Mets Winter Mistakes Could Cost Them The Infield Help They Need

With past decisions casting a long shadow, the Mets find themselves curbing ambitions in the free-agent market as they navigate costly commitments.

The New York Mets could have had a much cleaner path into free agency this winter. Instead, last winter’s moves are still hanging around the roster, and that’s making the shopping list a lot tighter than it should be.

Marcus Semien is still under contract for two more years, and while a reduced role would make sense if he doesn’t produce, it’s tough to imagine the Mets swallowing that deal before at least another season passes. Jorge Polanco is part of the problem too. His injury-riddled year and lack of production didn’t help, and with another season on the books for 2027, he continues to take up both payroll space and a roster spot without a clear role.

If those two situations weren’t already sitting there, the Mets would have more freedom to chase help in free agency. As it stands, they probably have to let those holdovers get another shot. That makes a few appealing names feel more like wishful thinking than realistic targets.

Brandon Lowe is one of them. He’s gone from being a shaky defender at second base to posting a 12 OAA season with the Pittsburgh Pirates, and the bat has never really been the issue.

Lowe owns a lifetime .810 OPS and has had three seasons with more than 30 home runs. Last season, he hit 35 and drove in 96 runs for the Pirates.

He also received and declined the qualifying offer from Pittsburgh, which already makes him a tricky fit. He can handle second base, and apparently do it well now, or even first base, but he still looks like a player the Mets would love to have and probably won’t land.

Luis Arraez fits a similar mold, just in a very different way. The long-running concern with him has been defense and the fact that he doesn’t bring much beyond contact and batting titles.

Then he turned into a 10 OAA defender with the San Francisco Giants and finished the year with the Philadelphia Phillies while batting .310 overall. That kind of defensive jump makes him more attractive in the market than he would’ve been if he were still the below-average infielder he’s often been.

But defense can swing year to year, and Arraez would come with a different kind of profile than Lowe. Lowe brings power and strikeouts with RBI production.

Arraez is there to put the ball in play. Even with that versatility, the Mets’ roster construction makes him look just as unlikely.

Ty France feels like the least likely of the three for a different reason. There are plenty of reasons to doubt he can repeat what he did with the San Diego Padres last season, and he’s in line for a deal that should run at least three years, with a push for a fourth.

He’s expected to land in the range of $15-16 million per year, which would still make him a better value than what Polanco became. But Polanco’s presence - and his uncertain role as a DH or possible first baseman - keeps blocking the Mets from adding offense more than Semien does.

And this isn’t a case where the Mets can just move on easily. They’ve already shown there’s a spending limit.

That’s why the better bet may be something else entirely, like Paul Goldschmidt, Alec Bohm, or a trade addition.

In Other News...

Mets Could Be Ready To Move On From A Recent Breakout Bat

Mark Vientos looked like one of the Mets more intriguing young bats after his 2024 breakout, but the follow-up has not matched that surge. According to Tim Kelly of Bleacher Report, the infielder has already surfaced as a top trade candidate heading into the offseason, a sign that New York may be willing to revisit its infield mix if the right opportunity comes along.

For a Mets team that has spent recent seasons trying to find more stability and upside in the lineup, Vientos uneven production has made him harder to project as a long-term fixture. The possibility of moving him after the 2026 season would fit a broader roster reset, though it also leaves open an obvious question about whether the club is ready to give up on a player who still has some appeal as a bat with upside. [Read more 🡒]

Mets Could Find Answers For Two Roster Holes This Week

With the non-tender deadline approaching, the Mets have a chance to shop the margins of the market and maybe solve a couple of nagging roster questions before winter really gets moving. The group of possible available players includes names with different paths and profiles, from power bats to arms who could help in a staff that still needs reinforcement, and that sort of opportunity is exactly where front offices can find value without paying full free-agent prices.

Jake Burger stands out as a possible answer at first base, while the pitching side of the board includes Luis Gil, Kutter Crawford, Jake Bird and Garrett Cleavinger as potential fits worth monitoring. None of them would be a sure thing, and each comes with its own level of risk, but for a Mets club trying to patch holes efficiently, this week could open a useful lane if one of those teams decides to move on. [Read more 🡒]

Mets Still Have One Bullpen Problem This Move Does Not Solve

The Mets added another arm to the organizational bullpen mix by signing veteran right-hander Joel Kuhnel to a minor-league contract, a familiar kind of depth move this time of year. Kuhnel brings major league experience with several teams, and he arrives after posting a 4.40 ERA across 45 innings in the 2026 season, giving New York another experienced option to evaluate as camp approaches.

It is also the latest in a string of low-risk additions for a relief corps that still has questions to answer. The Mets recently brought in left-hander Justin King on a minor-league deal with a spring training invitation, which helps stock the system with candidates, but it does not fully address the bigger bullpen issue the club is still trying to solve. [Read more 🡒]