The Mets have spent enough time looking for reasons not to chase Tarik Skubal. In 2026, those reasons have pretty much vanished.
With the Los Angeles Dodgers already in the mix and the Mets looming as the biggest obstacle, this is shaping up as a two-team race for the top-tier free agent. And for New York, the case is getting harder to dodge by the day: if Steve Cohen is going to open the wallet for a premium arm, Skubal is the kind of name that makes the most sense.
The rotation is the first place that argument starts. The Mets have enough moving parts to fill out a staff, but Skubal would change the entire conversation.
Zac Thornton could be sent down to keep developing, or he could stay in the picture. Sean Manaea has been steady enough to work near the back of the rotation.
Nolan McLean has put together a strong season that hasn’t gotten quite the attention it deserves because expectations were sky-high. Christian Scott looks more like a mid-rotation starter than a headline ace, but there’s still room for him to grow.
Add Skubal to that group, and that’s five.
That’s the part that should matter most. The Mets believed they were getting ace-level production from Freddy Peralta in 2026, but Skubal is in a different tier.
If he winds up at something like $44 million per year, the logic is pretty straightforward: would the Mets rather spend that money on one true difference-maker or split it between two players at $22 million apiece? In this case, the big bet looks cleaner than trying to spread the dollars around and hope it all works out.
The bullpen also gives them more breathing room than they might have expected. Even after the trade deadline stripped things down, the relief group has held up well in August.
If the Mets were mapping out next year’s bullpen right now, they could already point to Devin Williams, Kodai Senga, Daniel Duarte, Jonathan Pintaro, Nate Lavender, and Austin Warren. Some of those arms are optionable and could bounce between the majors and minors, but the point stands: there are affordable pieces here.
They’d still need help, especially another lefty and a right-handed arm, and the final read on Senga still isn’t complete. But the existence of those low-cost options matters.
David Stearns likely treats starters and relievers as separate budget buckets, and the bullpen’s cheap depth makes it easier to justify pushing harder for Skubal. If he lands him, Stearns can still keep building a functional relief mix without blowing up the rest of the plan.
At first base, Jared Young has also changed the math. His grip on playing time has grown stronger because he’s hitting, defending, and looking like the heavier side of a platoon.
That kind of production gives the Mets a path forward without needing to chase an expensive fix. If they do decide to pair him with someone else, the move could be more about reshuffling pieces than making a major splash.
The source even floated the idea of trading Marcus Semien for a longer bad contract, just to illustrate how little urgency there may be elsewhere.
Young’s emergence is especially important because it gives Stearns something real to point to after the Pete Alonso decision. First base has been a mess for the Mets in most respects, but Young has been the bright spot. If they can find a cheap platoon partner and keep the position from becoming a money pit, that only frees up more cash for the one move that keeps coming back to the front of the line: Skubal.
The outfield rookies have helped the same argument. Carson Benge needed a few weeks before he started looking like a big leaguer, while A.J.
Ewing has tailed off in the second half. Still, Ewing looks like he belongs, ideally hitting ninth and giving the Mets defense and stolen bases.
Benge, meanwhile, has shown enough to project anywhere from the top of the order to the middle.
And that matters because both are on league-minimum contracts. When young players are filling roles that quickly, it pushes the front office toward spending on the places where money actually matters.
This season, no area has demanded that more than the rotation. The Mets have tried nearly everything except paying a star ace in free agency, and that’s exactly why Skubal looms so large now.
They were already expected to add some kind of outfield help this offseason, and starting pitching was not the likeliest place for a bargain search. If they do address the rotation, it would probably be for veteran depth rather than another major splash.
But the real splash is right there.
In Other News...
Mets Suddenly Have A September Decision Fans Should Watch Closely
MJ Melendez has spent much of the 2026 season bouncing between the majors and Triple-A, and the results have left the Mets with a tricky evaluation as September approaches. He has been solid enough in both stops to stay on the radar, but his recent strong stretch at Triple-A has contrasted with limited success in the big leagues, keeping the organization in the familiar spot of weighing upside against what it can count on right now.
Jonah Tong has pushed his way into the conversation on a different track, turning in a one-hit shutout in a minor league double-header game and building on a better August overall. Even so, some of the underlying numbers suggest the improvement may not be as clean as the surface results, which makes his next step especially interesting. The Mets still appear likely to bring him back to the majors because of their roster needs, and that leaves one of the more watchable September decisions hanging over the club. [Read more 🡒]
Mets Face A Tough 40-Man Call On Their Peralta Trade Return
Several Mets prospects are about to enter a tricky offseason window, and Gary Gill Hill is part of the conversation. The 21-year-old right-hander, acquired in the Freddy Peralta trade, has taken a step forward in Double-A and now looks like one of the names the front office has to weigh carefully as it sorts through the clubs Rule 5-eligible players.
Protecting prospects from the draft is never simple, and this year figures to give the Mets a crowded 40-man roster conversation. Gill Hills progress has put him in line for consideration, but with a large pool of eligible players and the risk of losing talent if the wrong calls are made, the club will have to decide which young arms are worth shielding and which ones are left exposed. [Read more 🡒]
Mets Still Have To Decide How Patient To Be With A.J. Ewing
A.J. Ewing has settled in as the Mets primary center fielder since the Luis Robert Jr. trade, and even as his bat has cooled, the team has kept finding ways to keep him in the lineup. The offensive dip has shown up since July, when the contact quality slipped and the strikeouts climbed, but New York has also seen why it was willing to keep investing in him: the defense in center remains steady enough to give him real value even on quieter nights at the plate.
The Mets have already tweaked where Ewing hits in the order, a sign they are trying to protect him while waiting for the offense to rebound. For now, management still views him as part of the clubs future, which leaves the bigger question hanging over the rest of the season: how long can they stay patient if the bat does not start to follow the glove? [Read more 🡒]