The Mets are moving into a new youth wave, but the old one is fading fast.
Nolan McLean, Carson Benge, Christian Scott and A.J. Ewing have become real parts of the 2026 picture, and Jonah Tong is set to spend September trying to earn a place on the 2027 roster.
There’s energy around that group. There should be.
But the Mets’ own recent history is a reminder that young talent doesn’t always grow in a straight line.
The previous group - the one fans came to know as the “Baby Mets” - is close to disappearing from the organization’s plans altogether. That core was built around Mark Vientos, Brett Baty, Francisco Alvarez and Ronny Mauricio, with LuisAngel Acuna added at the 2023 trade deadline.
Each flashed enough to make it look like a future was taking shape. None of those flashes turned into something steady.
Acuna is already out of the picture after being dealt to the Chicago White Sox in the Luis Robert trade. Mauricio has never looked the same since the major knee injury he suffered in the 2023 offseason. Vientos’ huge second half in 2024 and Baty’s solid 2025 now look more like peaks than beginnings.
Alvarez is the one who has managed to carve out a real role, and at 24, he still brings pop behind the plate. Even so, the offensive flaws are obvious, and his defense has slipped enough that Luis Torrens has taken on a larger share of the work late in the season.
The bigger issue is that a lot of these players were never set up cleanly in the first place. The Mets’ player development system was in rough shape early in Steve Cohen’s ownership run, with the club cycling through top baseball executives and managers who had different ideas about how to build a roster.
That kind of instability can leave holes in a player’s game that don’t get patched up in the minors. It also makes the majors a bad classroom, and the Mets burned through a lot of option years on players like Vientos and Mauricio by shuttling them back and forth without giving them a stable runway.
Now the roster math is catching up. Vientos and Mauricio will be out of options after this year, which makes both harder to keep around, especially with defensive problems and only certain spots where they can really hit.
There’s even a real chance the Mets could non-tender both players. A bench full of one-dimensional bats doesn’t give a team much flexibility.
Baty, meanwhile, still has one minor league option left and can handle second and third, which gives him a path to hang on as a utility piece. The catch is that the Mets are also trying to force him into the outfield to manufacture more at-bats, and that may not be the best use of him.
Alvarez remains the most intriguing case. The Mets could pair him with Torrens while trying to get the defense back to a workable level. But Alvarez has his own swing issue, especially his tendency to chase high fastballs, and opposing pitchers can use that against him.
The Mets got some trade interest in Alvarez at last month’s deadline, and if they decide Torrens can handle the job as the primary catcher, moving Alvarez to help elsewhere on the roster is on the table. If that happens, it’s not hard to imagine Baty being the only Baby Met still around in 2027.
What happened with that group is a reminder of how difficult it is to develop major league talent, especially when the organization keeps changing around it. The current rookie class has had the same player development structure in place for three years under David Stearns, who came over from Milwaukee, a club known for developing talent well.
The Mets have also shifted the kind of players they target under Stearns, going after more athletic hitters and pitchers with plus stuff. The idea is simple: give them better raw tools, then give them a system that can actually shape those tools properly.
That combination - a more coherent development plan and a different kind of prospect pipeline - is the Mets’ attempt to make sure the next wave doesn’t end up the same way.
In Other News...
Mets First Base Problem Is Starting To Point In One Direction
The Mets are already looking ahead to 2027 with first base on the list of places that could use a reset. Last offseasons attempt to solve the position with Jorge Polanco never really got off the ground, with injuries limiting his time and leaving the club without much clarity about what the long-term answer should be.
Jake Bauers has started to emerge as a name worth watching in that search. Bleacher Report floated the Brewers first baseman as a possible target, and his strong season could put him on the market if he reaches free agency, giving the Mets another avenue to explore as they keep sorting out a spot that has not settled into place. [Read more 🡒]
Jacob deGrom Just Put Mets Fans Through A Familiar Misery Again
Jacob deGrom keeps producing the kind of outings that should feel automatic for a win, only for the result to turn into something all too familiar for Mets fans. In a recent start, he delivered six scoreless innings with 12 strikeouts and no walks, part of a stretch that included his second one-hitter in three games, yet the team still came away empty after another night in which his work on the mound was not matched by enough help elsewhere.
OptaSTATS noted just how unusual the loss was, saying deGrom is the only modern-era MLB pitcher to finish a scoreless start with 12 or more strikeouts and no walks, leave with a lead of three or more runs, and still wind up taking the loss. It fit a pattern Mets followers know too well, with this latest game joining a list of other strong deGrom performances that were wasted when the offense could not turn dominance into comfort. [Read more 🡒]
Rays May Have Found Another Pitching Fix With Freddy Peralta
The Rays took Freddy Peralta from the Mets knowing full well he was more project than finished product, and theyve already started to get a return on that gamble. Under pitching coach Kyle Snyder, Peralta has worked through changes in both his delivery and pitch mix, with the changeup emerging as a much more useful weapon as he has settled in over his recent outings.
In his last three starts, the right-hander has looked far more like a pitcher with a path forward than one still searching for answers, allowing just two runs and one walk over 18 innings. For a Tampa Bay staff that has long made its reputation on finding fixes others miss, Peraltas early progress is another reminder of how quickly the Rays can turn a reclamation case into something more interesting. [Read more 🡒]