Bleacher Report’s Tim Kelly floated five unpopular MLB trades, and one of them doesn’t sound all that far-fetched: the Athletics sending Shea Langeliers to the Mets.
Langeliers has built himself into one of the better offensive catchers in the game. He came up as a former Braves prospect and was part of the return in the Matt Olson deal, and after a power-first start to his career, the bat has taken a real step forward. Over the last two seasons, he’s hit .270/.326/.507, and his strikeout rate has fallen from the high 20s to as low as 19.7% in 2025.
That kind of production is exactly why his trade value would be so high right now. The Athletics also have reasons to listen, since they need help in other areas and could decide this is the moment to cash in. If the Mets were serious about making a run at him, the price would start with Francisco Alvarez.
In a simple version of the deal, the Mets would get Langeliers while the Athletics would land Alvarez, plus either Zac Thornton or Jonah Tong, along with Zach Franklin.
Alvarez is the centerpiece, and for good reason. He’s under team control through the 2029 season, and the upside is still there. That’s part of what makes this kind of swap tricky for both sides: the Mets would be moving a catcher with plenty of runway left, while the Athletics would be giving up a proven big-league hitter in Langeliers.
That’s also why the package needs more than just Alvarez. Thornton makes sense as the extra piece if the Mets go that route.
He climbed through the system last year, but the underlying numbers were more ordinary than eye-catching. He doesn’t miss many bats, and his only clearly defined major league skill is avoiding walks.
He also doesn’t have a locked-in role for 2027, especially if New York is serious about adding two starting pitchers this offseason.
If Thornton doesn’t do it for Oakland, Tong is the other option. He was always viewed as the bigger prospect, but his place in the organization has stalled.
The Mets haven’t shown any real sign of moving him to relief, though that may be premature. Even so, there doesn’t appear to be an immediate spot for him in the rotation, and 2027 looks like another year of him continuing to develop while trying to take the next step.
Franklin would be part of the return as well. He came over in the Huascar Brazoban deal, and because he’s Rule 5 eligible, moving him would help the Mets. The Athletics would have to protect him, and he’d give either club another bullpen arm to consider for this coming season.
If the Mets wanted to push the conversation further, the Athletics could also be asked to make sense of Ronny Mauricio or Mark Vientos, or to include another prospect outside the top 20. But asking for much more than that would likely mean Oakland would need something else coming back too.
The appeal here is obvious: Langeliers would give New York a more certain punch in the lineup and speed up the version of Francisco Alvarez everyone hopes to see. For a catcher with that kind of bat, the Mets would probably have to pay in pitching.
In Other News...
Mets Quiet Trade Could Set Up David Stearns Next Move
The Mets made a small but telling move by sending minor-league right-hander Juan Arnaud to the Rangers in exchange for $250,000 in international signing bonus pool space. It is the kind of transaction that barely registers on a busy calendar, but it gives the front office more flexibility while the international signing period remains open through Dec. 15.
Arnaud, whom the Mets signed in 2021, was also eligible for the upcoming Rule 5 draft, so the deal clears one more item from the clubs winter to-do list without forcing a protection decision. For a team still shaping its roster-building options, the trade suggests David Stearns is keeping an eye on the bigger picture, even when the move itself is easy to miss. [Read more 🡒]
Mets Face A Risky 40-Man Decision They Can't Afford To Miss
With the Rule 5 Draft approaching, the Mets are staring at one of those roster-management puzzles that can shape a winter before it really begins. Jefferson Rojas looks like the easy call among the clubs prospect group, but beyond him the picture gets murkier fast, with names like Chris Suero, Jack Wenninger and Gary Gill Hill all sitting in that uneasy middle ground where upside, development timeline and 40-man space have to be weighed against one another.
For a front office trying to protect the right pieces without clogging the roster, the risk is obvious: leave the wrong player exposed and another team can swoop in and stash him away. The Mets have several prospects who appear unlikely to get protected, but the real challenge is sorting out which of the borderline cases are worth the added commitment now and which ones can be left vulnerable without coming back to haunt them later. [Read more 🡒]
Stearns Just Clarified Where Mets Could Still Make A Big Upgrade
David Stearns used the offseason to sketch out where the Mets still see room to improve, and the clearest takeaway was that second base appears settled. He voiced confidence in Marcus Semien as the starting option there, which narrows the focus for a front office that has spent the winter weighing how to round out the rest of the roster.
First base looks like the likeliest place for a meaningful addition, with Stearns saying the club is exploring both free-agent and trade possibilities. He also left the door open to upgrades at designated hitter and catcher, so while the Mets have a better sense of one infield spot, the bigger question is how aggressively they choose to address the other openings before spring arrives. [Read more 🡒]
