The Mets took a meaningful step forward by signing veteran infielder Jorge Polanco, who’s coming off one of the most productive offensive seasons of his career. But make no mistake-this move isn’t the final piece of their offseason puzzle. In fact, it might just be the beginning of a broader strategy to reinforce the lineup, especially at first base.
Polanco is expected to see time at both designated hitter and first base, but the Mets aren’t stopping there. They’re still keeping an eye on the market for a right-handed power bat-someone who can bring more thump to the middle of the order. And that’s where Willson Contreras enters the conversation.
According to reports, the Mets have shown interest in the Cardinals slugger and are continuing to evaluate how he might fit into their roster. It’s a logical connection.
With Pete Alonso now in Baltimore, there’s a clear void at first base-not just defensively, but in terms of raw power production. Contreras could help fill that gap.
Now, let’s be clear: Contreras isn’t Alonso. But he’s no slouch either.
When healthy, he’s a consistent 20-plus home run threat and brings a level of offensive consistency that’s hard to ignore. Last season, he played in 135 games and posted a .257/.344/.447 slash line, launching 20 homers and racking up a career-high 31 doubles.
That kind of production from the right side of the plate would give the Mets a much-needed counterbalance to Juan Soto in the lineup.
Contreras has built a reputation over his decade in the big leagues-most of it with the Cubs-as a reliable offensive contributor. His career .258 average and .811 OPS speak to his ability to impact games regularly, and his bat speed and quality of contact metrics back up the eye test. He’s not just getting by; he’s making loud contact and doing it with consistency.
But it’s not just the bat that makes Contreras intriguing for New York. There’s also his glove.
While Polanco is still learning the position and has struggled defensively across the infield, Contreras is coming off his first full season playing first base and graded out well. Statcast rated him as a plus defender using the outs above average metric, which is no small feat for someone transitioning from catcher to first.
Of course, there’s one more layer to consider: Contreras holds a no-trade clause. That means any potential deal would need his approval.
According to reports, the 33-year-old has expressed a preference to stay in St. Louis but is open to a move if it benefits his family and fits their lifestyle.
So, where does that leave the Mets? In a position of cautious pursuit.
They’ve already added a versatile bat in Polanco, but the possibility of bringing in Contreras shows they’re still aiming higher. Adding his power and defensive upside would give the Mets another legitimate weapon-not just to replace Alonso, but to reshape the identity of their lineup.
This is about more than just plugging a hole. It’s about building a lineup that can compete deep into October. And if the Mets can land Contreras, they’ll be one step closer to doing just that.