The Mets have plenty of unfinished business heading into the offseason, and two names sit right in the middle of it: Brett Baty and Mark Vientos.
Neither player has made a strong argument to lock down a long-term spot after a brutal 2026 season in Queens. The Mets entered the year with hopes that both former top prospects would help carry them, but that plan never really took off. Instead, they’ve been part of a nightmare campaign for a club with the second-highest payroll in baseball, one that has stumbled to a 63-77 record and already saw manager Carlos Mendoza get fired in June.
Baty’s situation is the easier one to read, at least for now. The Mets took him in the first round of the 2019 MLB Draft, but the relationship has not gone the way either side imagined. He is heading into his first year of arbitration this winter, and his 2026 line does not give the front office much certainty: .223/.293/.340 with a .634 OPS, eight home runs, 43 RBI and a 0.4 bWAR in 124 games.
That slump stands in sharp contrast to what he did in 2025, when he looked like he was turning a corner. Baty hit 18 home runs, drove in 50 RBI and posted a .748 OPS with a 3.0 bWAR across 130 games.
Even with the down year, one rival talent evaluator told me the Mets are likely to keep him in 2027 because he still has one minor league option left. There’s also the utility factor: Baty can handle third base, first base, second base and the corner outfield spots.
At the very least, that gives him a path to stick as a left-handed bat off the bench next season. For now, that versatility may be his best shot at one more chance in Queens.
Vientos is a tougher call. His stock looked much stronger after his breakout 2024, when he blasted 27 homers, posted 3.1 bWAR in 111 games and played a major role in the Mets reaching Game 6 of the NLCS. He also came up huge at the plate in that postseason run, finishing with 14 RBI.
That version of Vientos feels distant now. Since the start of the 2025 season, he has put up a -1.4 bWAR, and his defense - already a question mark - took another hit after he shifted to first base this year.
The rival evaluator I spoke with called the Mets’ offseason choice on Vientos a "coin flip" when it comes to whether they tender him a contract. Still, the lean was toward keeping him because of his power, upside and the fact that he remains under control through the 2029 season. The other side of the ledger is hard to ignore, though: he offers no real defensive value and would be coming off back-to-back poor seasons.
In Other News...
Mets Face An Offseason Debate Fans Have Been Dreading
The Mets are heading into the offseason with the kind of roster questions that tend to linger well past the first winter meetings rumor. Chelsea Janes of SNY said the front office may not be inclined to make sweeping changes, even as fan frustration grows over a group that still feels incomplete. Instead, the conversation appears likely to center on a handful of young players and whether the club sees enough reason to keep everyone in the fold.
Mark Vientos and Ronny Mauricio were mentioned as possible non-tender candidates, while Brett Baty could get another year to sort things out. At the same time, moving veterans with bigger contracts is never simple, which leaves the Mets looking at a market that may require creativity more than splash. For a team trying to get better without tearing everything down, that can make for a tricky winter and an even trickier set of decisions. [Read more 🡒]
Mets Just Drew A Clear Line Around Lindor And One Teammate
David Stearns made one thing plain this week: Francisco Lindor is staying right where the Mets want him. The team president said there is no question Lindor will be the everyday shortstop next season, a statement that cuts off any trade speculation and underscores how central Lindor remains to the clubs plans.
Jorge Polanco, by contrast, was left in a far less certain spot. Stearns did not lock in a defensive role for Polanco, calling that part of his status to be determined, which leaves open a real question about how the Mets will use him after an injury-hampered 2026 season that limited both his time in the field and his offensive impact. [Read more 🡒]
Brett Baty Is Running Out Of Chances With The Mets
Brett Batys season has settled into the kind of uneasy middle ground that does little to clarify his place with the Mets. He has flashed enough at times to remind the club why his bat and defensive flexibility still matter, but the overall offensive production has been too uneven for him to lock down a true everyday role.
What makes Batys situation more complicated is that his versatility has not translated into stability, and the Mets have other players forcing their way into the lineup. There have been signs of improvement lately, which at least keeps the conversation open, but the bigger question is whether those gains arrive soon enough to secure him a meaningful spot in the clubs plans. [Read more 🡒]