At the All-Star break, the Mets are staring at a 40-57 record and a distant place at the bottom of the NL East, and the offseason that set this mess in motion looks even rougher in hindsight. The roster churn brought in big swings, a few calculated risks, and more than a couple of moves that have aged badly fast.
If you strip away the minor-league fliers, the small trades, and the departures, the picture gets pretty clear: New York spent the winter trying to remake itself, and most of the major additions have not delivered the kind of payoff the front office wanted.
Luke Weaver has been the bright spot. The signing earns an A+, and for good reason - this one went about as well as the Mets could have hoped. In a winter full of frustration, Weaver stood out as the best move on the board, even with the usual uncertainty that comes with relief pitching.
Bo Bichette’s deal lands at a B, though “massive overpay” is the phrase that hangs over it. The short-term nature of the contract keeps it from becoming a disaster.
If he opts in, there’s at least a chance he looks more like the player he’s been after that slow start. If he opts out, the Mets can either bring him back on a better number or hope the fanbase moves on.
It hasn’t worked out cleanly, but it also hasn’t turned into an all-time blunder.
The Freddy Peralta and Tobias Myers trade checks in at C, and that feels generous only because the intent behind it was sound. The Mets gave up two top 100 prospects, Jett Williams and Brandon Sproat, to bring in a starter-to-be in Peralta and a swingman in Myers.
Peralta has underachieved, and Myers has been unpitchable, which has made the whole thing look worse by the week. If Williams and Sproat become stars for the Milwaukee Brewers, this grade could slide even further.
Luis Robert Jr. also gets a C, but this one is easier to stomach because the Mets didn’t surrender much. Luisangel Acuna was on the way to being DFA’d anyway, so the cost was minimal.
Robert’s mostly absent season was something plenty of people saw coming, and with A.J. Ewing now in center field, a lot of fans have stopped worrying much about what comes next.
Devin Williams lands at C-. He hasn’t been a total bust, but he was part of the team’s early-season problems and the three-year contract is going to keep this one under the microscope for a while.
It’s not a bargain, and it’s not a disaster. It’s just there, with next season’s outlook as the Mets’ closer still very much up in the air.
The Brandon Nimmo for Marcus Semien trade gets a D+. That’s a tough one to sort through this early, since the point was always to clear money down the line.
But when Semien is barely hitting and playing poor defense, the long-term flexibility argument loses a lot of shine. Keeping Nimmo would have changed the mood around this team in a big way, and the old “devil you know vs. the one you don’t” line fits here.
Jorge Polanco comes in at D. The Mets should have expected some time on the IL, and they got it.
Even when he was healthy early on, nagging issues limited him and pushed him into DH work. The fit was shaky from the start because he lacked versatility and wasn’t comfortable at the position the Mets had talked up for him at first base.
Add in the fact that he’ll be a year older next season, and this one starts looking even worse. The money could have gone somewhere else, and that matters.
MJ Melendez finishes the list at D-. He had a couple of good days, but mostly he was a strikeout waiting to happen.
It was a worthwhile flier at under $2 million, but only nine games into his Mets run, he was cut. That’s a failure, plain and simple, even if the price tag kept it from becoming an even bigger one.
In Other News...
Rangers Fans Are Learning The Jacob deGrom Routine The Hard Way
Jacob deGroms latest turn in Texas has brought a familiar kind of tension for anyone who watched his Mets years closely: the ace stuff is still there, the workload is still manageable, and the next step is suddenly murky. In his fourth season with the Rangers, deGrom has made 18 starts and posted a 3.49 ERA, production that has helped stabilize the rotation even as the club waits to see how his body responds.
The uncertainty now is less about what deGrom can do on the mound than when the Rangers should ask him to do it again. He has said he can pitch through the discomfort, but the organization has to balance that against the risk of pushing him back too quickly. For a team trying to keep its rotation intact, the answer to that question could matter as much as any outing he has made so far. [Read more 🡒]
How Badly Did These Mets Roster Cuts Come Back To Haunt Them
A handful of the Mets recent roster cuts have already turned into a mixed bag elsewhere, which is exactly the kind of thing that can linger when a team is trying to sort out the back end of a bullpen or the edges of a bench. Craig Kimbrel has found work with the Rays and given them steady innings, Bryan Hudson has become a useful piece for the White Sox, and Richard Lovelady has carved out a role in Washington after New York moved on.
Austin Slaters path has been less direct, with his return to Tampa Bay leading to a demotion before he started producing in Triple-A, while the former Mets right-hander who landed in Minnesota has had a far rougher time keeping runs off the board. For a club that is always trying to balance short-term fixes against longer-term stability, these are the kinds of departures that can look minor in the moment and a lot more complicated a few weeks later. [Read more 🡒]
The Mets Have Made This Painful All-Star Move Five Times
Since 1992, the Mets have had a strange and painful habit of moving an All-Star in the same year he earned the honor, a reminder of how often the franchise has been willing to trade present value for future hope. The list stretches across eras and roster cycles, from Bobby Bonilla and David Cone in the 1990s to Rick Reed and Armando Benitez in the early 2000s, with each deal carrying its own mix of urgency, disappointment and second-guessing.
The Cone move remains one of the most consequential in hindsight because it came late in the season and helped reshape more than one pennant race. Even now, the pattern says plenty about the Mets' history of trying to balance contention with retooling, and why any in-season All-Star trade in Queens tends to feel bigger than a single transaction. [Read more 🡒]