Jonathan Santucci is starting to look like the kind of pitcher who can force the Mets to make room.
New York’s rotation has been a mess this season, but one possible answer for next year is already taking shape in the minors. Santucci, the Mets’ No. 2 prospect in their system according to MLB Pipeline, has put together a strong year built around one obvious weapon: he misses bats at a serious clip.
The 23-year-old left-hander has struck out 157 hitters in 119.2 innings, which is tied for the most strikeouts in minor league baseball. That kind of swing-and-miss production is hard to ignore, especially for a pitcher the Mets took in the second round of the 2024 MLB Draft out of Duke after selecting Carson Benge in the first round.
Across Double-A Binghamton and Triple-A Syracuse, Santucci has gone 4-10 in 26 starts with a 3.99 ERA, a 1.35 WHIP, and a .229 opponent batting average. The surface numbers are solid, but the more important story is that he’s been sharpening his four-pitch mix - a four-seam fastball, slider, curveball, and changeup - and the command has started to come with it.
That was especially clear in his latest start Wednesday. Santucci worked five innings, gave up five hits and one run, walked nobody, and struck out six on 67 pitches. He also generated 14 swing-and-misses, threw 73.7% first-pitch strikes, and allowed just two hard-hit balls, according to Joe DeMayo of The Mets Pod.
After a rough adjustment when he moved up to Triple-A Syracuse, Santucci has begun to settle in. Over his last three starts, he has posted a 3.00 ERA in 15 innings, struck out 19, and issued only two walks.
That kind of stretch matters because the Mets’ rotation picture for next season is wide open behind the top names. As things stand, Nolan McLean and Christian Scott are the only starters locked into spots.
Sean Manaea is expected to have a role, whether that ends up being in the rotation or as a bulk reliever, while rookie lefty Zac Thornton has impressed in his first major league run with a 3.53 ERA in 66.1 innings and could be in the mix to open the year. Jonah Tong, who recently returned to the majors, is also expected to play a key role.
Even so, none of those arms has clearly separated as a true ace, which is why the Mets are expected to shop the market too, with Tarik Skubal potentially becoming their top free-agent target.
That creates a crowded race for five rotation spots, and it could make a straight path to the Opening Day roster tough for Santucci. But the modern game doesn’t exactly reward durability the way it used to. Starters are throwing fewer innings, injuries keep opening doors, and the Mets have already used 15 different pitchers to start a game this season.
So while Santucci may not be the obvious favorite to break camp, he’s clearly putting himself in position to be one of the first names called when the Mets need help. If the command keeps improving, his stuff may end up demanding the opportunity sooner rather than later.
In Other News...
Mets First Base Problem Is Starting To Point In One Direction
The Mets are already looking ahead to 2027 with first base on the list of places that could use a reset. Last offseasons attempt to solve the position with Jorge Polanco never really got off the ground, with injuries limiting his time and leaving the club without much clarity about what the long-term answer should be.
Jake Bauers has started to emerge as a name worth watching in that search. Bleacher Report floated the Brewers first baseman as a possible target, and his strong season could put him on the market if he reaches free agency, giving the Mets another avenue to explore as they keep sorting out a spot that has not settled into place. [Read more 🡒]
Jacob deGrom Just Put Mets Fans Through A Familiar Misery Again
Jacob deGrom keeps producing the kind of outings that should feel automatic for a win, only for the result to turn into something all too familiar for Mets fans. In a recent start, he delivered six scoreless innings with 12 strikeouts and no walks, part of a stretch that included his second one-hitter in three games, yet the team still came away empty after another night in which his work on the mound was not matched by enough help elsewhere.
OptaSTATS noted just how unusual the loss was, saying deGrom is the only modern-era MLB pitcher to finish a scoreless start with 12 or more strikeouts and no walks, leave with a lead of three or more runs, and still wind up taking the loss. It fit a pattern Mets followers know too well, with this latest game joining a list of other strong deGrom performances that were wasted when the offense could not turn dominance into comfort. [Read more 🡒]
Rays May Have Found Another Pitching Fix With Freddy Peralta
The Rays took Freddy Peralta from the Mets knowing full well he was more project than finished product, and theyve already started to get a return on that gamble. Under pitching coach Kyle Snyder, Peralta has worked through changes in both his delivery and pitch mix, with the changeup emerging as a much more useful weapon as he has settled in over his recent outings.
In his last three starts, the right-hander has looked far more like a pitcher with a path forward than one still searching for answers, allowing just two runs and one walk over 18 innings. For a Tampa Bay staff that has long made its reputation on finding fixes others miss, Peraltas early progress is another reminder of how quickly the Rays can turn a reclamation case into something more interesting. [Read more 🡒]