playing time with the Mets will likely be less than his early days with the Royals.
If Melendez makes the roster, it wouldn’t be a major upset. Anyone he might edge out, like Benge or Ronny Mauricio, is likely to remain within the organization, or they’re replaceable, like Vidal Brujan. The Mets have been misled before by similar scenarios, such as with Zack Short and Joey Wendle in 2024.
Melendez could serve as a platoon option in right field alongside someone like Tyrone Taylor, or replace Brujan if Brett Baty shifts to a utility role. While the Mets value strong defense, they’ve shown willingness to take chances on players like Melendez. Unlike position shifts for players like Bo Bichette, the Mets are clear on what Melendez offers.
The recent signing of Mike Tauchman adds competition, but with Melendez on a guaranteed deal, the decision might hinge more on contract structure than pure performance.