The Mets’ rotation puzzle has gotten messy fast, and Robert Stock doesn’t look like the answer for much longer.
After the club thinned out its pitching depth at the MLB trade deadline, the final opening in the rotation became a real problem. The team already tried a few different looks, and the results have been uneven.
Kodai Senga got another shot in the mix just before the Freddy Peralta trade, then delivered four scoreless innings before everything unraveled in the fifth. He gave up three runs, walked two, and never finished the frame.
The Mets shifted him into a relief role after that, and the move has worked better there. With Devin Williams out, Senga has even taken over as closer.
Stock got his chance two days later and made the most of it at first. He worked five innings, allowed one run, and struck out four batters.
That earned him another turn in the rotation, but the second outing was a disaster. Against the Pirates on Aug. 8, he gave up eight runs in just three innings.
Even after that, manager Andy Green told SNY reporters before Tuesday’s game that Stock will start again in the weekend series against the Nationals.
That’s where the Mets are now: committed to a 36-year-old starter who doesn’t really fit the long-term picture, while several internal arms could at least give them a better look at what’s coming next. Three names stand out.
Tobias Myers is one of them. The former Brewer came over in the Freddy Peralta deal, with the idea that he could be a long-term reliever who might also make the occasional spot start in the majors.
Instead, the role changes have been rough on him. He posted a 6.26 ERA across 26 appearances before the Mets sent him down to Triple-A.
The numbers there haven’t been much cleaner, but the club has kept stretching him out. Myers has a 5.40 ERA in nine minor league appearances, five of them starts, and his longest outing came on Aug. 8 when he threw 3.1 innings on 61 pitches.
He allowed three runs and walked two. Still, the case for giving him the ball in the rotation is pretty straightforward: he’s under team control through 2031, and the Mets need to know what they have in a pitcher who was once considered promising.
Jonah Tong is another possibility, though his path has been rockier. He’s already made five starts for the Mets in 2025 and went 2-3 with a 7.71 ERA. In 2026, the club used him in a short relief role, where he logged a 3.60 ERA in three outings.
Green laid out what the Mets want to see from Tong before another promotion: "I think we want to see ingredients that we believe will succeed on the field here," said Green when talking to SNY reporters about what the Mets want to potentially see from Tong before a promotion. "We want to put him in a place where he's going to be successful when he comes back."
Tong has logged the most starts in Triple-A, going 3-6 in 20 outings with a 5.32 ERA. The strikeouts are there - 109 of them - but so are the walks, with 53.
He was back in action Tuesday night after an outing in which he allowed five home runs. This time, he threw four innings, gave up one run, struck out six, and walked four.
For the Mets, starting Tong in the majors might not be the cleanest developmental move, but it would tell them something. Either he helps solve the immediate issue, or he serves as a loud reminder that the offseason still needs a true ace-level answer.
Jack Wenninger is in the same conversation. The Mets’ No. 9 prospect has also battled command issues, walking 53 batters in 91 innings, the most of his career. In 17 starts this season, he has a 4.43 ERA and a 1.43 WHIP.
There’s also a roster wrinkle here: Wenninger has to be added to the 40-man roster by November to avoid rule-five eligibility. A call-up would at least give the Mets a baseline on where he stands and what adjustments might be needed heading into 2027.
In Other News...
Mets Pitching Search May Be Centered On One Obvious Trade Target
David Stearns has already signaled that the Mets know more help is needed next season, even after keeping Francisco Lindor and Juan Soto in place. With the offense anchored and the front office still weighing broader roster changes, the clearest area of focus appears to be the pitching staff, where New York would love a cleaner, more reliable answer heading into 2026.
One name that keeps coming up is Minnesota right-hander Joe Ryan, whose profile fits the kind of search the Mets seem likely to make. An MLB writer pointed to Ryan as a possible fit, noting both his appeal and the Twins recent spending patterns as reasons his situation could warrant attention, which is the sort of setup that tends to put a pitcher squarely on a contenders radar. [Read more 🡒]
Mets Trade Deadline Return Already Faces Pressure To Pay Off Fast
The Mets used the trade deadline to make a low-risk move with a long-tail payoff, dealing Huascar Brazoban to the White Sox in exchange for two prospects who fit different timelines. Zach Franklin looks like the more advanced piece, the one closest to the majors and already on the radar as a Rule 5-eligible arm this winter, while Gabe Davis brings a deeper developmental project after uneven results in Double-A. For a team trying to keep building without losing sight of the present, it was the kind of swap that could look smart if even one side of it comes through.
The pressure, though, is already baked in because the return is being judged almost as soon as it lands. Franklins proximity gives the Mets a faster read on whether the deal can produce help, while Davis has a much longer road and will have to show real progress before this starts to feel like more than a depth gamble. The front office and everyone else watching this club know the window for calling it a win is not endless, with the deadline haul expected to justify itself before the end of 2026. [Read more 🡒]
Mets Could Be Drifting Back Toward A Familiar Rotation Gamble
Under David Stearns, the Mets have not been shy about chasing pitching with upside, even when the path comes with real risk. Thats the backdrop for their latest rotation conversation, as the club continues to weigh aggressive options while other contenders, like the Dodgers, have already made their own splash with Tarik Skubal.
One name that fits the Mets general appetite for talent is Kris Bubic, a left-hander who would add intrigue to their long-range plans. The appeal is obvious enough, but so is the uncertainty, since his health situation makes the timing murky and leaves the club with a familiar question: how much patience are they willing to buy into while shaping a rotation that is supposed to hold up down the line? [Read more 🡒]